Appeals Court rejects lawsuit challenging recent farm laws | Beaufort County Now | A unanimous three-judge panel of the N.C. Court of Appeals has affirmed a lower courtís decision to dismiss a lawsuit challenging 2017 and 2018 amendments to North Carolinaís Right to Farm Act.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    A unanimous three-judge panel of the N.C. Court of Appeals has affirmed a lower court's decision to dismiss a lawsuit challenging 2017 and 2018 amendments to North Carolina's Right to Farm Act.

    The Rural Empowerment Association for Community Help, N.C. Environmental Justice Community Action Network, and Waterkeeper Alliance filed suit in 2019 against the amendments.

    The changes were designed to tighten restrictions on nuisance lawsuits filed against farms. Lawmakers have been dealing with the issue since "hundreds of plaintiffs" filed nuisance lawsuits against N.C. hog farms in 2013.

    "Our State's long-asserted interest in promoting and preserving agriculture, forestry, horticulture, livestock, and animal husbandry activities and production within North Carolina clearly rests within the scope of the State's police power," wrote Judge John Tyson for the unanimous court.

    The 2017 and 2018 farms laws "are intended to promote agricultural and forestry activities and production in North Carolina by defining and limiting nuisance claims from agricultural, forestry, and related operations," Tyson added.

    "The asserted and purported interference in the statute with the enjoyment of property is reasonable and clearly rests within the General Assembly's enumerated powers," the opinion continued. "By passage of an act with the signature of the Governor of North Carolina, the General Assembly can modify or amend the common law or amend, replace, or repeal a state statute."

    "Limiting potential nuisance liability from agricultural, forestry, and related operations helps ensure the State's stated goal to protect agricultural activities in North Carolina and to encourage the availability and continued 'production of food, fiber, and other products,'" Tyson wrote.

    Tyson and colleagues Fred Gore and Jefferson Griffin rejected a series of arguments from the environmental groups opposing the 2017 and 2018 farm laws.

    Opponents claimed the changes to rules surrounding nuisance lawsuits violated their rights to the enjoyment of their property. They also labeled the laws unconstitutional as "private laws" designed to protect the swine industry. They claimed new limits on nuisance lawsuits would deprive them of a right to a jury trial.

    "The Amendments are a valid exercise of legislative and the State's police powers, do not violate the Law of the Land Clause or Due Process, are not a special or private law, and do not deprive a prospective plaintiff of the right to a jury trial," Tyson concluded.
Go Back

HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Don't you think it's time for conservative county government?
A unanimous three-judge panel has upheld North Carolinaís new congressional and legislative election maps.
Imposter President Joseph R. Biden, America's First Idiot President, but America's second Non Patriot President, is the chronic, constant tool of the Marxists manning his administration, believes that the "Browning of America" is the harbinger to forever enact the destruction of our Republic.
The Carolina Journal makes a wide sweeping evaluation of the news that most effects us here in North Carolina, and is distilled, here on BCN, for your clear understanding by the electronic means of video broadcast.
The Carolina Journal makes a wide sweeping evaluation of the news that most effects us here in North Carolina, and is distilled, here on BCN, for your clear understanding by the electronic means of video broadcast.
This past week about 98.8% of people in NC were estimated to pose no threat of passing along COVID-19 to anyone. That is the lowest estimate recorded since this same time last year, during the height of cold and flu (respiratory viruses) season.
The Carolina Journal makes a wide sweeping evaluation of the news that most effects us here in North Carolina, and is distilled, here on BCN, for your clear understanding by the electronic means of video broadcast.
The Gavi Vaccine Alliance is run by the Gates Foundation and they published a paper in 2018 in which it made reference to its Infuse program. This paper should be required reading for every parent of young children.
The Daily Wireís Matt Walsh on Friday night was suspended from Twitter over tweets he posted recognizing biological realities and not so-called ďgender identity.Ē

HbAD1

The Carolina Journal makes a wide sweeping evaluation of the news that most effects us here in North Carolina, and is distilled, here on BCN, for your clear understanding by the electronic means of video broadcast.
Is having a college degree a critical dimension in becoming a business leader for those running North Carolinaís largest corporations?
Kendall Klett, recently fired from the N.C. Department of Health and Human Services, explains why she has taken a stand against the department's mandatory COVID vaccination policy.
Unnerved and stretched thin. Thatís a good description of how my extended family is feeling heading into the new year.
The Carolina Journal makes a wide sweeping evaluation of the news that most effects us here in North Carolina, and is distilled, here on BCN, for your clear understanding by the electronic means of video broadcast.
After the Biden administrationís Defense Department, through the U.S. Navyís COVID Consolidated Disposition Authority, issued a directive that would threaten Navy SEALs declining the vaccine by removing them from special warfare, reducing their salaries, and forcing them to repay training.
Entrepreneurs experience mental health issues that often go unnoticed. Recent studies have indicated that the majority of people in business are sleep-deprived and overworked.
On Thursday, January 20, the Republican National Committee (RNC) will host a roundtable event in Greensboro discussing one year under the Biden administration.
The Carolina Journal makes a wide sweeping evaluation of the news that most effects us here in North Carolina, and is distilled, here on BCN, for your clear understanding by the electronic means of video broadcast.

HbAD2

 
Back to Top