Barber Claims First Amendment, Technical Reasons To Toss Trespass Conviction | Beaufort County Now | The four-year-old case of a high-profile, left-of-center N.C. political activist convicted of trespassing at the state Legislative Building now sits in the hands of the state’s second-highest court.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The four-year-old case of a high-profile, left-of-center N.C. political activist convicted of trespassing at the state Legislative Building now sits in the hands of the state's second-highest court.

    The Rev. William Barber, leader of the national Poor People's Campaign and former president of the state NAACP, wants his conviction thrown out. It stemmed from a 2017 protest aimed at Republican legislative leaders.

    Barber's lawyer argued before the N.C. Court of Appeals Wednesday that the trespass charge violated Barber's First Amendment rights. Meanwhile, attorney Scott Holmes also contended that a technical violation should have prevented the case from reaching Superior Court in the first place.

    "What this court needs to do is direct the state courts on how to deal with trespass when it is a public forum" like the corridors of the General Assembly's buildings, Holmes said.

    Special state Deputy Attorney General Matthew Tulchin countered that Barber had been charged and convicted because of illegal conduct, not the speech linked to his First Amendment rights. The state also downplayed Holmes' technical argument.

    "This case is just not about the First Amendment," Tulchin said. "It is about a defendant who, along with approximately 50 other people, gathered in the hallways outside the legislative leaders' offices and impeded people's entering and exiting, and impeded the flow and staff who were trying to walk in those hallways."

    "They also created a huge disturbance," he said, going on to describe the noise linked to yelling and call-and-response chants led by Barber.

    Judges Chris Dillon, Lucy Inman, and Jeff Carpenter peppered both lawyers with questions. Some dealt with the details of a trespass charge. Others focused on a protester's right to remain in a public place after authorities have asked them to leave.

    Multiple questions focused on whether Barber's case should have gone to Superior Court without an indictment. Prosecutors never acted on their initial May 2018 indictment of the activist. They proceeded instead with a misdemeanor statement of charges issued three weeks later. Holmes challenged that process.

    There's no timeline for a decision in the case. Barber's original sentence for his 2019 trespass conviction was a $250 fine, court costs, one day in jail suspended for 12 months, two months of unsupervised probation, and 24 hours of community service.
Go Back


( August 25th, 2021 @ 4:51 pm )
Abject stupidity will not save America's First Idiot President from his blatant divergence from his oath to enforce the laws of this land.

N.C. ABC, Contractor Approve Moves to Decrease Some Warehouse Costs Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics State Auditor Uncovers Poor Record Keeping in Town of Plymouth


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

The list of Democrats retiring just keeps growing. From the U.S. House to the North Carolina House, Democrats are running scared because they know their chances of winning are dwindling just like Joe Biden’s approval ratings.
I have been following the Sheppard case and the Franks case the last couple of years with a somewhat dispassionate interest. The wheels of justice grind and they do grind slow.
House Republicans, led by Rep. Chip Roy (R-TX), have sent a letter to Biden administration Attorney General Merrick Garland calling his recent schools memo an effort to weaponize the DOJ and curb Constitutional rights.
Today, U.S. Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC) and 49 Senate Republican colleagues filed a formal challenge against President Biden's vaccine mandate under the Congressional Review Act.
Last week, the UNC Board of Governors met at NC State’s Hunt Library for its November meeting.
Amid the shopping bags, holiday music, and twinkle lights, smash and grab crime videos are plaguing the retail season this year.
The parents of the suspect accused of shooting up a high school in Michigan were hit with involuntary manslaughter charges on Friday, prosecutors announced.
If you are covering Kamala Harris’ visit to Charlotte today, please consider the following statement from the Republican National Committee
Democrat Rep. Rashida Tlaib (MI) effectively admitted on Wednesday that she only wears a mask when there are cameras around, which undercuts a number of public statements she has made about the importance of wearing masks.


In a letter a few weeks ago, State Auditor Beth Wood insisted that applications to purchase the Bald Head Island ferry (System) by the Village of Bald Head Island (Village) and the Bald Head Island Transportation Authority (Authority) not be included in the December Local Government Commission (LGC)
So far this year, Gov. Cooper has pledged over $930.7 million in tax incentives to just 22 corporations, including $845.8 million over four decades to Apple
Candidate filing for the 2022 statewide primary and rescheduled municipal elections begins at noon on Monday, December 6, and ends at noon on Friday, December 17.
In May, the UNC School of Medicine revised its Guidelines for Appointment, Reappointment, and Promotion.
While a bill that would legalize sports betting across North Carolina passed a House committee last week, odds are heavily against it passing the full General Assembly before the session ends.
James W. Frick had a head full of Carolina common sense. Born in New Bern, in 1924, he was raised in a Catholic orphanage and graduated from Notre Dame.
Tristen Wallace began his college days at the University of Oregon with dreams of eventually playing in the NFL. But shortly into his college career, he was accused by two women of rape and expelled.


Back to Top