Why Is the AAUP Investigating UNC? | Beaufort County Now | On September 29, the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) announced that it is investigating what it calls “egregious violations of principles of academic governance and persistent structural racism in the University of North Carolina System.”

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of The James G. Martin Center. The author of this post is Jenna A. Robinson.

    On September 29, the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) announced that it is investigating what it calls "egregious violations of principles of academic governance and persistent structural racism in the University of North Carolina System." To do so, it has launched a special committee and will release its findings in early 2022.

    According to the AAUP's press release, the investigation was prompted by the "widely publicized mishandling of the tenure case of New York Times writer Nikole Hannah-Jones." But there has already been a significant-one might even say exhaustive-investigation of that incident. Local and national media outlets of all stripes have uncovered the relevant facts: policies that govern tenure and appointments at UNC, the timeline of events in Hannah-Jones' tenure case, and emails from involved parties. A UNC employee even leaked a copy of Walter Hussman's UNC donation agreement to the media. It's unlikely that the AAUP will discover anything new.

    Thus, the investigation will go far beyond the Hannah-Jones incident. According to AAUP's press release, the report will also cover "the influence of the gerrymandered state legislature on the systemwide board of governors and campus boards of trustees" and "how the use of political pressure has obstructed meaningful faculty participation in the UNC system." In short, the AAUP will be looking into all the things it doesn't like about the UNC System: namely, its conservative Board of Governors and Board of Trustees, their statutory authority to oversee faculty appointments, and the Republican-controlled legislature that appointed them.

    It's a very thinly veiled attempt at intimidation in a power struggle between left-of-center faculty members and the governance structure that stops them from having completely free rein on campus.

    To be sure, the AAUP represents the professional interests of its constituents-faculty-but it also represents their radical, and often illiberal, politics. For example, the AAUP-funded campaign for "A New Deal for Higher Education" promotes concepts like "economic justice" and the cancellation of student debt. The AAUP's blog, Academe, regularly demonizes conservative principles and policies generally (such as individual responsibility and fiscal discipline) as well as questioning many conservative ideas for universities (such as viewpoint diversity, free speech, or a Great Books curriculum).

    The AAUP's politics have also corrupted its vision of academic freedom. For many years, the AAUP has adopted an expansive vision of academic freedom-including complete faculty autonomy over teaching, curriculum, research projects, and extramural speech. But now, it only extends the "right" to autonomy to those who toe the political line. Eva Cherniavsky, president of the University of Washington's AAUP chapter, explains this double-standard on the Academe blog. She says, "Against the Right's argument that all perspectives must be represented, the faculty assert a collective authority to norm intellectual debates in our fields." This kind of thinking allows leftist faculty majorities to exclude heterodox scholars from contemporary academic discourse and squelch the first amendment rights of dissenters-all while maintaining an "anything goes" standard for their political fellow-travelers.

    The composition of the committee tasked with the investigation is further evidence of the political motivations driving this investigation. The committee members all come from disciplines that are well-known to tilt left. (According to a 2014 study by Gross and Simmons, only about five percent of social scientists and humanists are registered Republicans.) No members of the committee come from STEM or business fields. The members are:

  • Nicholas Fleisher, associate professor of linguistics at the University of Wisconsin - Milwaukee (co-chair)
  • Afshan Jafar, professor of sociology at Connecticut College (co-chair);
  • Monica Black, professor of history at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville;
  • Emily Houh, law professor at the University of Cincinnati;
  • Henry Reichman, professor emeritus of history at California State University - East Bay;
  • Charles Toombs, professor of Africana studies at San Diego State University; and
  • Brian Turner, professor of political science at Randolph-Macon College.
  • Several of the members of the committee list research interests that are highly politicized, including, "gender and the body," "critical race theory," and "Black queer studies."

    The press release itself also makes it clear that the AAUP's motives are political. It compares the forthcoming report to the AAUP's previous work "which reviewed dismissals of faculty members during the McCarthy Era" and "conditions for academic freedom in Mississippi and its institutions of higher education in relation to segregation and efforts to abolish it."

    But to anyone paying attention, it's clear that the AAUP has it backward. It is faculty hiring committees (not the Board of Governors) who are now instituting political litmus tests reminiscent of Joseph McCarthy-in the form of required "diversity statements" from job and tenure candidates. And the new segregationists can be found amongst faculty and administrators who promote separate resources and activities for different "affinity groups." One recent instance made headlines at Appalachian State University, where a "black male" housing initiative was paired with a Black Panther course.

    The AAUP's forthcoming report isn't a serious investigative endeavor, and shouldn't be treated as such. It's a political statement. When the report is released this spring, legislators, board members, and the UNC System should treat it that way.

    Jenna A. Robinson is president of the James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

At least two people are dead and more than 40 have been injured in a powerful tornado that ripped through northern Michigan Friday night.
A Democratic state representative from Raleigh proposes a statewide ban on transporting dogs in open vehicle beds and cargo areas.
Updating the press on the baby formula shortage that's affecting millions of American families, Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre (black, gay, immigrant) stated that all blame for the shortage rested squarely on the curly locks of the giant baby from Honey, I Blew Up The Kid.
Powerful U.S. artillery pieces have started to arrive in Ukraine that offer the country’s military the opportunity to outgun Russia’s military as the new equipment can outreach the capability of Russia’s military by several miles.
As the baby formula crisis continues to grow, more families have opted for an alternative formula source and have started taking whey protein instead. The babies will still get everything they need for healthy development, as well as 50grams of protein per bottle.


A biography of George Floyd will be published on May 17, 2022, and appears to whitewash his life story to highlight his constant “search of a better life” and his “relentless struggle to survive as a Black man in America.”
The first day of class the law professor strode into the room. The first thing he did was ask for the name of a student sitting in the front row.
Republican primary voters picked Trey Allen, Donna Stroud, and Michael Stading to represent the party on the November ballot in three key appellate court races
American voters are increasingly disenchanted with the men and women who have been elected to govern their interests both domestically and abroad.
The House Committee on Ethics said in a statement on Monday that it has opened multiple investigations into outgoing Rep. Madison Cawthorn (R-NC).
RALEIGH: Today, Governor Roy Cooper released a video on critical gun safety reforms to protect our communities.


The U.S. Army, apparently interested in furthering its recent journey into wokeness, is considering a policy called a “compassionate reassignment” permitting soldiers to request a transfer to a different area if they feel state or local laws discriminate against them because of their gender.


Back to Top