The Clash of Constitutions

Latest Polls (view all)

In the shadow of the political assassination of Charlie Kirk, founder of Turning USA, a stain now exists upon our nation's collective conscious, a condition that must be excised, or our nation will not function properly as one of a self-governed people. Understanding these long standing truths: What would you suggest as a quick, and, or proper corrective measure?

20% Destroy the Fascist Donald Trump and all of MAGA, because America must never be Great Again.

80% Our self-governed people, and their properly restored institutions, under President Trump, must discover the root causes to properly correct, and save our Constitutional Republic.

0% I thought we had to shut down Free Speech we don't like to save our "democracy," so I am totally confused now.

Click Here to Vote
10 Vote(s)

View all Polls

Published: Wednesday, October 28th, 2020 @ 4:29 am
By: John Locke Foundation ( More Entries )

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Mitch Kokai.

John McGinnis writes at Law and Liberty about two competing views of the U.S. Constitution.

The Senate hearing on the nomination of Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court shows that we effectively have two different Constitutions today, because the interpretive methodologies of Democratic and Republican political actors diverge so dramatically. Republicans embrace originalism as a mode of interpretation. Democrats aspire to a method that bends the Constitution toward "the moral arc of the universe" where that arc traces the parabola of progressive politics.

The implications of this divergence are profound both for the nation and for academic debates over originalism. We are in a period of political polarization unprecedented since at least the New Deal and probably since the 19th century. Successive waves of partisanship have now engulfed our fundamental document, threatening a kind of legal instability we have not seen in the last 150 years. It will likely get worse, particularly if Democrats go through with threats of court packing, which will inevitably beget more and more court packing, turning our highest tribunal into something more resembling the British House of Lords. Academically, the dramatic divergence shows that the positive argument that originalism should be followed simply because it is our law is inadequate because high officials do not agree on the rule of recognition-that is, the standard by which we determine what constitutes constitutional law.

The hearing was, of course, full of the posturing and cynical maneuvering that politicians bring to any televised event, particularly one so close to an election. But it was genuinely illuminating on the parties' professed approach to interpretation, even though those approaches would be applied inconsistently by many politicians. The Republicans all affirmed some version of originalism or suggested following the Constitution as written, sharply separating law from politics and policy.

The Democratic Senators on the Judiciary Committee, in contrast, have never been as explicit in simultaneously rejecting originalism and embracing an expressly progressive jurisprudence.

Go Back

Login to Leave a Comment

Civil Society and the Future of American Education

John Locke Foundation Guest Editorial, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics

Is Roy Cooper’s State Board of Elections Irredeemably Racist?

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Mentally Ill, Repeat-Criminal Kills Young Ukrainian Female Refugee. Media Silent. Guess Why.

If a white person commits a crime against a black person, it is a national news story.

Published: Monday, September 15th, 2025 @ 5:21 pm By: Daily Wire

Bill to punish lenient judges introduced in Congress to stop criminal release

would allow civil lawsuit against judge if released criminal causes harm

Published: Monday, September 15th, 2025 @ 8:32 am By: John Steed

poll: 3 most popular politicians in France are all from anti-immigration right

good sign for next French election

Published: Sunday, September 14th, 2025 @ 9:17 pm By: John Steed

Charlie Kirk: A martyr for faith and freedom

By Rev. Mark Creech

Published: Sunday, September 14th, 2025 @ 5:43 pm By: Countrygirl1411

Venezuela Taunts U.S. Navy, Pentagon Fires Back

"This highly provocative move was designed to interfere with our counter narco-terror operations."

Published: Sunday, September 14th, 2025 @ 5:43 pm By: Daily Wire

Charlie Kirk, While Speaking to College Students on Campus, Was Shot Dead by an Assassin in Utah

Charlie Kirk, 31 years of age, who was renowned as one of the most important and influential college speakers /Leaders in many decades; founder of Turning Point USA, has been shot dead at Utah Valley University.

Published: Sunday, September 14th, 2025 @ 5:42 pm By: Stan Deatherage

Obama-Appointed Judge Blocks Trump’s Freeze On Harvard’s Federal Funding

The Trump administration took actions against Harvard related to the anti-Israel protests that roiled its campus.

Published: Sunday, September 14th, 2025 @ 5:33 pm By: Daily Wire

In Remembrance of 9/11

In remembrance of the day that will forever seer the concept of 'evil' in our minds, let's look back at that fateful morning, exactly 11 years ago today to that series of horrific events which unfolded before our unbelieving eyes......

Published: Sunday, September 14th, 2025 @ 5:32 pm By: Diane Rufino

Nigel Farage Spars With Dems As He Warns About ‘Authoritarian’ Crackdown On Free Speech

“This could happen to any American man or woman [who] goes to Heathrow."

Published: Sunday, September 14th, 2025 @ 5:31 pm By: Daily Wire

Charlie Kirk assassin lived with "transgender" partner who he asked for help UPDATED

transgender etchings on bullets now have basis shown

Published: Saturday, September 13th, 2025 @ 1:57 pm By: John Steed

Bleeding under the blade of lawlessness

By Rev. Mark Creech

Published: Saturday, September 13th, 2025 @ 12:22 pm By: Countrygirl1411

Judicial coup fail - Appeals Court nixs Dist Ct order on Planned Parenthood funds

crooked Biden judge had put herself above both president AND congress

Published: Friday, September 12th, 2025 @ 8:09 pm By: John Steed

Kamala Harris book backfires as Biden aides expose her glaring failures

Another failure for Harris

Published: Friday, September 12th, 2025 @ 4:04 pm By: Countrygirl1411

Charlie Kirk assassin tied to ANTIFA, used same message board as Butler shooter

Time to investigate Discord and its users

Published: Friday, September 12th, 2025 @ 3:54 pm By: John Steed

Young Brazilian woman is first refugee from "transgender" tyranny

faced 25 years in prison for "misgendering" a leftie tranny politician

Published: Friday, September 12th, 2025 @ 1:58 pm By: John Steed

RINO Tillis pooh-poohs conservative concerns about Charlie Kirk assassination

tone deaf to the end

Published: Friday, September 12th, 2025 @ 9:18 am By: John Steed

Illegal alien migrants behaving badly - migrants and crime NEWLY UPDATED

illegal alien "asylum seeker" migrants are a crime wave on both sides of the Atlantic

Published: Friday, September 12th, 2025 @ 7:34 am By: John Steed

Fentanyl Crisis Escalates In U.S. Workplaces As China Fuels Supply Chain

"Up from 0.91% in 2023 and double the rate in 2020"

Published: Thursday, September 11th, 2025 @ 9:59 pm By: Daily Wire

Bullets of Charlie Kirk assassin had transgender and ANTIFA words on them

Is this the latest act of "transgender" violence?

Published: Thursday, September 11th, 2025 @ 11:30 am By: John Steed

Ten Years (now 24 years later) After 9/11: a Recollection, a Time to Remember

It was a clear beautiful, royal blue sky day on Wall Street. The S & P futures were up markedly, awaiting a positive open, as I turn to get my first cup of coffee. I return to CNBC to get the morning business news, when I notice that the S & P futures are falling, and they're falling fast.