Judge Rules Suit Against DEQ Will Proceed | Beaufort County Now | CLF filed suit against the NC Department of Environmental Quality on behalf of county residents Stephen Owens and Jillanne Gigi Badawi, alleging that they were aggrieved by the agency's determination that Iberdrola Renewables' Amazon Wind Farm East was not subject to state permitting standards.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's note: This post, by eengstrom, was originally published in the Issues section of Civitas's online edition.

    Judge Melissa Owens Lassiter of the Office of Administrative Hearings on Monday denied the Attorney General's motion to dismiss in Owens v. NC Department of Environmental Quality. The Perquimans County case, concerning a major wind energy facility, will now proceed to the merits of whether the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) acted contrary to statute when it notified Iberdrola Renewables that it is not subject to state permitting standards.


    On September 25, CLF filed suit against the NC Department of Environmental Quality on behalf of county residents Stephen Owens and Jillanne Gigi Badawi, alleging that they were aggrieved by the agency's determination that Iberdrola Renewables' Amazon Wind Farm East was not subject to state permitting standards.

    DEQ's counsel from the Attorney General's Office advanced several arguments in favor of dismissal, chief among which was that petitioners Owens and Badawi, who are husband and wife, lacked standing to bring their claims. The counsel from the AG's Office also argued that the couple failed to file their petition in a timely manner, despite the fact that DEQ never gave them proper notice of its decision.

    "DEQ never gave our clients notice of its decision because it did not consider them to be 'aggrieved,' and then tried to argue that their petition was not timely because it was filed after it gave notice to Iberdrola," CLF Lead Counsel Elliot Engstrom said. "If that argument were to hold up, administrative agencies in North Carolina would essentially be able to decide who could and could not bring suit against them based on their own determinations of who is 'aggrieved' by their decisions."

    Engstrom is joined by Dr. David Schnare, General Counsel for the Energy & Environment Legal Institute (E&E). Dr. Schnare has been admitted pro hac vice to practice before the Office of Administrative Hearings in this case, and helped craft the arguments against dismissal.

    "This is an important step forward," Schnare said. "The ruling affirms that the petitioners have standing to bring this suit under North Carolina law. We can now argue the merits of why and how the NC Department of Environmental Quality broke the law."

    The case will now proceed to a contested case hearing in early 2016.
Go Back

HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Thomas I was the wrong black guy
bill would remove illegals sent to TN, and move them to DE, NY, and CA
Several foreign airlines announced on Tuesday that they have started to cancel flights to the United States over concerns that 5G networks deployed near airports could cause interference issues.
As of 2020, across all fields 30.4% of successful grant abstracts contained at least one of the terms ‘equity,’ ‘diversity,’ ‘inclusion,’ ‘gender,’ ‘marginalize,’ ‘underrepresented,’ or ‘disparity.’
Billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk warned again on Tuesday that people need to be much more concerned about the collapse of civilization due to declining birthrates.
Dr. Anthony Fauci still insists it’s too early to say the pandemic is waning due to the contagious but mild Omicron variant.
Today, the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services announced another data dump of cases blamed on a nonreporting lab.

HbAD1

Writing "In God We Trust" on his cars and trying to buy loyalty and silence with arbitrary raises and position reclassifications will only keep maligned staff quiet for a short while.
The death of a democratic republic is not a new possibility; it has happened before in the pantheon of World history, and it can happen again; but, who will be to blame?
In terms of crime and public order, the middle decades of the 20th century were a period of remarkable tranquility.
More than 30 years ago, on June 26, 1987, Joyce Watkins, who at the time was in her late 30s, went with her then-boyfriend Charlie Dunn to pick up her four-year-old great-niece Brandi.
An NCAA task force has recommended high school students looking to play Division 1 or Division 2 sports shouldn’t have to submit their SAT or ACT scores as part of the recruiting process.
Who knew I had so many friends worried about my car’s warranty? Before Christmas it felt like a horde calling to warn me.
The Carolina Journal makes a wide sweeping evaluation of the news that most effects us here in North Carolina, and is distilled, here on BCN, for your clear understanding by the electronic means of video broadcast.
Breakthrough company brings first supersonic aircraft factory in the United States to Piedmont Triad International Airport site

HbAD2

 
Back to Top