Did You Know? UNC-Chapel Hill Now Has Some of the Best Free-Speech Policies in the Nation | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of The James G. Martin Center. The author of this post is Jenna A. Robinson.

    Last week, the UNC-Chapel Hill Board of Trustees passed two important resolutions on campus viewpoint neutrality. With the addition of these protections, UNC's free-speech policies are among the best in the nation.

    In a joint meeting of the University Affairs Committee and the Strategic Initiatives Committee, trustees voted unanimously to adopt both resolutions. The "Resolution on the Affirmation of Academic Freedom and Freedom of Speech" affirms the university's commitment to "academic freedom as embodied in the Chicago principles and the Kalven Committee Report on the University's Role in Political and Social Action." The Kalven report, written in 1967 at the University of Chicago, clarifies the university's role in political affairs. The University of Chicago describes it as "affirm[ing] the University's commitment to the academic freedom of faculty and students in the face of suppression from internal and/or external entities while also insisting on institutional neutrality on political and social issues."

    "Academic Freedom and Institutional Neutrality are foundational principles for UNC," said trustee Perrin Jones. "The trustees' unanimous affirmation of this resolution clearly shows the Board's support for these principles."

    Jones continued, "It is arguable whether academic freedom can exist on a given campus if institutional neutrality is not the standard. This concern led us to couple the Chicago Principles with the Kalven Report. Our goal was to remove any specter of politicization and ensure Chapel Hill remains a forum for free and open debate."

    The second resolution adopted by UNC last week extends the principle of neutrality to student government. The "Resolution on Viewpoint-Neutral Access to Mandatory Student Fees" directs the Chancellor and his staff to develop and issue a policy requiring all levels of student government to "appropriate all student fees in a viewpoint-neutral manner." Trustee Teresa Artis Neal pointed out during the meeting that this resolution keeps UNC in line with existing law regarding mandatory student fees.

    "Institutional neutrality benefits Carolina," said trustee Jones. "It doesn't quash the freedom of academicians or students to say what they will in the public square. It instead keeps all actors involved with governance rowing as harmoniously as possible at their respective oars. Our charge to keep is the sound administration of Carolina as an institution consonant with its ethos, summarized as 'Lux et Libertas,' not to impede upon public discourse on campus that is healthy, constructive, and assumes good-faith participation from all."

    The resolutions came after politicized campus responses to the Supreme Court's Dobbs decision, which the Martin Center wrote about here.

    These resolutions build on previous work that UNC-Chapel Hill has done to protect free speech and academic freedom.

  • In 2015, UNC earned a "green light" rating from the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, the first public university in North Carolina to do so.
  • In 2017, the NC General Assembly adopted legislation to restore and preserve campus free speech. In response, UNC-Chapel Hill began including information about free speech during new-student orientation and reporting yearly on campus threats to free speech.
  • In 2018, the UNC Faculty Council adopted a version of the Chicago Principles. In that statement, faculty members affirmed, "The ability to speak freely, debate vigorously, and engage deeply with differing viewpoints is the bedrock of our aspirations at Carolina."
  • The university has now conducted two campus climate surveys to measure students' views of free expression on campus and hosts the Program for Public Discourse, which hosts and encourages debate and deliberation on campus.
  • These policies have laid a strong foundation for free speech and academic freedom at UNC-Chapel Hill. The rest of the UNC System should follow suit.

    Jenna A. Robinson is the president of the James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

More Troubling Economic News at Home and Abroad James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics DeSantis orders schools to reject Biden gender agenda


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Morale at the FBI has reportedly never been higher because agents no longer have to travel abroad to turn countries into banana republics.
Miami Beach, Florida, issued a state of emergency and imposed a curfew after two people were killed in separate fatal shooting incidents over the weekend.
A lawyer who previously advised ex-Trump lawyer Michael Cohen is expected to testify this week in the Manhattan grand jury investigation into former President Donald Trump’s alleged $130,000 hush money payment to porn actress Stormy Daniels during the 2016 election.
Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR) said during an interview over the weekend that he expects President Joe Biden to sign legislation that was unanimously passed by Congress to declassify U.S. intelligence on the origins of the COVID pandemic.
Former Project Veritas CEO James O’Keefe sat down with Ben Shapiro on this week’s episode of “The Sunday Special,” discussing how he plans on outsourcing undercover operatives equipped with hidden cameras in order to decentralize journalism.
The United States Supreme Court has already ruled equal representation of counties in state legislatures to be unconstitutional.
GA school teachers armed with guns
Sixteen people on the FBI’s terror watch-list — mixed in with record-breaking numbers of migrants illegally entering the United States — were stopped along the U.S.-Mexico border last month, authorities said.


Results of a new study have confirmed that the number of "true crime" podcasts produced has officially surpassed the number of actual murders in the world, per capita.
Switzerland‘s two largest banks are poised to merge in a deal regulators sought to help create stability as volatility rocks financial institutions around the globe.
Some Republican-led states, including Tennessee, are joining Democrats in actively resisting school choice policies after dozens of red states have already begun implementing such changes.
Former President Donald Trump will be arraigned in a Manhattan courthouse on Tuesday afternoon after being indicted this week, court officials said on Friday.
In what the media and political experts are hailing as an ingenious move, President Joe Biden has announced a plan to offer "hush money" to 330 million Americans so they won't tell anyone how bad he's doing as President.
Louisiana Republican lawmakers gained a significant upper hand after a longtime Democrat switched parties.
Leftist billionaire George Soros denied that he knows or has donated money to Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, who indicted former President Donald Trump on Thursday, but the prosecutor's campaign efforts were assisted by a group which Soros funds.
Today, Republican National Committee (RNC) Chairwoman Ronna McDaniel released the following statement on Biden’s Bankrupting America Tour stop in North Carolina:


Back to Top