Attorney: Libel Lawsuit Could Be Attempt To Protect Crime Lab, DOJ | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's note: The author of this post is Dan Way, who is an Associate Editor for the Carolina Journal, John Hood Publisher.

First Amendment lawyer Bussian suggests case against N&O actually sought to block critical coverage of crime lab's failures


    A lawyer defending the News & Observer of Raleigh against a libel suit filed by a State Bureau of Investigation special agent suggested in court Wednesday that the case actually might be an attempt by the state to protect the image of the Department of Justice and State Crime Lab that were under the management of Attorney General Roy Cooper.

    "This lawsuit is really being driven not about a recovery for damages" by plaintiff Beth Desmond, who claims the newspaper libeled her with false reporting about her testimony at two trials related to a 2005 Pitt County murder, "but by a need for political damage control," John Bussian told Wake County Superior Court Judge Graham Shirley.

    Desmond was a firearms examiner in the State Crime Lab, whose various divisions were beset with slipshod work. The N&O ran a four-part investigative series in August 2010 chronicling the problems, growing questions about the accuracy of forensic sciences, and the implications for the administration of justice.

    Bussian suggested to Shirley that there were officials who wanted to cover for the state Department of Justice and the crime lab, "right down to concealing" the existence of an inspection report by the American Society of Crime Laboratory Directors/Laboratory Accreditation Board, a national accreditation agency that found major problems in the North Carolina crime lab.

    Among those findings were questions about Desmond's lab work on bullets from the Pitt County case, and testifying with "absolute certainty" at trial they were fired from the same type of gun even though her lab report said they could have been shot from other models of guns.

    Bussian and fellow defense attorney Mark Prak contend Desmond's absolute certainty claim deprived the Pitt County murder suspect of his defense that a second shooter fired the fatal shot.

    "To say 'I'm absolutely certain' is something no reasonable, reputable firearms examiner could or should do," Prak said. "They're putting their finger on the scales of justice."

    Bussian's oral argument echoed his July 29 written motion for reconsideration to admit the ASCLD/LAB report into evidence to bolster a constitutional press protection that truth is a defense in a defamation lawsuit.

    "The report is an important element of defendants' proof that Agent Desmond's lawsuit is, in fact, motivated by a desire to deter the press - if not silence it altogether - from reporting accusations of serious misconduct" by the crime lab, the motion stated.

    The report's findings would show Desmond's analysis and testimony in the Pitt County cases "created the impetus" for DOJ and SBI to conceal the report from the public and press, and with Desmond wage a concerted effort at political damage control through the lawsuit, Bussian wrote.

    DOJ issued "a lengthy series of press releases that touted the supposedly positive results of various internal and external 'reviews' of the Crime Lab" while avoiding mention of unfavorable evaluations, including the ASCLD/LAB inspection and report, Bussian wrote.

    At the same time, the court filing said, crime lab, SBI, and DOJ personnel "encouraged the pursuit of a lawsuit" ostensibly to clear Desmond's name, but designed to exonerate the lab and SBI from the criticisms in the N&O series. Jerry Richardson, the crime lab assistant director at the time, paid $100 to a web page financially supporting Desmond's lawsuit.

    "I think it would be difficult for anyone to deny the problems that existed" in the crime lab, Shirley said. "But to argue that this is damage control for that" might be a tough sell to a jury.

    Shirley did not rule on the matter Wednesday, and said he likely would not before the trial starts the week of Sept. 26. Instead, rulings on the admissibility of disputed evidence and witnesses might occur "as things are known" at trial, Shirley said.

    He told lawyers for both sides he was "going to do my best to keep that door closed" to a long stream of trial witnesses, in his words "to protect the jury from hearing a lot of irrelevant stuff."
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




Hillary Clinton’s True Legacy: Witness Tampering and Money Laundering Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics NCGOP Statement On Hillary Clinton's Economic Speech


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Vice President Kamala Harris will visit a Minnesota Planned Parenthood clinic, reportedly the first time a president or vice president has visited an abortion facility.
University of Wisconsin tried to punish conservatives for the fact that liberals regularly commit crimes to silence opposition
most voters think EU officials not doing a good job on illegal immigration
Be careful what you wish for, you may get it
Come from behind by GOP candidate is a blueprint to 2024

HbAD1

Biden spending and energy policies to blame
Tuberculosis carried by illegal invaders has already infected Texas cattle
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) said this week that the only campaign promise President Joe Biden has delivered on as president is the complete dismantling of the U.S. southern border.
Hamas is reeling after losing two of their most cherished leaders on the same day: military commander Saleh al-Arouri, and Harvard President Claudine Gay.
President Joe Biden’s brother told the Internal Revenue Service that Hunter Biden told him he was in business with a “protege of President Xi,” referring to the leader of China, according to notes by an IRS investigator that were divulged during a congressional interview of Jim Biden.
Gov. Roy Cooper seeks a temporary restraining order to block a law changing the composition of the State Board of Elections.

HbAD2

X owner Elon Musk mocked a news segment from ABC News this week that promoted President Joe Biden’s talking points about the Democrat-led Senate’s failed border bill, which critics and many experts have said would make the situation on the border worse.

HbAD3

 
Back to Top