Orange County plaintiffs ask N.C. Supreme Court to revive their zoning challenge | Eastern North Carolina Now | Orange County property owners want the N.C. Supreme Court to review their challenge of a local rezoning decision.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    Orange County property owners are urging the N.C. Supreme Court to take up their challenge against a local rezoning. The owners contend their case "involves legal principles of major significance to the jurisprudence of this State."

    A petition filed Tuesday asks the state's highest court to take up the case Mitchell v. Orange County. In May a unanimous three-judge panel of the N.C. Court of Appeals affirmed a trial judge's decision to dismiss the suit.

    Appellate judges determined that the property owners lacked legal standing to challenge the rezoning. Because the rezoning decision was "legislative" in nature, the plaintiffs would need to prove more than "diminution of one's property value."

    "In such a case, a landowner must show that (s)he will suffer 'special damages distinct from the rest of the community,'" wrote Judge Chris Dillon.

    The property owners contend that the Appeals Court has misapplied state Supreme Court precedent.

    "This Court is the ultimate arbiter of North Carolina law. When this Court decides an issue, the Court of Appeals must follow," according to the petition.

    "In Blades v. City of Raleigh, this Court established that neighboring property owners have standing to challenge a zoning ordinance in a declaratory judgment action if they live in an area affected by the ordinance," the plaintiffs' lawyers wrote. "This Court has since applied that standard in cases involving legislative zoning challenges, and the Court of Appeals is required to do the same."

    "While the Court of Appeals applied this Court's precedent in the first few decades following Blades, recently, the Court of Appeals has strayed, even claiming of late that its own case law has superseded the standard set forth by this Court."

    "Getting the standing requirement wrong matters," the property owners' lawyers argued. "The North Carolina Constitution provides that our 'courts shall be open,' and 'every person for an injury done him in his lands, goods, person, or reputation shall have remedy by due course of law.'"

    The Court of Appeals has been "imposing barriers to standing that this Court has never sanctioned nor has the General Assembly enacted," according to the petition. "The Court of Appeals repeatedly and often has imposed a special damages requirement for standing in legislative zoning cases that is both absent from section 160D-1401 [of the N.C. General Statutes], which governs those cases, and is contrary to this Court's precedent."

    "As a result, the lower courts have been denying neighboring property owners who live in areas affected by zoning ordinances their right under section 160D-1401 to seek judicial review of legislative zoning decisions, and those zoning decisions are now essentially immune from judicial review."

    The neighbors are challenging Research Triangle Logistics Park, an industrial park in Hillsborough that would include 12 acres of land that had been zoned for residential use. Plaintiffs contend the Orange County commissioners engaged in "arbitrary and capricious" "illegal spot zoning" when approving the project.

    The state Supreme Court is under no obligation to take up an appeal of a unanimous Appeals Court decision.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Researchers at Yale University are challenging the idea of irreversible cardiac death after new technology tested on pigs restored some of the animals’ heart and brain cells an hour after dying.
President Biden just solved the economy by creating thousands of IRS jobs! We know you've always dreamed of working for the IRS, but do you have what it takes?
Teach yourself to be disobedient to bad orders
Is the legacy media ever embarrassed or angry that it consistently gets fed false information — and repeats it verbatim — in order to push anti-conservative narratives, or does it enjoy being a mouthpiece for the government?
A U.S. federal appeals court issued a stay on Saturday temporarily halting Democrat President Joe Biden’s vaccine mandate that would have required companies with at least 100 employees to get vaccinated for the coronavirus or be tested weekly.
After a critically acclaimed first season that was allegedly watched by some people, the producers of the January 6th Hearings have sadly confirmed that their star Liz Cheney will not be returning for season 2.
Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis slammed doctors who perform transgender surgeries on young children during a press conference this week, saying that they needed to be held legally liable for their actions.


A fired Durham police sergeant is asking the N.C. Supreme Court to permit his lawsuit accusing the city of violating his state constitutional rights.
The U.S. Department of Justice is moving to unseal more documents related to the raid on former President Donald Trump’s home in Florida but will not unseal the underlying FBI affidavit because it claims that doing so will damage the ongoing criminal investigation.
Top House and Senate Republicans are moving to put an end to Democrat President Joe Biden’s vaccine mandate, calling the move “a highly inappropriate invasion of what should be a personal medical decision for every American.”
In order to make his upcoming Sunday message as entertaining as possible, a local pastor plans to stay up late in search of the perfect Bible verse to compliment the hilarious personal experience he wants to share.
Jeff Bezos’ Blue Origin successfully launched its sixth human mission on Thursday, sending six people into suborbital space.
Former President Donald Trump claimed in a statement Monday afternoon that the federal agents who executed a search warrant at his Florida home last week took his passports.
Time to clean house. Get out and vote and get 10 other conservatives to do the same thing
Kansas Democrat Governor Laura Kelly came out against Democrat President Joe Biden’s vaccine mandate on Friday, saying that she does not believe it’s the best solution and that it’s too late to implement it.


Back to Top