North Carolina DPI Releases Draft Healthful Living Standards | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Kaitlyn Shepherd.

    The North Carolina Department of Public Instruction (DPI) has finally unveiled the first draft of proposed revisions to the state's Healthful Living Standards, which encompass both Physical and Health Education.

    The draft has been a long time coming. It was originally scheduled to be made public in August 2022, but the State Board of Education (SBE) then approved a six-month delay. During the February 2023 meeting - and during several meetings after that - DPI staff explained to the SBE that the standards writing team was still preparing the first version. At long last, DPI representatives presented the draft yesterday.

    While a cursory review of the draft standards show they appear fairly innocuous, additional information and careful scrutiny is needed to determine the value and impact of the proposed standards.

    Content standards represent "what students should know and be able to do" after completing each grade level or course. As the John Locke Foundation has previously observed, "In general, standards are grade- and subject-specific outlines of the content, concepts, and skills that state education officials expect all educators to cover during the academic year." Districts and teachers must align their lessons with state standards, but they can choose the curriculum and instructional methods used to achieve the objectives prescribed in the standards.

    The delay in releasing the initial draft of the Healthful Living Standards raised questions about the extent to which the standards would depart from biological truths about sex and promote instruction about transgenderism and gender identity to kids. A read-through of the proposed Health Standards reveals no specific mention or reference to sexual orientation or gender identity.

    In places, the proposed standards promote the benefits of abstinence. For example, as part of the content on interpersonal communication and healthy relationships, seventh graders would be expected to "[e]xplain the physical, social and emotional benefits of choosing to delay sexual activity (abstinence) for young people" (p. 18). Explaining the various risks of underage sexual activity is laudable, but the standards undermine themselves in other places. Eighth graders, for example, would be asked to "[e]xplain how avoiding sexual activity (abstinence) is the most effective way to avoid pregnancy and STIs," but they would also be tasked with evaluating the effectiveness of FDA-approved contraceptives (p. 21).

    Although the draft standards seem to promote healthy behaviors overall, the devil is often in the details, and important questions remain.

    During their presentation on Wednesday, DPI staff mentioned that the standards for both Physical and Health Education would incorporate elements of Social-Emotional Learning (SEL), possibly including instruction on the five core competencies promoted by the Collaborative for Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning (CASEL), one of SEL's biggest proponents. This is problematic. SEL is often a vehicle to import the harmful tenets behind critical race theory and gender ideology into classrooms, and critics have raised the alarm about how SEL programs threaten students' psychological development, violate their privacy, and aim to "mold children into the type of human being the government deems most useful to the economy, society, and the state." A review of future drafts of the standards and associated supplemental materials will be required to determine the extent to which these ideas have been woven into them.


    The DPI will solicit feedback on the draft standards from stakeholders and the public until September. At that point, a data review committee will review the comments and make recommendations, and a standards writing team will create a second draft.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

NCGOP convention draws presidential primary frontrunners to make their case Educational Realities, Educating our People, NativeFront, Statewide, John Locke Foundation Guest Editorial, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal What Are “Stranded” Credits?


Latest State and Federal

The state Supreme Court will not bypass an intermediate court's consideration of two parents' lawsuit against a Charlotte private school. Doug and Nicole Turpin accuse Charlotte Latin of expelling their children to retaliate against criticism of changes in the school's focus.
NBC sketch-show “Saturday Night Live” delivered a series of comedic slaps to an increasingly gaffe-prone President Joe Biden, focusing on his recent conversation with Chinese President Xi Jinping in California.
Elon Musk‘s SpaceX made headway in the second test flight of its Starship rocket despite the demo on Saturday ending with explosions.
Comedian and HBO host Bill Maher told former Democratic National Committee chair Donna Brazile that he couldn’t see President Joe Biden winning a second term in the White House.
House Intelligence Committee Chairman Mike Turner (R-OH) said over the weekend that the terrorist threat to the U.S. is the highest that it’s been in over a decade following Hamas’ attack on Israel last month.
Texas Governor Greg Abbott endorsed former President Donald Trump for a second term as president on Sunday during a campaign event in Edinburg, a city about 30 miles away from the Mexico border.


CNN’s Jake Tapper made false claims over the weekend about remarks that X owner Elon Musk made on the social media platform last week.
Rosalynn Carter, the wife of former President Jimmy Carter, died “peacefully” on Sunday afternoon at their home in Plains, Georgia, accompanied by family, according to the Carter Center.
State Supreme Court Justice Michael Morgan's final opinion day featured a 183-page opinion defending a death penalty verdict, a dissent in a castle doctrine case, and a vote with Republican colleagues to fight back environnentalists' challenge of a mining quarry's state permit.
Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) said on Sunday that she would try again to get Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas impeached after the House punted on her latest effort last week.
Yet another arm of the Democratic Party got rattled by nearly 1,000 anti-Israel protesters at a convention held in Sacramento, California, on Saturday.
CNN faced backlash this week after it published an article that sought to cast doubt on footage the the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) released of weapons that it found inside Al-Shifa hospital after special forces commandos raided the Hamas-controlled hospital.


The North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services today announced historic Medicaid reimbursement rate increases will soon be implemented for most mental health, substance use, intellectual and developmental disabilities and traumatic brain injury services in North Carolina.


Back to Top