One group of redistricting challengers wants all N.C. Supreme Court justices to participate | Beaufort County Now | One group challenging North Carolina’s new election maps in court is distancing itself from debates about recusal of targeted N.C. Supreme Court justices.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    One group challenging North Carolina's new election maps in court is distancing itself from debates about recusal of targeted N.C. Supreme Court justices.

    In a court filing Wednesday, plaintiffs in the case dubbed N.C. League of Conservation Voters v. Hall responded to motions seeking the removal of as many as three justices from the case.

    "This case raises urgent issues of statewide importance concerning the lawfulness of the redistricting maps the General Assembly enacted in

    November 2021,"
according to the document from attorney Stephen Feldman. "The NCLCV Plaintiffs-Appellants hope that, on a matter of such great consequence, every judicial officer who can participate - while respecting the constraints of the North Carolina Code of Judicial Conduct and other applicable standards - will do so."

    "Indeed, there is a substantial 'negative impact [from] the unnecessary disqualification of even one Justice' in cases, like this one, before a court of last resort, where 'unlike the situation in a [lower court,] there is no way to replace a recused Justice,'" Feldman added, quoting a 2000 statement from former U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice William Rehnquist.

    The NCLCV plaintiffs are grouped at the state Supreme Court with plaintiffs in a similar case titled Harper v. Hall. The left-of-center activist group Common Cause is also intervening in the case. All of them want North Carolina's highest court to toss out new congressional and legislative election maps. Those maps are set to take effect for this year's elections.

    In contrast to the NCLCV plaintiffs, the Harper plaintiffs filed a Jan. 11 motion seeking disqualification of Republican Justice Phil Berger Jr. from the election maps case. Berger's father is the top officer in the N.C. Senate. In that official capacity, Sen. Berger is a named defendant in the lawsuits.

    Meanwhile, the maps' Republican legislative defenders have filed separate requests for recusal from Democratic Justices Anita Earls and Sam "Jimmy" Ervin IV.

    Earls is targeted because of her close involvement with participants in the case. Ervin is the only Supreme Court justice running for re-election this year. His involvement in decisions about candidate filing and election dates could influence his own election, according to legislative defendants.

    A Dec. 23 Supreme Court order ensures that Berger, Earls, and Ervin will have the opportunity to make individual decisions about whether to take part in the case. They can turn the decision over to a vote of their colleagues but are not required to do so.

    The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments in the election maps case on Feb. 2.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Soon, high school graduates will be making monumental decisions that will determine their future quality of life. These decisions include whether to attend college; if so, where; and finally, what degree program to pursue.
State Sen. Valerie Foushee, D-Orange, is the winner of the competitive Democratic primary race in North Carolina’s 4th Congressional District.
With infant formula shortages reaching crisis levels across the nation, Pete Buttigieg is struggling to find food for his twin babies and has been forced to resort to chestfeeding.
A St. Louis University (SLU) student who put up flyers advertising an upcoming lecture from The Daily Wire’s Matt Walsh is facing suspension or expulsion, even though he says he put the flyers up off campus.
climate crazies are at war with middle class lifestyle


Wiley Nickel and Bo Hines will face off for the 13th Congressional District seat. The district includes Johnston County, as well as parts of Wayne, Harnett, and Wake Counties.
On Wednesday afternoon Governor Roy Cooper released his recommended budget adjustments for the upcoming fiscal year that begins on July 1.
At the suggestion of his agent, his team of attorneys, and his plumber, Johnny Depp had bird spikes installed on his bed to prevent Amber Heard from pooping in it.
A giant $10 billion space telescope is scheduled to be rocketed into space on December 22 with the hope that it will discover the universe’s origins and the first light that ever emanated in the universe, taking humanity back to the Big Bang.
Critical state Supreme Courts seats are on the ballot in Illinois, Michigan, North Carolina, and Ohio in 2022, and political observers are starting to recognize the monumental impact these races will have this election cycle
A former major mob boss ripped into former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo over his actions in the nursing home scandal in which thousands of New Yorkers died from COVID-19, snapping, “I’m a bad***. I’d never do it.”
Following the leak of the Supreme Court opinion that could overturn Roe V. Wade, hundreds of abortion advocates traveled to protest outside the homes of the conservative Justices.
Sen. Joe Manchin this shuts down drilling


Back to Top