Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutActually van ZANt, he didn't. Why?
He views, (to use his term) 'objective history", through his lens and his experience. Anything outside his experience he deems slanted history or propaganda. In America, white people do this all time. they often assume their version of "history" is objective (it isn't) and therefore more true and relevant than the historical perspectives of other people and cultures (they aren't). For that to be true, it would mean we all experience the world in the exact same way. Utter nonsense, right? CV has a right to his world view. We all do. The question is, should we consider history from more than one point of view.? Cv says no. I say yes. That, in a nut shell is why his explanation is piss poor. Now if you believe it's possible to have a monopoly on the truth, as CV does, it offers the comfort of a safe space to marginalize a large segment of the population. What gives anyone the right to do that?
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 10:58 pm
By: Big Bob
|
|
Under DEI, the one who checks the most boxes gets the job. For an FAA air traffic controller under Biden that would be a blind one-armed paralyzed pyscho dwarf who is a lesbian and member of a minority group. Is that who you really want directing airplanes where to go at an airport? For me, I will take the most qualified person, not who checks the most DEI boxes.
Commented: Thursday, May 2nd, 2024 @ 7:36 am
By: Rino Hunter
|
|
Just wanted to say that I love your content. Keep up the good work.
My friend Jordan from Thailand Nomads recommended your website to me. Cheers, Virginia
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 6:57 pm
By: Virginia Hamlin
|
|
Based on your posts, I respectfully disagree.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 9:19 pm
By: Big Bob
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutCV did a real good job of explaining the way history is approached by people and societies. That used to be taught in University History Department graduate courses (don't know about these days of wokeness).
A good number of commenters on this thread have displayed a strong background and understanding of history. With all due respect, the far-left troll is a bit over his head here. To his credit, he is trying. I suspect he could learn a great deal from this experience if he weren't such an idealogue. Fanatics often times are hindered by their zealotry in the pursuit of learning. Hate is also an unfortunate obstacle. Passion is good. Hate is poison. It is too bad what is happening at West Point. A healthy society builds on its history and tradition. These days we are not a healthy society, and these types of things are indicative of our decline. If we do not rebound, I hate to think of what may become of us.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 8:38 pm
By: Van Zant
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutHistory can be told as 1) objective history, 2) slanted history that ignores inconvenient facts and glosses over things with generalizations, or 3) all out historical propaganda. Communist countries are noted for the last version, and that is certainly what one would get in communist Vietnam. The ideal standard for history in a democracy is objective history.
A slogan widely used by the communists has been "history is on our side" and the modern American far left has revised that slogan to become "the right side of history". Communists when they are in power constantly try to destroy and rewrite history. Chairman Mao's Cultural Revolution is a prime example and one that seems to be the concept behand the American and European far left's cancel culture. A good example of objective history is compare what a modern German student learns about World War II and what an American student learns. There is very little difference because both countries are democratic and, at least for now, tend to look at history objectively. George Orwell has written extensively about how totalitarian regimes try to rewrite history in their drive to control the present and future. We are now seeing some of the things Orwell predicted being advanced by the far left in American and in Europe. The middle point is slanted history, which sticks to facts but relies on selective facts to skew interpretations. A good example is the history of the War Between the States. Those writing from a northern perspective will leave out things like the Corwin Amendment and the Fremont Affair which call into question the basic northern narrative about the war and are therefore memory-holed. Similarly, there are things that one writing from a southern perspective would gloss over. Mildly slanted history is not so bad as the heavily slanted history that borders on pure propaganda. I prefer objective history, but mildly slanted history is readable if one recognizes the slant they are being presented with. When one gets to some of the left's distorted history like the 1619 Project, its authors are writing through a prism, not a lens.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 5:01 pm
By: Conservative Voter
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutCV fails to see that History is told through a lens.
Example: Lets say two people want to learn about the Vietnam war. One American living in the US One Vietnamese living in Ho Chi Minh City Does any one think these two will learn the same history of events and/or lessons from that war? Same war. But 2 perspectives. Is one right, and the other wrong. No Are both perspectives worth hearing about? Yes. Clear as a bell.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 2:30 pm
By: Big Bob
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutSaid the white man.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 2:21 pm
By: Big Bob
|
|
So, a total of $4 Billion dollars we don't have and will have to borrow goes to beinging in migrants we don't need and particularly in the case of the Gazans, should not want. That does not include all the resettlement benefits that will be lavished on those Gazan migrants at taxpayer expense. These provisions of that bill are a betrayal of the American taxpayer, and Mike Johnson has shown himself to be little more than a pathetic pawn of the big spending Democrats. He is worse than shifty McCarthy.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 1:28 pm
By: Concerned Taxpayer
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutThere is no "white history" or "black history". There is simply only history.
Confederate history is also the history of many ethnic groups, like the highest ranking minority to serve in the war on either side, Confederate General Stand Watie, whose statue has been attacked by BLM/ANTIFA thugs. I would point out that the Yankees, in contrast, did not even let minorities serve as officers at any rank. Confederate heroes who distinguished themselves in battle include Moses Dallas, a black Confederate naval officer, who was instrumental in planning and helped lead one of the most daring exploits of the war, the capture of the Union warship USS Waterwitch while she was on blockade duty off Savannah in a surprise nighttime attack boarding from small boats. When the far left tries to cancel Confederate history, people like Watie and Dallas are among those they cancel. That is also true of Confederate political history, where Judah P. Benjamin of Louisiana became the first person of the Jewish religion to hold cabinet rank in a government this side of the Atlantic. Benjamin served in the cabinet of President Jefferson Davis throughout the war, successively as Secretary of State, Attorney General, and Secretary of War.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 12:25 pm
By: Conservative Voter
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutAgain your take away is has got you twisted all up. You favor only white history and resent any other perspective.
