NCInnovation Raises Serious Transparency Concerns | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of The James G. Martin Center. The author of this post is Jenna A. Robinson.

    Earlier this month, the usually frugal North Carolina Senate surprised pundits by including $1.425 billion for NCInnovation in its budget proposal, considerably more than the $50 million allocated earlier this year by the N.C. House. NCInnovation is a non-profit organization established by N.C. business and education leaders, intended to support the commercialization of university research and development. The Raleigh News & Observer describes the public-private partnership thusly: "NCInnovation aspires to create a massive endowment to help researchers at UNC System schools convert their ideas into revenue-generating businesses."

    NCInnovation promises to make North Carolina "THE Innovation State." It counts accountability among its key values, stating on its website, "We will hold ourselves and our partners accountable for measurable results."

    But there are problems with that promise. NCInnovation lacks some essential oversight mechanisms. Unlike other university units, it does not report to the UNC Board of Governors but to its own board. It is also exempt from North Carolina's open meetings and public records laws. John Locke Foundation president Donald Bryson pointed out in Carolina Journal why such oversight is essential:

    Open meetings and open records laws for organizations receiving funding from state governments are critical in maintaining transparency and accountability. They allow citizens to track the decision-making process of state-funded organizations and hold them accountable for their actions. These laws create transparency and accountability and mitigate the risk of fraud, waste, and abuse. If state lawmakers appoint 62% (eight of 13) of the board of directors, and taxpayers are providing $1.4 billion as an endowment, then citizens deserve to know what is happening with their hard-earned money.

    The lack of transparency surrounding NCInnovation follows a pattern for public-private partnerships involving UNC institutions. As the Martin Center has pointed out before, a large portion of university real-estate transactions fall outside traditional board oversight because they are controlled by university foundations instead of the universities themselves. As Shannon Watkins wrote in 2018,

    Within the UNC System alone, there are 58 foundations-all of which are, according to UNC-System lawyer Tom Shanahan, "distinct legal entities separate from the university." As such, university foundations are not only exempt from the Umstead Act, but they are also not subject to public records laws or the governing authority of the Board of Governors.

    The Umstead Act is state legislation intended to prevent government entities from competing unfairly with private businesses.

    Concerns have also been raised about Project Kitty Hawk, a nonprofit ed-tech startup that will partner with UNC-System universities to serve adult learners. Unlike members of the UNC Board of Governors, Project Kitty Hawk board members are not required to file statements of economic interest. As the Martin Center wrote last year,

    Such statements are required by law for all parties who are subject to the State Ethics Act, including legislators and members of the UNC Board of Governors as well as members of various planning organizations and advisory committees. They are not currently required for members of "associated entities," including Project Kitty Hawk.

    As a 501(c)(3) organization, NCInnovation will also be exempt from the State Ethics Act and the Umstead Act, despite the large amount of public funding it will receive. Taxpayers deserve more oversight and better accountability from their public investments.

    Jenna A. Robinson is the president of the James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Polls Reveal What Parents, School Board Members Think about Teachers James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Oscar-Winning Actor Alan Arkin Dead At 89


Latest State and Federal

A judge in Colorado has rejected a challenge filed by a Left-leaning group to remove former President Donald Trump from the state’s 2024 presidential primary ballot under the 14th Amendment.
The Republican-controlled Texas House of Representatives voted to reject a school choice measure on Friday, drawing the ire of Republican Governor Greg Abbott.
Former police officer Derek Chauvin was charged with yet another appalling atrocity today after allegedly assaulting a fellow inmate's shiv with his body while serving time for the 2020 death of George Floyd.
X owner Elon Musk said on Saturday that he would be filing a lawsuit against leftist outlet Media Matters for America over a story it ran this week that he said was misleading and intended to undermine free speech.
Lee County Sheriff Brian Estes is asking a federal judge to dismiss him as a defendant in a lawsuit challenging the rollout of North Carolina's eCourts record management system.
One of New Jersey’s main teachers unions is calling for the end of the basic skills test for certifying teachers.
Jewish celebrities blasted TikTok after a surge of viral anti-Semitic content on the platform surfaced following the Hamas terrorists attacks on Israel that resulted in the deaths of more than 1,200 people.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis attacked tech executives this week for “groveling” to Chinese communist dictator Xi Jinping this week as he appeared in San Francisco for a meeting with President Joe Biden and California Governor Gavin Newsom.
A newly released poll that was conducted at the start of the month by the Arab World for Research and Development found that the overwhelming majority of Palestinians supported the October 7 terrorist attacks against Israel and hate the United States.


North Carolina Supreme Court Justice Anita Earls has recently filed a lawsuit against the North Carolina Judicial Standards Commission, alleging the commission has aimed to stifle her First Amendment right to freedom of speech.
The GOP-led House began on Friday to release tens of thousands of hours of video footage from January 6, 2021 — the day of the U.S. Capitol breach — to the public.
A former Fox News producer is suing the network, saying it fired him due to his “refusal to report false information,” such as concerns about harmful effects of COVID vaccines.
Arizona State University canceled an event that the school was set to host on Friday featuring Rep. Rashida Tlaib (D-MI), which comes after she openly expressed support for the elimination of the state of Israel.
A teacher at an Illinois high school sought to exclude students who allegedly opposed the school’s transgender bathroom policy from meetings of the school’s “Diversity” club.
The four-part training will be administered by a diversity consulting firm that embraces Critical Race Theory
Felon voting advocates in North Carolina seek a hearing before US District Judge Loretta Biggs and an expedited schedule for their federal lawsuit.
Republican senators are questioning the IRS about its audit of a watchdog organization that has released reports on multiple Biden nominees to key federal positions.


Back to Top