Government Programs Can Never Replicate the Value of Voluntary Charity | Beaufort County Now | One of the biggest political and cultural shifts over 90 or so years is the clamoring for the government to do more in just about every area of society.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Government Programs Can Never Replicate the Value of Voluntary Charity

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Civitas Institute. The author of this post is Ray Nothstine.

    One of the biggest political and cultural shifts over 90 or so years is the clamoring for the government to do more in just about every area of society. One of the most comical occurrences we often see today is celebrities or the super-rich figures who write op-eds or get on TV imploring for higher taxes so they are forced to give up more of their money. After all, is anybody stopping them from giving voluntarily?

    I recently published a piece over at the Carolina Journal titled, "Christmas reminds us that voluntary charity is superior to government coercion." It's a reminder that the government is no match for voluntary giving. There are liberties and a deeply moral component to free association. There is freedom in picking and choosing how you give. This can't be replicated by government coercion to merely tax and spend in order to expand a bureaucratic welfare state. It's disappointing to see so many conflate the government spending more with compassion or virtue. Here is an essential line from the Carolina Journal piece:

  • The ancient theologian and philosopher Augustine noted that "Human society is knit together by transactions of giving and receiving." This is an important point and something the government hasn't proven it can replicate. Ultimately, the government has little capacity to meet deeper needs or restore goodness to society. The long list of failures of the federal war on poverty undoubtedly provides the starkest example.

    One good example comes from my 3-year-old son this Christmas season. My wife picked up an Angel Tree kid to sponsor for Christmas at the courthouse. Our child in need is a foster child and about the same age as our son. They have similar interests in toys like Paw Patrol. We explained to him what we were doing and wanted our son to be a part of picking out gifts for this child. He understood at a pretty deep level and asked a lot of questions. And then suddenly, without asking, he ran to get his piggy bank because he wanted to buy presents for the little boy. I teared up a little. Of course, we paid but if you knew how my son is a little obsessive about all the coins he has in his piggy bank, you'd know how much sweeter his actions really were. He saw and understood a need and wanted to meet it. It's great how children often teach us to give and be generous in ways we are often incapable or hesitant to do.

    The government can never replicate compassion like that. It can do some things well, but it can't provide for all our needs or wants and was never intended to do anything like that. It's amazing how many people can't see this simple truth today. Christmas remains a great reminder that the government has limits.

    Don't be one of those citizens who merely clamor for the government to do more when it comes to assisting others. Don't ever think that bureaucracy and programs can ever replace compassion or meet the deeper needs of the human person. If you have the opportunity, be a generous giver this Christmas and not because you are compelled by laws. Rather, always be a person motivated to give from the heart.
Go Back

HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Helen Raleigh writes at National Review Online about an aspect of “clean” energy that its advocates try to hide.
One customer caused the major internet outage that made several well-known websites crash earlier this week, according to the cloud service at the root of the problem.
Many people have resisted getting what has been described as "The Vaccine Shot".
Emily Brooks of the Washington Examiner highlights a new national Republican effort to promote South Carolina’s Sen. Tim Scott.
Governor Roy Cooper signed the following bills into law today: Senate Bill 248 & 2 others
We will offer this allotment of three with more to come; some old, most new, but all quite informative, and, moreover, necessary to understanding that in North Carolina, there is a wiser path to govern ourselves and our People.
The State Board of Elections invites public comment on an amendment to a permanent rule related to the arrangement of official ballots.
The N.C. House passed a bill by a vote of 100-5 on Wednesday to exempt military retirement pay from state income taxes.

HbAD1

Today Governor Roy Cooper announced that he signed an Executive Order to extend a variety of measures currently in place to respond to the COVID-19 Pandemic until July 30.
According to a new study, a microscopic freshwater animal known as a “bdelloid rotifer” or “wheel animalcule,” has survived after being frozen for 24,000 years in Siberian permafrost.
State Auditor Beth Wood’s office found that Shelton Jeffries, the former superintendent of Nash County Public Schools, violated his contract and district procedures by ringing up $45,690 in questionable expenses during his three-plus years at the helm.
The Senators urged Secretary Fudge to reconsider this policy, and instead focus her efforts on housing for more Americans in need during the ongoing pandemic.
Read and decide for yourself if you believe this story
North Carolina state Senator Jeff Jackson, aka Cal Jr., is working his way across the state as part of his “100-Day, 100 County” tour

HbAD2

 
Back to Top