Three-quarters of PPP Benefits Went to Unintended Recipients | Eastern North Carolina Now | In response to the Covid shutdown recession, the Small Business Administration and Department of the Treasury rolled out the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP).

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Paige Terryberry.

    In response to the Covid shutdown recession, the Small Business Administration and Department of the Treasury rolled out the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP). PPP distributed $800 billion within two years with the stated intent to maintain payroll, retain employees laid off due to Covid, and cover overhead.

    A new study in the Journal of Economic Perspectives evaluated the efficiency of PPP and revealed astounding government inefficiencies. Though the program was temporary and timely, it was "essentially untargeted."

    Only about a quarter of PPP funds supported jobs that otherwise would have disappeared, according to the report.

    The program was implemented quickly, prioritizing immediate relief. The study notes, "Ironically, the program feature that arguably made the Paycheck Protection Program's meteoric scale-up possible is also the feature that made it potentially the most problematic: the program was essentially untargeted, aside from excluding firms with more than 500 workers." In the end, 94 percent of all small businesses took up a PPP loan. The tradeoff between speed and targeting was significant, resulting in waste.

    The program did not prioritize the highest need. Instead, "loans reached the most and least distressed firms-and all those in between-in nearly equal proportions."

    Only roughly 25 percent of the PPP's efforts went to workers' wages. The majority of the funds, however, went to the small business's creditors and suppliers.

    The cost to taxpayers for preserving jobs was a substantial $169,000 to $258,000 per job for a year depending on the firm's size.

    The study also analyzed who ultimately received these loans and found the results to be highly regressive, with 72 percent of PPP funds going to households with incomes in the top 20 percent.

    Confusion surrounded the program. Initially, demand for loans exceeded the banks' abilities to execute them. Businesses also lacked clarity on whether the loans would be forgiven.


    Unlike some countries, the U.S. lacked the existing administrative infrastructure for overseeing targeted federal aid to businesses. The study found that such an infrastructure is crucial to preventing waste: "building administrative capacity now would enable greatly improved targeting of either employment or business liquidity when the next pandemic or other large-scale economic emergency occurs, as it surely will." Accepting the inevitability of both another Covid-style shutdown or economic emergency, along with a massive federal bailout, is quite concerning.

    The study also recommended "work-sharing" to assist in targeting. Work sharing would encourage a reduction in hours across the broader workforce, for example, to prevent mass unemployment in any given group. It would encourage "paying partial unemployment to many, rather than full unemployment to some" which would result in a more stable economy, according to the study's authors.

Inarguably, the policies of the Democrats in congress and Joe Biden as the Executive is plunging the United States into a recession, if we are not already there; a recession that was completely avoidable. Will abrupt changes in policies occur in time?
  Yes, the Democrats have a bold plan, yet to be revealed, to save us.
  No, there will have to be a complete undoing of the damage done by these Democrats.
  I can't do simple math, so how am I to understand the concept of basic economics.
833 total vote(s)     What's your Opinion?

    In the end, the program's timeliness, a reflection of the great need and uncertainty, was a success. But the accolades end there. With essentially no targeting at all, allowing universal takeup, taxpayers were left on the hook for the government's unintended consequences and lack of alternatives.
Go Back


Latest Regional Business

The last few years have seen an exploding housing market, with the costs of homes surging amid low inventory, but now, experts say the market has taken a turn, and the U.S. has now entered a housing recession.
SECU Foundation recently provided a $40,000 grant to TimberKnolls Spirit Cove (TSC), an organization that provides animal-assisted activities and therapy to veterans, military families, first responders, healthcare workers, and people battling illness or trauma.
As Beaufort County begins to welcome students back into the classrooms, academic and athletic groups are looking for ways to earn funds.
With words not so complicated in clarity, but are proven beyond their capability to fathom in purpose; evidenced by their pejorative words of pure conjecture to corporately misunderstand the essential nature, the core machinations of those self-asserted issues important to their corporate identity.
Albemarle Eye Center is preparing for Operation Sight, which will take place during National Sight Week, from October 9th through October 15th.
It has begun, and it will be a process, but know this NOW: Beaufort County Now (BCN), created by Symbiotic Networks (SNI), has evolved to a point that this online publication's most natural progression is to transition into Eastern NC NOW (ENC NOW).


Unemployment rates (not seasonally adjusted) increased in all but two of North Carolina’s counties in June, according to the latest release from the North Carolina Department of Commerce.
National Economic Council Director Brian Deese said on Wednesday that the United States can address high inflation by passing more spending bills.
In response to the Covid shutdown recession, the Small Business Administration and Department of the Treasury rolled out the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP).
CNBC ranked North Carolina as the #1 state for business and economy in 2022. North Carolina has consistently been a top 10 contender and last year was the runner-up, but what caused the state to take the top spot?
As unemployment remained at low levels in June, the portion of American adults participating in the job market remains far below pre-recession levels, according to a Friday news release from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
In the politcal age of Covid, Beaufort County may be taking some real advantage of "free money" rolling around making some communities richer while making our Republic far poorer ... in a relative sense.


I have a growing collection of images, the vast majority of which are in North Carolina, that I am now offering for sale in a limited edition format.


Back to Top