A Middle Ground Is Possible in SCOTUS Redistricting Case | Eastern North Carolina Now | In Moore v. Harper, the Supreme Court can clarify what role state courts may take in the redistricting process

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Dr. Andy Jackson.

    When the US Supreme Court granted cert (agreed to hear the case) to plaintiff petitioners from the North Carolina General Assembly in Moore v. Harper, I noted that there were two likely outcomes of the case:

    If the court finds for the General Assembly, it could make a broad ruling that would effectively cut state judiciaries out of the redistricting process entirely or a narrow ruling holding that state judiciaries can hold congressional districts to be unconstitutional under state constitutions but that the actual drawing of maps must be done by state legislatures or bodies state legislatures designate to draw districts.

    Now two law professors have explained the legal reasoning behind the "narrow ruling" and held it up as "a sensible middle ground:"

    Later this term, the Supreme Court will decide Moore v. Harper, a case that has been pitched as a seismic clash between two troubling positions. One side asks for state legislatures to be freed from the traditional safeguards of state constitutional law, while the other asks the Court to effectively ignore the text of the Constitution. The Court should look beyond these unsupportable positions and take a commonsense middle ground. Fortunately, one is readily available: an approach that maintains the Constitution's emphasis on state legislatures without divorcing them from their traditional constitutional constraints...

    Missing from the debate has been a key principle that points to a sensible middle ground: A state constitution may limit a legislature's power over federal elections, but it may not give that power to somebody else. We need not an independent-state-legislature doctrine, but a constitutional-state-legislature doctrine...

    It means that state constitutional provisions can restrain legislative districting, such as by limiting the use of partisan gerrymandering. The broad challenge to state constitutional law in Moore therefore should fail. But it also means that the North Carolina courts do not have independent constitutional power to adopt their own map.

    You may recall that a group of court-appointed special masters drew North Carolina's current congressional districts earlier this year. Analysis has found that the court-drawn districts are a "Democratic protection plan that will likely spare them from the worst of an expected red wave this fall."

    That "constitutional-state-legislature doctrine" is the most likely outcome of Moore v. Harper and the only outcome that might result in a unanimous decision. Such a decision would affect congressional, but not state legislative, maps.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Poll shows faith in American dream is eroding as inflation takes hold Statewide, John Locke Foundation Guest Editorial, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal, Bloodless Warfare: Politics No Tenure? No Problem


Latest Bloodless Warfare: Politics

Treasurer Folwell, Local Government Commission Praise Turnaround, Hand Keys Back to Town
Today, Governor Roy Cooper greeted members of the North Carolina Christmas Tree Association to accept the Christmas trees and wreaths that will be displayed inside the State Capitol during the holiday season.
RALEIGH: Today, Governor Roy Cooper announced that the State is offering a reward of up to $25,000 for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible for the murder of Patrice Faison, age 38.
RALEIGH: Governor Roy Cooper appointed Scott Conrad as District Court Judge to Judicial District 25 serving Burke, Caldwell and Catawba counties today. He will fill the vacancy created by the retirement of The Honorable Burford Cherry. Conrad was also elected earlier this month for this seat.
The North Carolina Medium- and Heavy-Duty Electric Vehicle State Policy Bootcamp and Showcase emphasizes the importance of electric vehicles across the state
On Tuesday, Nov. 1, North Carolina’s Democrat Gov. Roy Cooper held a press conference at the Executive Mansion announcing the creation of a new commission tasked with reforming the University of North Carolina System’s governance.
RALEIGH: Today, Governor Roy Cooper appointed individuals to the Governor's Commission on the Governance of Public Universities in North Carolina.
The Governor joined officials from the NC Poultry Federation, Warren Farms, NC Department of Agriculture and Butterball for Annual NC Turkey Pardon


This week Lt. Governor Mark Robinson visited Machine Specialties Inc. in part of celebrating the 8th Annual National Apprenticeship Week.
RALEIGH: Today, Governor Roy Cooper celebrated Apprenticeship Week by touring the Caterpillar Pre-Apprenticeship Training in Welding Program at Central Carolina Community College.
NC TOWERS Hears Best Practices from UK Offshore Wind Delegation – Encourages Participation in Stakeholder Survey
Our Next Meeting Is Thursday November 17 At 6:00 Pm At King Chicken Restaurant.
(Advance, NC) – US Senator-Elect Ted Budd announced today that Jonathan Felts will serve as the Chairman of the transition team who will manage the process of setting up the new offices as Ted moves from the US House to the US Senate.
Today, U.S. Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC) and his colleagues Tammy Baldwin (D-WI), Susan Collins (R-ME), Rob Portman (R-OH), and Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ) announced they have reached a compromise on a bipartisan amendment to the Respect for Marriage Act
Governor Roy Cooper signed the following bill into law today: Senate Bill 255 & 43


Back to Top