Closely Split N.C. Helped Spur Bill of Rights | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's note: The author of this post is Dr. Troy Kickler, who writes for the Carolina Journal, John Hood Publisher.

    RALEIGH     Many political pundits now consider North Carolina a battleground state. Some things, however, are not new.

    During the 1787-89 debates over ratifying the U.S. Constitution, for example, North Carolina's population was divided over the necessity of a new constitution and what became known as the Bill of Rights.

    After the framers drafted their document at the 1787 Philadelphia Convention, it was submitted to respective state ratification conventions for approval. According to Article 7 in the Constitution: "The ratification of the conventions of nine states shall be sufficient for the establishment of this Constitution between the states so ratifying the same."

    Nine states approved the Constitution, and the new Union was formed. In some, the vote was unanimous (Georgia, 26-0, and New Jersey, 38-0). In others, the vote was divided (Pennsylvania, 46-23, and South Carolina, 149-73).

    Widespread criticism and skepticism, however, remained in key states: New York, Virginia, Rhode Island, and North Carolina. In New York, the recurring skepticism prompted Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay to pick up quills, dip them into inkwells, and pen 85 essays that became known as The Federalist - one of the best commentaries regarding the Constitution's meaning.

    In North Carolina, Edentonian James Iredell, using the pseudonym Marcus, explained the Constitution's meaning and pointed out the necessity of its adoption. Tar Heel Federalists, such as Iredell and William Davie, believed the "general government" needed more "energy," such as more authority to tax and be able to have an army to defend the fledgling nation.

    A strong Anti-Federalist sentiment, however, remained in North Carolina. Many North Carolinians remembered the Parliamentary abuses before the Revolutionary War and questioned giving more authority to what would become the federal government.

    Tar Heel Anti-Federalists, including the influential yet somewhat reticent Willie Jones and the vocal and somewhat bumbling Judge Samuel Spencer, questioned handing any more power from the individuals and the states to the general government.

    Unlike other states, there were two ratification conventions in North Carolina. One was in Hillsborough (1788) and the other in Fayetteville (1789). James Madison, the "Father of the Constitution," remarked more than once that the state ratifying conventions provided the key to unlocking an understanding of the Constitution's meaning.

    That said, many historians consider North Carolina's ratification convention minutes to be the most revealing and balanced regarding the debate between Federalists and Anti-Federalists. (In most states, Federalists paid for transcribers, and many times convention minutes give the impression of erudite Federalists engaging Anti-Federalist ignorance; the Hillsborough minutes instead reveal a sophisticated exchange among delegates with opposing beliefs.)

    At Hillsborough, Anti-Federalists preferred a quick vote and dismissal while the Federalists desired opportunities to provide commentary for the record. Ultimately, the delegates debated and discussed such issues as defining local and state responsibilities and the necessity of paper money and religious oaths of office.

    Much debate centered on questions regarding taxation. In many ways, the Regulator spirit remained in many parts of North Carolina, and many delegates were concerned with local authority or wanted a declaration of rights added to the submitted constitution.

    In Hillsborough, the delegates voted, 184-84, neither to reject nor ratify the U.S. Constitution. Some historians have called this "the great refusal."

    In subsequent months, debate continued not only in North Carolina but also in other states regarding the necessity of the Bill of Rights. After being assured that a declaration of rights would be added, in November 1789 North Carolina ratified the Constitution by a vote of 195 to 77 at the Fayetteville Convention. The Old North State finally had joined the new Union.

    In the end, North Carolina's heated political debate and strong dissent contributed significantly to ensuring that Americans have a Bill of Rights.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Priceless Christmas Gifts Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Friday Interview: Big Money's Impact on College Football


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Haley wants big corporations to dictate immigration policy
Local woman Kelly Reese somehow remained completely unmoved today despite her husband Tom reciting every single word from the Lord of The Rings movies from memory.
The mezuzah attached to the front door frame of our house has a little rolled scroll inside that has been blessed by a Rabbi.
A lawyer representing former President Donald Trump told Daily Wire Editor Emeritus Ben Shapiro that Justice Department special investigator Jack Smith was putting the American justice system in jeopardy after he brought another indictment against Trump.


State Supreme Court justices split on a decision to vacate a Court of Appeals ruling addressing a media outlet's "fair report privilege." The decision prompted commentary from four of the court's seven justices.
After announcing major budget cuts to the city’s police force and Education Department last week, New York City Democratic Mayor Eric Adams blamed the federal government for leaving him with no choice but to strip money away from New Yorkers to deal with the illegal immigration crisis.
A local Chick-fil-A ground to a halt Wednesday after an employee accidentally told another employee, "My pleasure." As a result, the pair of employees became trapped in an endless loop of "my pleasure" with no end in sight.
The Iranian-backed terrorist group Hezbollah reportedly caused “heavy damage” to an Israeli military base on Monday after it launched a rocket and drone attack at the army base.
The state Supreme Court has agreed to hear a New Bern eye surgeon's legal challenge against North Carolina's certificate-of-need law.
There were no survivors on Kfar Aza's street of nightmares, where evidence remains as proof of Hamas atrocities


proposed legislation would provide 10 year prison sentence, huge fines


Back to Top