Leandro Judge, in Apparent Reversal, Tries To Compel Lawmakers to Fund Planned Requirements | Beaufort County Now | The judge in the ongoing Leandro school funding case has signed an order that attempts to compel the General Assembly to fund the components of the Comprehensive Remedial Plan agreed to by both the defendants and plaintiffs in the case last year.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is David N. Bass.

Photo: Maya Reagan / Carolina Journal

    The judge in the ongoing Leandro school funding case has signed an order that attempts to compel the General Assembly to fund the components of the Comprehensive Remedial Plan agreed to by both the defendants and plaintiffs in the case last year.

    The move by Superior Court Judge David Lee appears to be a reversal from remarks he made during a hearing in April, when he pledged to not tell lawmakers how to spend money on public education.

    "If the State fails to implement actions described in the Comprehensive Remedial Plan ... it will then be the duty of this Court to enter a judgment declaring relief and such other relief as needed to correct the wrong," Judge Lee's latest order states.

    Republican lawmakers were quick to denounce Lee's declaration.

    "A court has no more authority to direct the legislature to spend money or enact policy than the legislature does to direct a trial judge to decide a case," Sen. Deanna Ballard, R-Watauga, says in a statement. "If Judge Lee wants a say in education policy, he can run for the state legislature. That is the only way his opinions will have any weight."

    In his order, Lee praised House Bill 946 and Gov. Roy Cooper's budget, both of which would fund the first two years of the eight-year remedial plan.

    The contents of H.B. 946 are built from multiple sources, including Cooper's proposed 2021 budget, the nearly 300-page report from the California-based consulting firm WestEd, Cooper's Commission on Access to Sound Basic Education, and the Comprehensive Remedial Plan itself.

    H.B. 946 funds seven priority areas, including ensuring "well-prepared, high-quality" principals and teachers in schools, new mechanisms for measuring student performance, and support for low-performing schools.

    By law, the General Assembly is the governing body with the sole authority to allocate money. Even so, Democrats have long hoped the judicial branch would impose funding requirements on lawmakers.

    "Judge Lee is setting the stage for a confrontation with the General Assembly that will test one of the foundations of our state government: the separation of powers," said Dr. Terry Stoops, director of the Center for Effective Education at the John Locke Foundation.

    "Judge Lee and the Leandro plaintiffs and defendants are free to appear before the members of the General Assembly to make their case for full funding of the Comprehensive Remedial Plan. And the members of the General Assembly are free to accept or reject their request based on the budgeting authority reserved to the legislative branch in the N.C. Constitution."

    Republican lawmakers have made overtures to Lee to involve him in the process. In February 2020, Ballard invited the judge to speak to members of the Senate Education Committee, an invitation he declined.

    According to Lee's order, the next steps will require lawmakers to submit a progress report on "fulfilling the terms and conditions" of the order by Aug 6.

    The Leandro lawsuit dates to 1994, when five rural school districts sued the state over education funding. The N.C. Supreme Court has ruled twice since then — in 1997 and again in 2004 — that the state has a constitutional obligation to provide a "sound, basic education" to all students.

    "The first judge assigned to oversee compliance with the Leandro ruling, Howard Manning, pointed out repeatedly that throwing more money at public schools would not guarantee that children receive a sound, basic education," noted Stoops. "Judge Lee's endorsement of a plan would require the legislature to add billions of additional taxpayer dollars to the state education budget belies the wisdom of his former colleague."
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

orphans in New York were victims of Fauci experimentation
The staff of the N.C. ABC met Tuesday, Nov. 9, with representatives from 34 local ABC boards across the state to talk about ways to improve the distribution of high-demand, low-supply, allocated spirituous liquor products.
On Wednesday, Texas GOP Senator Ted Cruz grilled Deputy Attorney General Kristen Clarke over the Biden Justice Department ordering the FBI to investigate alleged “threats” against school board members and teachers.
In September, the chancellor of UNC-Wilmington, Jose Sartarelli, announced his plan to retire next year.
The Beaufort County Commissioners will get another bite at the patriotic apple, a fruit they far too often hold in great disdain, to pass this necessary resolution.
A controversial environmental program controlled by North Carolina’s attorney general and funded by hog farm proceeds returned today to the N.C. Supreme Court. The court must decide whether the AG can maintain control of the funding moving forward.


Johns Hopkins’ Dr. Marty Makary is speaking out about blanket vaccine mandates that are “ruining lives” and bizarrely discount natural immunity, which he said studies have shown to be 27 times more effective than vaccinated immunity.
I have been following the Sheppard case and the Franks case the last couple of years with a somewhat dispassionate interest. The wheels of justice grind and they do grind slow.
On Tuesday, just before 1 p.m. a shooter allegedly injured multiple people at Oxford High School in a suburban area roughly 45 miles north of Detroit.
Montana State University (MSU) professors and other faculty members have taken it upon themselves to verbally accost students protesting MSU’s mask mandate. In emails obtained by The Daily Wire, at least five MSU professors and faculty used work emails to harass and swear at engineering students.
Today, Governor Roy Cooper and North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Mandy K. Cohen, M.D. provided an update on the state’s COVID-19 key metrics and trends.
A federal judge in Kentucky issued a preliminary injunction on Tuesday against Democrat President Joe Biden’s coronavirus vaccine mandate for federal contractors and subcontractors in three states.


A top N.C. Senate education leader is criticizing Attorney General Josh Stein for his handling of the state’s defense in the long-running Leandro school funding lawsuit.


Back to Top