Split Decisions Ahead for NC’s Supreme Court? Maybe Not. | Beaufort County Now | Voters in 2020 gave Republicans more seats on the North Carolina Supreme Court, including elevating Republican Paul Newby to the Chief Justice seat. | john locke foundation, split decisions, supreme court, paul newby, january 7, 2021

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Split Decisions Ahead for NC’s Supreme Court? Maybe Not.

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Donna Martinez.

    Voters in 2020 gave Republicans more seats on the North Carolina Supreme Court, including elevating Republican Paul Newby to the Chief Justice seat. But Democrats maintain a 4-3 political advantage on the court. So what does it mean for future rulings? That's the question addressed by Mitch Kokai, the John Locke Foundation's senior political analyst, in Mitch's latest Carolina Journal column. He looks at the history of the North Carolina Supreme Court for a hint of what could be ahead.

  • Conditions changed after 2018. Democrats flipped an additional seat in that year's election, then picked up a sixth seat in 2019 when a Republican resignation opened up a spot for a Cooper appointee.
  • As the Supreme Court's only remaining Republican, Newby proved to be his colleagues' most frequent critic. He dissented 54 times over the next two years. (No one else cast more than 25 dissenting votes.) But Newby did not always speak as a lone wolf. Ervin voted alongside Newby in dissent 11 times. Morgan and Newby dissented in 13 of the same cases.
  • Some of those cases proved politically consequential. Morgan and Newby bucked the majority in a pair of high-profile cases involving questionable leniency for sexual predators. Ervin and Newby differed on the legal reasoning — but reached the same result — in objecting to a court decision that freed a convicted murderer from death row.
  • Both Ervin and Morgan remain on the Supreme Court today. Recent history suggests that either one could prove willing to join Republicans in a split decision, even if that means voting against fellow Democrats. Strong legal reasoning could prove persuasive in winning Ervin's or Morgan's support.


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Get your batsuit and hang tight with the Wolfman as we enter into Gotham City for battle.
Will Europe be a harbinger of things to come in America
With the U.S. Supreme Court shutting the door this month on future legal action, a state Supreme Court decision will continue to dictate the University of North Carolina’s compliance with public records requests linked to sexual assaults.
Army relieves dozens of soldiers for political reasons
Vice President Mike Pence reportedly called Vice-President Elect Kamala Harris on Thursday to congratulate her on her win.
The Pentagon has reportedly turned down a request from President Donald Trump to have an extravagant sendoff from the White House, nixing the president’s plans to have a military parade at Joint Base Andrews before he departs Washington, D.C.
Many of us are very frustrated with the present political situation in both North Carolina and the Washington, D. C.


Gov. Roy Cooper is again pushing for a multibillion-dollar infrastructure bond, but Republican leaders caution that North Carolina’s still-unsteady economy makes it impossible to tell whether it would be prudent.
Order to release information within 180 days was part of $2.3 trillion COVID-19 relief bill
Clarice Feldman of the American Thinker explores the political calculations linked to President Trump’s second impeachment.
Governor Roy Cooper announced today that the North Carolina Executive Mansion will be illuminated on January 19, 2021, at 5:30 PM in remembrance of the lives lost as in the COVID-19 pandemic.
In her fine opinion piece for the Martin Center, Megan Zogby bemoans the “Quixotic” requirement that North Carolina college and university students take between two and four courses in a language such as Spanish, French, or German.
In this installment, we will discuss the "controversial" Gospel of Judas and how it can be used to decipher cryptic messages made by actors portraying the role of "Judas" in the current political arena..
Frank Main and Fran Spielman write in the Chicago Sun-Times about one consequence of the recent nationwide attack on police.
West Virginia leads the nation in COVID-19 vaccine administration and distribution, even more so than other states that have gained attention for their vaccine rollout strategies, according to federal data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Bill Moore looks at the Democrats call for unity


He denounced the assault on the Capitol. But still the Democrats want his head.
Former U.S. House Speaker Newt Gingrich writes at FoxNews.com that the Republican Party is not as likely to fracture as its opponents hope.
Newly sworn in Chief Justice Paul Newby is wasting little time in getting North Carolina’s court system back up and running.
I’ve joined many others, including the President of the United States, in being locked out of Twitter for posing a tweet about hydroxychloroquine that I posted time and time again and that Twitter had already found to be in compliance with its rules.
This email came from an unknown source but we like it
He may be giving the cult group too much credit.
From a Birmingham jail, where he was arrested for trying to help blacks exercise their right to vote, MLK wrote: "Remember, everything that Hitler did was legal."
A new national study says that it appears safe to reopen schools for in-person instruction in counties with lower rates of COVID-19 hospitalizations.


Back to Top