Unanimous N.C. Appeals Court Panel Bans Voter ID Indefinitely | Beaufort County Now | A unanimous, all-Democrat N.C. Appeals Court panel has decided to block voter ID in North Carolina indefinitely. | john locke foundation, appeals court, voter ID, ban, february 18, 2020

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Unanimous N.C. Appeals Court Panel Bans Voter ID Indefinitely

Publisher's note: The author of this post is Mitch Kokai for the John Locke Foundation.

    A unanimous, all-Democrat N.C. Appeals Court panel has decided to block voter ID in North Carolina indefinitely.

    A federal court already had blocked voter identification for the March 3 primary election. The state Appeals Court's decision means voter ID will not be used - if at all - until after a full trial on the merits of a challenge to North Carolina's voter ID law in state court.

    Judges Toby Hampson, John Arrowood, and Allegra Collins reversed a decision from a lower three-judge panel. That Superior Court panel had determined that voter ID critics had not presented enough evidence to justify a preliminary injunction blocking voter ID before a full trial.

    Writing for the unanimous Appeals Court panel, Hampson's 45-page opinion outlines several reasons why the voter ID law shows signs of discriminatory intent. Take his assessment of a provision that allows any qualified voter to argue that a "reasonable impediment" stands in the way of acquiring a voter ID:

  • While it may be true that African-American voters without a qualifying ID could still be able to vote by using the reasonable-impediment provision, this fact does not necessarily fully eliminate the disproportionate impact on African-American voters resulting from both S.B. 824's voter-ID provisions and the reasonable-impediment provision. As Plaintiffs have shown, the voter-ID provisions likely will have a negative impact on African Americans because they lack acceptable IDs at a greater rate than white voters. Accordingly, it follows African-American voters will also then have to rely on the reasonable-impediment provision more frequently than white voters. Although the reasonable-impediment provision casts a wide net in defining the types of reasonable impediments that qualify under the law, which Defendants contend will result in almost every reason for lacking an acceptable ID to constitute a reasonable impediment, a voter using this provision must still undertake the additional task of filling out the reasonable-impediment form and submitting an affidavit verifying its veracity to cast a provisional ballot, which is subject to rejection if the county board believes the voter's affidavit and reasonable impediment are false. Although Defendants assert these additional steps to vote are not overly burdensome,the use of the reasonable-impediment provision is still one more obstacle to voting, which Plaintiffs have shown will be an obstacle that African Americans will have to overcome at a rate higher than white voters, given their disproportionately lower rates of possessing qualifying IDs. Accordingly, even though at this stage the evidence shows it is "not [an] overwhelming impact," the reasonable-impediment provision nevertheless suffices as a "[s]howing [of] disproportionate impact," establishing another circumstance evidencing discriminatory intent.


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Biden caught on camera admitting he does not know what he is signing, but does so anyway
Now that President Biden has been sworn in as the 46th president, he wants to hit the ground running and attend to urgent priorities.
Brittany Bernstein of National Review Online highlights one disappointing opening-day action from the new Biden administration.
Is the “Jet Pack Guy” who has been spotted several times flying miles in the sky near Los Angeles airport really a “guy”? Or is it just a drone dressed up to look like a guy?
The fall 2020 semester did not go as planned for most students and many felt that their universities failed them.
Ross Marchand writes for the Martin Center about the new president’s approach to higher education policy.
This piece was created by Paul Harvey many years ago, but reflect on its application to today


A former Carolina Panthers star has now become an advocate for re-opening North Carolina schools for in-person instruction.
Chicago prosecutors say 36-year-old Aditya Singh lived in the city’s O’Hare International Airport for three months to avoid flying home to Los Angeles, California, amid the coronavirus pandemic.
So much is made of the Cancel Culture, which is as real as Trump Derangement Syndrome; however, the Impeachment Culture, as an offshoot of this Cancel Culture, has NOW won the day for the religiously Woke.
Looking into January, state legislative sessions will begin across the nation. For many states, a critical focus point will be on the emergency powers those states’ governments have exercised in the wake of COVID-19.
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) will deliver an article of impeachment against former President Donald Trump to the Senate on Monday, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer announced Friday.
He thinks it's clearly unconstitutional to try a man already out of office.
Victor Davis Hanson writes for National Review Online about the work of President Trump’s commission on American history.
Before he left office, former President Donald Trump ordered the Secret Service to continue protecting his children for the next six months.


The bass-playing younger brother of cultural icon Dolly Parton died of cancer, according to a statement from the Parton family.
Dan McLaughlin of National Review Online notes a recent abrupt change in Republican Party fundraising.
Although Twitter had not taken large-scale action against popular Antifa Twitter accounts during President Trump’s tenure, allowing Antifa more latitude to organize their efforts at creating chaos, this week, after President Biden was inaugurated, Twitter suspended some of those Antifa-related accou
Through one of Donald Trump’s final acts as president, former N.C. Republican Party chairman Robin Hayes became one of the most prominent North Carolinians to receive a presidential pardon.
Democrats have started to face backlash online after photographs emerged Thursday of National Guardsmen being forced to sleep in parking garages while also having minimal access to restrooms and other essential items.
The great gift this Christmas was that help was on the way. The vaccine was a welcome gift 10 months into the pandemic. It is no exaggeration that North Carolina’s vaccination rollout started poorly.


Back to Top