Court Delays Candidate Filing, Stretching Redistricting Drama a Couple More Weeks | Eastern North Carolina Now

Publisher's note: This post, by Andy Jackson, was originally published in Civitas's online edition.

    Candidate filing in North Carolina starts on December 2, but one group of candidates will not be able to file that day. A court order issued yesterday means that congressional candidates don't know if they will be able to file the next day or sometime in 2020.

    The same NC Superior Court judges that effectively threw out North Carolina's congressional districts in a preliminary injunction in Harper v Lewis ordered a hold on congressional candidate filing. Instead, the court will hear several motions related to that hearing at 9:00 AM on December 2:

  1. Plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment (a ruling without the need for a trial) against the previous maps. It is hard to imagine the court not dismissing this motion. The old districts are no longer in use and the court would have to pretend that the current districts do not exist in order to rule on the old ones. If the court did grant this motion, candidate filing would be delayed for several weeks as the General Assembly draws yet another set of districts and the court reviews them. Congressional primaries will be delayed.
  2. Legislative Defendants' motion for summary judgment to dismiss the suit in Harper v Lewis because the drawing of new congressional districts makes the lawsuit moot. This is the most likely outcome since the new districts are different from old districts and the procedure for drawing the new districts was different than the procedure for drawing the old districts; you cannot get much more moot than that. If the court grants this motion, candidates can file as early as December 3 and the primaries will not be delayed.
  3. Plaintiffs' motion for review of the new districts passed by the General Assembly. The court did not order new districts in its preliminary injunction (only suggesting that the General Assembly do so on its own accord). Given that the new districts and the procedures used to draw them are different from what the plaintiffs presented to the court, a review of the new districts would likely take at least several weeks, perhaps delaying candidate filing for months.

    After the Harper v Lewis preliminary injunction that threw out the previous congressional districts, the General Assembly moved quickly to enact new districts. Those districts will likely result in an 8-5 split in favor of Republicans in most elections, a split that fits North Carolina's political geography.

    If the court grants either of the plaintiff's motions, that judicial overreach would likely force the state to conduct special primaries for contested congressional races, reducing voter turnout and costing the state millions of dollars, a detriment to North Carolina voters and taxpayers.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Thanks Largely to Expansion, Medicaid Fraud Likely to Exceed $75 Billion Civitas Institute, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Why the Bible Warns Us Against the ‘Uncertainty of Riches’


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Researchers with the U.S. Food & Drug Administration have determined that cereal reaches its peak flavor at 10 pm if eaten on the couch while watching a true crime documentary.
Congressman Jim Banks (R-IN) wants to make federal buildings beautiful again. Well, what he really wants to do is cement a Trump-era executive order into law requiring “classical architecture” on all new buildings to make that happen.
RALEIGH: Today, Governor Roy Cooper joined the North Carolina Reproductive Freedom Coalition at a rally for health care freedom.
The Statue of Liberty was surrounded by an orange haze on Tuesday as New Yorkers were tormented by smoke coming from Canadian wildfires that started June 2 in Nova Scotia and Quebec.
The University of North Carolina System says it could face a "massive liability" if students from UNC Chapel Hill and N.C. State University win their lawsuit over challenged student fees. The dispute sits at the N.C. Supreme Court.
Twitter CEO Elon Musk revealed on Tuesday that his team has managed to significantly increase efficiency at the social media company since he purchased the firm six months ago.
Gov. Ron DeSantis signed an executive order Friday to prevent Link, the hero of Hyrule, from wearing the female clothing of the Gerudo people.
While many people have heard of Judeo-Christian values, Dennis Prager believes few can articulate them, which he laments, because, in his words, “Judeo-Christian values are the moral foundation of Western Civilization.”
Washington, D.C. – Today, Rep. Greg Murphy, M.D. released the following statement after reports from Fox News revealed the identity of the University of Pennsylvania (UPenn) donors having relationships with both the Chinese Communist Party and Hunter Biden’s business deals.


Two key documents cautioning U.S. officials about a deteriorating security situation in Afghanistan before withdrawing in 2021 revealed President Joe Biden’s administration failed to heed specific warnings, a top House Republican said.
Lawmakers in the North Carolina House passed a bill Wednesday that would streamline the process of approving new charter schools in the state. The vote was 75-42, with four Democrats joining Republicans in supporting the measure.
Enrollment for most forms of postsecondary education in the United States continued to decline three years after nationwide lockdowns forced many students to temporarily continue their degrees online, according to a new analysis from the National Student Clearinghouse.
The advances in artificial intelligence over the past couple of years might very well turn out to be a watershed moment in history.
The Federal Trade Commission launched an inquiry on Wednesday into the baby formula shortages which have harmed infants and strained their parents over the past several months.
An unfolding legal saga at the UNC-System institution may expose dramatic threats to free speech.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has officially entered the 2024 presidential race.
Rep. Tricia Cotham (R-Mecklenburg) released the following statement following the N.C. General Assembly's successful override of Governor Cooper's veto of SB 20, the Care for Women, Children, and Families Act:
Actor Josh Duhamel (“Transformers“) admitted in a recent interview that he has become a bit of a “doomsday prepper,” building a remote compound in North Dakota where his family could survive “if s*** hits the fan” in Los Angeles.


House and Senate lawmakers have reportedly come to a deal to avoid defaulting on the national debt by raising the debt ceiling to infinity million billion +1.
Most Americans favor cutting spending alongside raising the debt ceiling as President Joe Biden and House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) negotiate a deal to avert a U.S. default, according to a recent survey.
The North Carolina General Assembly is set to take up the veto override of SB20, the Care for Women, Children, and Families Act, much to the chagrin of Gov. Roy Cooper, who has conducted a pressure campaign in an attempt to swing legislators.
The Black Lives Matter’s Global Network Foundation, which has reportedly paid some of its official and unofficial chapters millions of dollars, appears to be risking bankruptcy.
Appearing before the Senate beneath a mysterious, hooded robe, California Senator Diane Feinstein addressed the hushed audience, speaking in a gravelly, Sidious-like voice.
Senator Tim Scott (R-S.C.) fired back at “The View” on Tuesday after several of the ABC show’s liberal co-hosts leveled racially-charged attacks against him.
A senior FBI official stunned GOP members of Congress on Tuesday upon testifying that she has not read or even been briefed on special counsel John Durham‘s report.
A mysterious new virus is forcing millions of people around the world to call in sick to work today, according to sources.
Pop culture and fashion magazine Vanity Fair raised eyebrows with a Tuesday headline comparing Twitter owner Elon Musk with former KKK Grand Wizard David Duke – all in an effort to undermine Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis ahead of his 2024 presidential bid.


Back to Top