Supreme Court Supports Right for General Assembly to Intervene in Voter ID Case | Eastern North Carolina Now | The decision allows legislative leaders to defend voter ID themselves instead of just relying on Attorney General Josh Stein

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Dr. Andy Jackson.

    In an 8-1 ruling written by Justice Neil Gorsuch, the United State Supreme Court upheld the right of legislative leaders to intervene in a lawsuit over North Carolina's voter ID law. Only Justice Sonya Sotomayor dissented.

    The ruling, in Berger v. North Carolina NAACP, will allow attorneys working for the General Assembly to defend the ID law in federal court. The reasoning of the court is simple; sometimes the attorney general opposes the law he is supposed to defend (pages 2-3):

    Sometimes leaders in different branches of government may see the State's interests at stake in litigation differently. Some States may judge that important public perspectives would be lost without a mechanism allowing multiple officials to respond. It seems North Carolina has some experience with just these sorts of issues. More than once a North Carolina attorney general has opposed laws enacted by the General Assembly and declined to defend them fully in federal litigation.

    In short, if an attorney general cannot be trusted to vigorously defend a law, lawmakers must have the ability to defend the law themselves. That is especially important given Attorney General Josh Stein's history of failing to protect voter ID in North Carolina.

    The majority opinion also makes it clear that ruling against the legislature intervening in the case would open the floodgates to lawyers shopping around in order to get defendants who do not have an interest in defending the law the lawyers want to overturn (pages 12-13):

    Yet, contrary to the premise implicit in the NAACP's argument, a plaintiff who chooses to name this or that official defendant does not necessarily and always capture all relevant state interests. Instead and as we have seen, where a State chooses to divide its sovereign authority among different officials and authorize their participation in a suit challenging state law, a full consideration of the State's practical interests may require the involvement of different voices with different perspectives. To hold otherwise would risk allowing a private plaintiff to pick its preferred defendants and potentially silence those whom the State deems essential to a fair understanding of its interests.

    In other words, those seeking to get rid of North Carolina election laws cannot simply play red rover and ask for Stein and the Democratic-controlled North Carolina State Board of Elections to come over to defend election laws they do not like.

    The voter ID lawsuit itself is still working its way through the federal court system.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

N.C. Republican Congressional delegation outraged at FBI raid on former President Donald Trump's Mar-a-Lago home in Florida.
The trouble with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money
A federal magistrate judge has ordered the Department of Justice (DOJ) to respond to requests to make public the warrant authorizing the FBI’s unprecedented Monday raid of former President Donald Trump’s residence.
New Zealand Prime Jacinda Ardern smiled during an interview late last week when saying that she was effectively creating two different classes of people in her country that have different levels of freedom depending on whether they are vaccinated.
On Tuesday, Democrats filed an emergency motion to stay federal Judge James Dever’s decision last week to order the North Carolina State Board of Elections to place the Green Party’s candidates on the ballot.
Communist China threatened to shoot down Democrat House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s (D-CA) plane on Friday if the 82-year-old lawmaker tries to visit Taiwan.


those 87,000 new auditors will be hard asses
China accused the White House of lying when it claimed President Joe Biden pressed Chinese President Xi Jinping on the country’s systematic abuse of Uyghur Muslims when the leaders spoke by phone Thursday morning.
Former President Donald J. Trump was seen fleeing on a golf cart while shouting defiantly at federal agents Monday. Witnesses claim he led authorities on a daring chase that reached speeds of up to 30 Mph.
Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) slammed Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and the Chief Medical Advisor to the President, on Sunday over a new letter from the National Institutes of Health (NIH)
Disgraced star Will Smith finally broke his silence on what occurred between him and wife Jada Pinkett Smith before Smith walked on stage at the 2022 Oscars and struck Chris Rock in the face.
As students head back to campus this month, school safety is a growing part of the equation facing administrators and parents.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents found 73 illegal immigrants in homes believed to be operated by human smugglers in an affluent area of Washington D.C.
Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT) called on Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV) to switch political parties during an interview on Sunday night, saying that Manchin needed to abandon the party of “inflation” and “lawlessness.”
The Inflation Reduction Act reportedly provides for additional funding to hire 140 million new IRS agents — one for every home in America.


Back to Top