N&O Ends Rearguard Action in Libel Fight | Beaufort County Now | About halfway down page 5 in this morning’s News & Observer, we learn that the newspaper has settled a decade-old libel dispute.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

N&O Ends Rearguard Action in Libel Fight

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Mitch Kokai.

    About halfway down page 5 in this morning's News & Observer, we learn that the newspaper has settled a decade-old libel dispute. The settlement arrives after the N.C. Supreme Court guaranteed that the newspaper would have to pay a libeled state government worker at least $1.5 million.

    A unanimous high court ruled last August that the N&O had libeled State Bureau of Investigation firearms analyst Beth Desmond in a 2010 newspaper series called "Agents' Secrets." The court's decision upheld a damage award of at least $1.5 million.

    But a trial court originally had awarded Desmond another $4.5 million in punitive damages. That figure, capped by state law, fell well below the $7.5 million in punitive damages awarded by the jury in the case. The Supreme Court agreed that an error during the original trial necessitated throwing out the punitive damage award. Justices ordered a new trial to deal only with the issue of punitive damages.

    Today's N&O report says both sides were preparing for the new trial when they decided to settle the case through mediation. Terms of the settlement are undisclosed. The case is now over.

    The Supreme Court's unanimous decision followed an earlier unanimous opinion from the N.C. Court of Appeals against the newspaper. Writing about the issue in January 2019, I noted:

  • Journalists aren't the only ones who should learn a lesson from the Raleigh News & Observer's recent loss in a multimillion-dollar libel case.
  • The case offers a warning to other reporters, producers, pundits, activists, and advocates: Be careful not to let your favorite "narrative" blind you as you pursue the truth. ...
  • ... [Reporter Mandy] Locke made no mistake when she started looking into alleged misdeeds at the SBI. She made no mistake when she listened to a defense attorney's concerns about one SBI analyst. She didn't even make a mistake if she, as the court suggests, adopted that attorney's accusations as her own theory. That theory helped drive research for her article.
  • But Locke ran into trouble when conversations with multiple experts failed to back up her theory. She could have adjusted the story — or dropped it — in response to new information. Instead documents linked to the lawsuit suggest Locke twisted the experts' words to fit her preconceived theory. Evidence "tended to show that the primary objective of defendants was sensationalism rather than truth," according to the Appeals Court.
  • Pundits and activists should strive to avoid that type of error. Even if there's no multimillion-dollar court judgment on the line.

Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

If you know anyone in Alaska please send them a link to this post and or send this lady a contribution
Gov. Roy Cooper pushes wind energy panacea via executive order, but Chairman of the N.C. Energy Policy Council Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson deems the move an overstep of authority that does not ‘follow the science'
The nation’s federal prison system is in hot water again, this time for security failures that allow inmates to escape undetected.


Leave it to the Donald to lay it out
87% of respondents, who are likely Republican primary voters, view former president Donald Trump favorably
North Carolina Senator Natasha Marcus, D-Mecklenburg, has been spreading falsehoods about N.C.’s donor privacy bill.


Two bills, which would allow medical professionals who aren’t doctors greater latitude in serving patients, are advancing in the Senate.
Congresswoman Ilhan Omar is at it again, this time comparing the U.S. and Israel’s actions in the Middle East to those of Hamas and the Taliban.
A county in California has revised their COVID-19 death total down 25% — by 411 cases — after initially counting all deaths with a positive COVID-19 test as a COVID-related death.
Recently, U.S. Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC) introduced the Hazard Eligibility and Local Projects Act (HELP Act) and the Strategic Acquisition and Floodplain Efficiency Reform Act (SAFER Act), legislation to help communities recover from natural disasters.
What about the part of Washington outside the Downtown?


Back to Top