There are many others stories out there. We should be willing to hear them.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 11:55 am
By: Big Bob
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutWe should never forget that it was RINO Greg Murphy who voted for the bill that led to this Maoist Cultural Revolution style attack on our history, including making Fort Bragg no longer Fort Bragg. "Cancel culture" Murphy needs to GO.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 11:54 am
By: Rino Hunter
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutBobbie never seems to let us forget that he hates whites and males, especially white males, and even more so if they are straight white males or Christian white males. That is the mark of today's "woke" brand of racism.
I would think a portrayal of Robert E. Lee, a man who wrote in 1859 that "slavery is an institution of moral and political evil" and who freed the hundreds of slaves he inherited from his father-in-law as soon as he closed the estate would be more acceptable to any black cadet who understood history than a portrayal of U. S. Grant who was still a slaveowner when the War Between the States ended and actually remained a slave owner until the end of 1865 when the 13th Amendment finally freed the Grant family slaves.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 11:48 am
By: Rino Hunter
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutThe modern-day cultural revolution purge going on throughout all of western civilization must end. Rational people must stand up and stop this insanity.
History is a rich tapestry of human stories. Totalitarian attempts to sanitize it to their own standards or to cancel it entirely only destroy it. When we stop building on our history, we stop enriching our culture. We ultimately commit cultural suicide. This attack on West Point history and tradition is awful. People are now even considering taking down reconciliation monuments. Think about what that means. Lately, in many countries people have destroyed monuments to James Cook of all people. Cook mapped more of the world than anyone. His voyages catalogued thousands of plants and animals and contributed greatly to mankind. During our own war for independence against Britian, Benjamin Franklin wrote to captains of colonial warships, recommending that if they came into contact with Cook's vessel (a British vessel), they were to "not consider her an enemy, nor suffer any plunder to be made of the effects contained in her...but that they treat the said Captain Cook with all the civility and kindness...as common friends to mankind." Cook's work was that important to the human race, and he gave his life to make those contributions. Now in today's hate filled world, he is made to be a supposed villain to be erased from history. As for me, no thank you to that totalitarian nightmarish vision of the world. Madness such as this must be opposed.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 10:10 am
By: Charles Hickman
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutGrow up, Bobbie. When you run out of even your distorted facts in an argument, it should not be time to turn to personal attacks. Go take a puberty blocker or something.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 10:05 am
By: Conservative Voter
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutThe white male president in the 1950's admired Robert E Lee. A real shocker.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 9:48 am
By: Big Bob
|
|
Well, NO, Jim Crow is on YOU. It was your party, the Democrats, who proposed it and all voted for it. My party, the Republicans voted AGAINST Jim Crow. That is the actual historical record that you want to sweep under the rug. Own it, Bobbie, Jim Crow is YOURS.
As far as air traffic controllers, you were the one who brought up the year 1776 in reference to them. Regardless of the year, air traffic controllers are FEDERAL jobs, dumbass, and state Jim Crow laws did not apply to federal jobs at any time. And the issue of the present DEI problem with air traffic controllers never had anything to do with race in the first place. It has to do with Biden giving DEI preference to these categories: Hearing (total deafness in both ears) Vision (Blind) Missing Extremities Partial Paralysis Complete Paralysis, Epilepsy Severe intellectual disability Psychiatric disability Dwarfism
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 9:53 am
By: John Steed
|
|
How can you possibly forget that up until the 1950's the hiring preference in this country favored white men? Every idiot knows this to be true. I notice you often twist up the smallest of details to in an effort to justify your own ignorance while completely missing the point.
Unlike salvery - Jim Crow is on us.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 9:42 am
By: Big Bob
|
|
Here we go again with Bigot Bob's fractured history. We are talking about racial preference hiring at the FAA for air traffic controllers, and now Bob claims that only white men could get jobs as air traffic controllers IN 1776! What aircraft were flying then, Bob?
But then, that is just one of his dodges to claim the FAA issue is all about race. I listed the DEI categories Biden is trying to hire for FAA and NONE of them have anything to do with race. But Bigot Bob is never going to admit he was factually wrong in trying to inject race into this issue. With Bobbie's tunnel vision, everything is about race to him.
Commented: Wednesday, May 1st, 2024 @ 9:27 am
By: John Steed
|
Commented on West Point Begins Removing Confederate Monuments From Campus; Robert E. Lee Portrait And Bust Cleared OutCV- I have zero respect for you.
go shoot a dog
Commented: Tuesday, April 30th, 2024 @ 9:01 pm
By: Big Bob
|
|
knock your self out. we may both learn new things
Commented: Tuesday, April 30th, 2024 @ 8:43 pm
By: Big Bob
|
|
No, it started in 1776 when only white men could get a paid job. Good lord. What a stuipis post.
Commented: Tuesday, April 30th, 2024 @ 8:40 pm
By: Big Bob
|
|
Right on. Most young people dont even know what real food is.
Commented: Tuesday, April 30th, 2024 @ 8:38 pm
By: Big Bob
|