Restoring welfare to work requirements | Eastern North Carolina Now

Tom Campbell
    "He that will not work shall not eat (except by sickness he be disabled)," Captain John Smith told the 1609 Jamestown colonists. It wasn't a new idea, in fact it dates back to at least the first century when the Apostle Paul wrote the church in Thessalonica, "For even when we were with you, we used to give you this order: if anyone is not willing to work, then he is not to eat, either."

    Our nation was founded on the concept that we are sturdy, hardworking people, responsible for ourselves but also to our neighbors. We have long been willing to help those who could not help themselves and in that spirit of compassion allowed government programs to provide that help, especially during The Great Depression.

    We grew increasingly concerned that some who were able to help themselves had become too dependent on government assistance. In 1996, President Bill Clinton signed welfare to work legislation into law. Workfare, as it was called, proclaimed that those who were able had to work to continue what had become commonly known as welfare. Many predicted that poverty and hunger would soar as people left the welfare rolls, but just the opposite happened. The welfare rolls dropped from 5 to 2 million, largely among those who had never been married.

    There is nothing wrong with asking those in the wagon who can, to get out and help pull with the rest of us, former Texas Senator Phil Gramm explained. There is strong evidence that work is essential in helping establish a person's sense of self worth and dignity. We cannot allow our compassion and generosity to move us to lessen the requirements or qualifications, or attempt to justify why some aren't working. But we must also avoid the trap of calling those who receive these benefits worthless or lazy, as some have done.

    Workfare was a great concept and worked pretty well for more than 20 years but the Great Recession of 2008 knocked the props from under this success story. Unemployment soared and those who could not find work increasingly turned to government help. More than 40 states, including North Carolina, received waivers from the requirement that food stamp recipients must work, volunteer or be enrolled in job training programs in order to receive more than three months of benefits in a three-year period.

    The Department of Health and Human Services has announced our state will begin restoring the work requirement in counties over the next six months, affecting more than 100,000 current recipients. Maine reinstated these work provisions last year and the number of recipients dropped from 12,000 to 2,500.

    If we truly want to help people off "the public dole" and onto a road of self-sufficiency our legislature must help by restoring the earned income tax credit they eliminated several years ago. This is often the difference between making it or not to lower income citizens.

    We can debate what constitutes an "able" person or even what qualifies as work, but we strongly support the principle that those who can work should do so. We also recognize that some need help in the transition to self-sufficiency and North Carolina would be an uncaring state if we were not willing to provide that help.

    Publisher's note: Tom Campbell is former assistant North Carolina State Treasurer and is creator/host of NC SPIN, a weekly statewide television discussion of NC issues airing Sundays at 11:00 am on WITN-TV. Contact Tom at NC Spin.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )


( October 6th, 2015 @ 2:42 pm )
If we look at the history of recovery from the Great Depression, we find such projects as the Hoover Dam and many parks were made by the Civilian Conservation Corp (CCC) and WPA. If government tax money is being spent to help, then good public works projects are a perfect result. The people have a sense of self-worth over seeing themselves as tit-suckers.

The mistake of Title XX (War on Poverty / LBJ) is that it now is being wasted on a 5th generation of smart people enough to beat the system and keep on sucking. I have had many workers who were getting disability and prefer to work---as long as I don't report their income!

They are following the lead of the rich and corps who have loopholes aplenty to make money and pay no taxes. The shame is that we want to disparage the poor and then turn right around and complain about raising the Minimum Wage to the point a person can pay their bills without seeking public assistance.

Something is badly wrong with this picture and it could be fixed in a flash, if we had the moral courage to face some realities in American scheming over taxation.

Amateur Obama Status: Bullied by Putin, Economy Stalled, Talking Democrat Gibberish Related to State, My Spin, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics What took so long?


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

The International Atomic Energy Agency said in a confidential report this week that 2.5 tons of natural uranium have gone missing from a site in Libya that is not controlled by the government.
Multiple reports out of the U.S. Thursday indicated that Long John Silver's is still a thing. Experts confirmed their findings that the fast-food seafood restaurant, which is an actual thing, is in fact still in existence.
SVB Financial Group, the parent company of now-defunct Silicon Valley Bank, is considering bankruptcy as a possible mechanism to sell its other assets, according to a Wednesday report from Reuters.
RALEIGH: Today, Governor Roy Cooper toured Dawnsha’s Loving Childcare #2 in Greenville and highlighted his recommended budget investments in child care to support children, families and businesses.


After a train carrying highly toxic chemicals derailed in East Palestine, Ohio, President Joe Biden hopped on Air Force One, transferred to a train and went to … Ukraine.
Well, the day has finally arrived: your cute little parasitical clump of cells has popped out of one of the birthing persons in your relationship, and it's now suddenly a real human being. But what gender is it? It's hard to say. It could even be - fingers crossed - trans!
Officials with the United States Surface Transportation Board approved the merger of Kansas City Southern Railway Company and Canadian Pacific Railway Limited on Wednesday, marking the first combination of major rail companies in two decades.
Republican Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson said that he doesn’t consider himself a politician but rather a public servant, as he delivered the Republican response to Gov. Roy Cooper’s final State of the State address on Monday night.
General Mark Milley said Wednesday that he was not prepared to consider Russia’s downing of an American drone to be an act of war. “Incidents happen,” he said.
Author and podcast host Sam Harris said author and Daily Wire host Candace Owens “should not” have opinions on subjects like the vaccine, climate change, or the war in Ukraine, adding that people should also not listen to her about such matters.



Back to Top