N&O Ends Rearguard Action in Libel Fight | Beaufort County Now | About halfway down page 5 in this morning’s News & Observer, we learn that the newspaper has settled a decade-old libel dispute. | john locke foundation, news and observer, rearguard action, libel fight, january 27, 2021

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

N&O Ends Rearguard Action in Libel Fight

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Mitch Kokai.

    About halfway down page 5 in this morning's News & Observer, we learn that the newspaper has settled a decade-old libel dispute. The settlement arrives after the N.C. Supreme Court guaranteed that the newspaper would have to pay a libeled state government worker at least $1.5 million.

    A unanimous high court ruled last August that the N&O had libeled State Bureau of Investigation firearms analyst Beth Desmond in a 2010 newspaper series called "Agents' Secrets." The court's decision upheld a damage award of at least $1.5 million.

    But a trial court originally had awarded Desmond another $4.5 million in punitive damages. That figure, capped by state law, fell well below the $7.5 million in punitive damages awarded by the jury in the case. The Supreme Court agreed that an error during the original trial necessitated throwing out the punitive damage award. Justices ordered a new trial to deal only with the issue of punitive damages.

    Today's N&O report says both sides were preparing for the new trial when they decided to settle the case through mediation. Terms of the settlement are undisclosed. The case is now over.

    The Supreme Court's unanimous decision followed an earlier unanimous opinion from the N.C. Court of Appeals against the newspaper. Writing about the issue in January 2019, I noted:

  • Journalists aren't the only ones who should learn a lesson from the Raleigh News & Observer's recent loss in a multimillion-dollar libel case.
  • The case offers a warning to other reporters, producers, pundits, activists, and advocates: Be careful not to let your favorite "narrative" blind you as you pursue the truth. ...
  • ... [Reporter Mandy] Locke made no mistake when she started looking into alleged misdeeds at the SBI. She made no mistake when she listened to a defense attorney's concerns about one SBI analyst. She didn't even make a mistake if she, as the court suggests, adopted that attorney's accusations as her own theory. That theory helped drive research for her article.
  • But Locke ran into trouble when conversations with multiple experts failed to back up her theory. She could have adjusted the story — or dropped it — in response to new information. Instead documents linked to the lawsuit suggest Locke twisted the experts' words to fit her preconceived theory. Evidence "tended to show that the primary objective of defendants was sensationalism rather than truth," according to the Appeals Court.
  • Pundits and activists should strive to avoid that type of error. Even if there's no multimillion-dollar court judgment on the line.



HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Governor Roy Cooper today announced the establishment of a COVID-19 vaccination center in North Carolina, in partnership with the federal government.
Lawmakers in the General Assembly have filed a series of bills that would exempt counties they represent from some or all of Gov. Roy Cooper’s COVID restrictions.
How the Left plans to impose the Green New Deal
Few things have been more disturbing than the politicization of our health care by leftists imposing their racialist agenda on innocent and vulnerable Americans.
Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-IL) went on CNN on Tuesday to blast Donald Trump for the CPAC speech he gave this past weekend, claiming that he was “really bored” during it because it was like many of the others the former president had previously given.
Gov. Roy Cooper’s 11th-hour veto of a school reopening bill Friday isn’t sitting well with nearly half of North Carolina likely voters, a Civitas Flash Poll shows.
On Tuesday, as he was leaving the room with Vice President Kamala Harris, President Biden was asked by reporters whether there was a crisis at the southern border of the United States.

HbAD1

This article is dedicated to our great Founding Fathers - men who had the courage, the foresight, and the wisdom to secure the freedom that I exercise and enjoy every single day. - Diane Rufino
We will offer this allotment of three with more to come; some old, most new, but all quite informative, and, moreover, necessary to understanding that in North Carolina, there is a wiser path to govern ourselves and our People.
The North Carolina Senate on Monday failed to override Governor Cooper’s veto of SB37, legislation that would have required districts to provide in-person learning.
Today, Governor Roy Cooper announced that the State is offering a reward of up to $5,000 for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible for the murder of Matthew Leon Peterkin, age 41.
Isaac Schorr of National Review Online reports on congressional Republicans’ reaction to the Biden administration’s opening days.
So, a year later, states like Florida that lifted their lockdowns quickly and eased other restrictions early have far better COVID-19 records than states of similar size, like New York, that stayed locked down longer and were slow to ease other restrictions.

HbAD2

The company that designed the stage used at CPAC this year has stepped forward to reportedly take full responsibility for the debacle that unfolded when internet trolls noticed the stage resembled the othala rune, a symbol featured on Nazi uniforms.
The N.C. General Assembly on Monday, March 1, tried but failed — by one vote, 29-20 — to override the governor’s veto of a bill to reopen schools.
It was not necessary and all the extra money did not matter. Somebody tell the Governor!
Because of Biden weakness, they now have the opportunity to do it.
Marc Landy writes for the Federalist about the value of federalism during times of difficult politics.
Public school systems in the Tar Heel State are experiencing the highest declines in student enrollment in decades.

HbAD3

 
Back to Top