Certificate of Need: A Bad Law Leads To Bad Behavior | Beaufort County Now | My research brief today answers nine questions about the remarkably “unremarkable” Certificate of Need (CON) law case just decided in the N.C. Court of Appeals.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Jon Sanders.

    My research brief today answers nine questions about the remarkably "unremarkable" Certificate of Need (CON) law case just decided in the N.C. Court of Appeals. Still, I'd like to highlight the ridiculous behavior this "Soviet-style" central planning has created in North Carolina:

  • Reading the decision, one picks up the following. InSight was going to serve two locations, and Mobile Imaging, six. Two host facilities - it is important to note - was the minimum requirement for the CON. InSight had "proposed a statewide mobile PET route with the scanner moving weekly between six potential host sites in eastern, central, and western North Carolina" but "At least three potential host sites told InSight they would not provide documentation to support its CON application due to their concerns about [Mobile Imaging's] reaction."
  • InSight had testified that the UNC Health-affiliated Mobile Imaging maintained an "effective monopoly on mobile PET services" and "described [Mobile Imaging's] history of opposing opportunities to allow additional providers to introduce services to North Carolina's health care market." The potential host sites declining to support InSight's CON application "were wary of taking action to put their current service with [Mobile Imaging] at risk."
  • Remember about the two host facilities? Mobile Imaging "undertook efforts to encourage InSight's two host sites to rescind their support for InSight's CON application" - going so far as to "draft rescission letters for both of InSight's host sites: Caldwell and Harris Regional. Caldwell's president signed the letter. Harris' did not." Fortunately for InSight, the agency, ALJ, and appellate court all saw through Mobile Imaging's "anti-competitive behavior to ensure it was awarded the CON."
  • Unfortunately for North Carolina health consumers, as well as Mobile Imaging and the other two competitors in this case, North Carolina's policymakers have not seen through the greater anticompetitive problems wrought on this state by CON law.

    As I wrote in the brief, who is harmed by all this? It should be obvious, and it's why the John Locke Foundation has long advocated repeal of North Carolina's CON law: "People with a medical need for mobile PET scanners are harmed while health care companies wage high-stakes battles in state courts over state agency decisions regarding a law that 15 states and the federal government have already ditched for making health care more costly and less accessible to citizens."
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

The N.C. Court of Appeals has affirmed state regulators’ ruling against a proposed solar energy plant for North Carolina.
There are so many more like these but it is mostly the "bad apples" we hear about
In conversations about record inflation, most people harken back to the Jimmy Carter era where annual price inflation growth surpassed 10%.
A school district in Michigan has not only canceled Halloween ahead of October 31, but also gone ahead and canceled Valentine’s Day, which is still four months away.
Don't you think it's time for conservative county government?
North Carolina set another record for new business creation in 2021.
The first time crime really hit home for me was when a thug pointed a gun at a family member’s head while she was making an after-hours bank transaction.
Nicholas Curry just wrapped up his first semester at Appalachian State University. It’s a moment to celebrate for any student, but for Nicholas, the victory is particularly meaningful.
A leftist California politico who serves as co-president of the Global Forum on Modern Direct Democracy mocked Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s statements on abortion by stating the concept of “equity” demands parents give up their children to the state.


Last week, part-owner of the NBA’s Golden State Warriors, Chamath Palihapitiya, asserted that “ nobody cares ” about the Uyghur genocide happening at the hands of Chinese authorities.
Lawyers supporting and opposing North Carolina’s new election maps will take their arguments to the N.C. Supreme Court on Feb. 2.
Macron's Minister of Education issued order while vacationing in Spain
America’s colleges and universities are loaded with professors who insist on teaching students various theories that amount to nothing but fringe opinions and who don’t engage intellectually with those who disagree, but merely try to “cancel” them.
Joins Fight to Uphold the Will of Voters by Allowing State Legislatures to Properly Defend Their Laws
The Washington Post finally got around to covering the sexual assault allegations at a high school in Virginia, first revealed by The Daily Wire.
Omicron is spreading faster than Kudzu, especially among our children.
Military installations in North Carolina will benefit from the recent passage of the National Defense Authorization Act, which U.S. Sen. Thom Tillis, R-North Carolina, helped to push through Congress.


In 2019, Gov. Roy Cooper pledged $146.0 million in corporate welfare to 66 corporations. In 2020, amid shutting down and crippling small businesses with extreme executive orders, Cooper pledged $519.3 million in corporate giveaways to just 48 corporations.
When you get right down to it, two years of COVID-19 and the government intrusion that has gone along with it, has led to what CNBC dubs a “winter of discontent.”
Many college campuses aren’t as hospitable to open inquiry and free expression as they should be. However, there is reason for hope.
A majority of the state’s hospitals are reaping the benefits of tax-exempt status but come up short in providing adequate charity care to earn that designation — and they’re getting away with it.
Former Democrat presidential candidate Tulsi Gabbard slammed Democrat President Joe Biden on Wednesday for remarks that he made during a speech this week that were widely panned as divisive and anti-American by critics.
Kathleen Buhle, the ex-wife of Hunter Biden, is releasing a new book releasing dirt on the son of Democrat President Joe Biden, detailing his addictions, alleged affairs, and alleged abusive behavior.


Back to Top