Federal Appeals Court upholds ruling favoring Vance County over fired sheriff’s deputy | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has affirmed a lower court's ruling against a fired Vance County sheriff's deputy. The deputy had made claims against the county and sheriff including retaliation, disparate treatment, and a hostile work environment based on race and sexual orientation.

    "Justin White's tenure as a sheriff's deputy was short and troubled," according to the unanimous unsigned seven-page opinion.

    White's problems started in 2018, when he told a supervisor "won't nobody going to tell him what to do" about his job performance. That incident led to an official reprimand and five-day suspension.

    White later made false statements about activating his blue lights during a traffic stop in which he backed into another car, according to the 4th Circuit opinion. He then broke a woman's arm during an arrest on an "old arrest warrant for suspected shoplifting."

    Two days after the last incident, the sheriff accepted a senior officer's recommendation to fire White.

    While still working in the sheriff's department, White had filed an Equal Employment Opportunity Commission complaint against the sheriff, "claiming retaliation and disparate treatment based on his race and sex," according to the 4th Circuit.

    "After being fired, White filed an amended EEOC charge containing two new allegations," according to the opinion. "First, White alleged a higher-ranking officer called him gay and made a lewd joke about White's sexual orientation, for which the officer soon apologized. Second, White alleged finding a purple unicorn hat in his mailbox."

    White sued the county, sheriff's office, sheriff, and two other employees. "Black employees at the sheriff's office were subject to critical and hostile comments," according to the fired deputy's updated complaint.

    U.S. District Judge Terrence Boyle ruled in favor of all defendants in the case.

    "The district court correctly dismissed White's claims against the county on the ground it was not White's employer," according to the opinion. "Although White emphasizes the county hosted an employee orientation, gave White a personnel manual, and paid White's salary, his argument faces an insurmountable problem. North Carolina vests sheriffs (not counties) with 'the exclusive right to hire, discharge, and supervise the employees in [their] office[s]," and 'North Carolina courts interpret this statute to preclude county liability for personnel decisions made by sheriffs.'"

    "We also conclude the district court properly granted summary judgment for the remaining defendants."

    The court rejected White's claims of a hostile work environment, including his description of co-workers using the n-word on a handful of occasions. "White does not show the words here were received as racial epithets, nor does he demonstrate any of the statements were made or blessed by anyone with supervisory authority over him," the 4th Circuit judges wrote. "Similarly, White's sex-based hostile work environment claim fails because two isolated instances of teasing (one of which was followed by an apology) are not severe or pervasive enough to alter White's conditions of employment."

    The judges also panned the fired deputy's claim of disparate treatment. "White's performance was not satisfactory, and the circumstances of his termination do not give rise to a discriminatory inference."

    Nor can White succeed in claiming retaliation, according to the opinion. "There is a four-month gap between White's protected activity (complaining to the sheriff about perceived Title VII violations) and his adverse employment action (being fired), which is too long to support an inference of causation."

    "[T]he sheriff has consistently (and plausibly) maintained White was fired because he broke a woman's arm - the culmination of an otherwise unsuccessful stint at the sheriff's office," according to the opinion.

    Judges Toby Heytens, Paul Niemeyer, and Allison Jones Rushing decided the case.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

NC youth suicide rate nearly tripled in two decades Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Whatley tapped for national RNC leadership role


Latest State and Federal

House Intelligence Committee Chairman Mike Turner (R-OH) said that communist China is using TikTok to make its way into U.S. data systems as calls grow for the federal government to ban the app.
Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC) brought up left-wing riots during an interview over the weekend when asked about the recent media coverage surrounding the January 6 riot following the release of thousands of hours of video footage from the incident.
General Assembly leaders agreed to a bottom-line budget number last week, kicking off the biennium budget season. Senate Leader Phil Berger (R-Rockingham) and House Speaker Tim Moore (R-Cleveland) announced that General Fund spending would increase by 6.5% in the first year
House Intelligence Committee Chairman Mike Turner (R-OH) slammed Dr. Anthony Fauci, former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, over the weekend for making statements about the origins of COVID that are not supported by the findings of the U.S. intelligence
Senator John Kennedy (R-LA) said during an interview on Sunday that when he approached President Joe Biden about using the U.S. military to take out Mexican drug cartels, the president rebuffed him and said that it was a “bad idea.”
In a press conference Thursday, Senate Leader Phil Berger and House Speaker Tim Moore announced that an agreement has been reached between the chambers to expand the federal Medicaid entitlement program in North Carolina.


The U.S. Navy announced this week that it would be renaming a ship named for oceanographic pioneer Matthew Fontaine Maury because of Maury’s ties to the Confederacy during the later years of his life.
School staff, mental health professionals and the community can learn how to expand support for K-12 students and families experiencing mental and behavioral health issues in a webinar from 10 a.m. to noon, Wednesday, March 15.
Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis’ first memoir, which was launched ahead of an expected announcement that he will run for president in 2024, sold more copies in its first week than books from Donald Trump, Barack Obama, and Hillary Clinton.
North Carolina’s state motto offers a great guide to policymakers
White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre faced backlash late this week after falsely claiming during a White House press briefing that Daily Wire host Michael Knowles called for the “eradication of transgender people” during a speech at CPAC.
Energy Department Secretary Jennifer Granholm gushed about China’s approach to green energy in a Friday interview, saying she hoped that the U.S. could learn from China’s approach.


Are you currently looking for a new job? Scammers have ramped up efforts to take advantage of job seekers to trick them out of their money or steal their identity.


Back to Top