Appeals Court sides with Town of Matthews in dispute over fatal tree fall | Eastern North Carolina Now | A unanimous N.C. Court of Appeals panel has ruled that the Town of Matthews will not face legal liability for a fatal tree fall in 2018.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The Town of Matthews will not face legal liability in the case of a fatal tree fall during a 2018 winter storm. A unanimous N.C. Court of Appeals panel ruled in favor of the town Tuesday.

    "The Town of Matthews is like many suburbs in our growing State. Though new businesses and homes have appeared in recent years, the natural charm of the Town is preserved in its several parks and the canopy of trees arching its streets," wrote Judge April Wood for the unanimous court. "East John Street is one such street where towering oaks bow to the procession of traffic below. A winter storm in late 2018, however, disrupted the tranquility."

    "Paul and Dianne Ladd drove through this storm and down East John Street when a tree fell atop them - killing Mr. Ladd and injuring Mrs. Ladd," Wood wrote.

    Dianne Ladd and her husband's estate sued the tree's owners in 2019 for wrongful death, negligence, and negligent infliction of emotional distress, according to Wood's opinion.

    The affected property owners, Thomas and Mary Funderburk, later cross-sued the town. The Funderburks argued that Matthews had a duty to protect people on local streets from the danger of a falling tree.

    A trial judge rejected Matthews' motion for summary judgment. A judgment favoring Matthews would have exempted the town from legal action. The Appeals Court ruling reverses the trial court's decision and grants Matthews protection from the Funderburks' complaint.

    The Appeals Court decision relies on a 1974 court precedent dealing with Chapter 160A of the N.C. General Statutes. That chapter deals with cities and towns.

    "[I]n Bowman v. Town of Granite Falls, we held that a potentially dangerous tree on private property and near a street did not create an affirmative duty under Section 160A before the tree fell onto a car," Wood wrote. "The present case aligns more with Bowman. The Section 160A affirmative duty does not require preventative measures for trees on private property which are not already an obstruction. We therefore hold the statute does not apply to the Town's inaction here."

    Appellate judges rejected the argument that Matthews faced a duty to remove the tree before it toppled. "The tree ordinance authorizes the Town to enter private property and cut down trees in specific circumstances," Wood wrote. "Having empowered itself to do a thing does not mean, as in this case, that it must have done that thing. This is true even if the tree was within the Town's zone of control."

    "The Town did not have an affirmative duty under this State's statutes or the Town's own ordinances to preemptively cut down the tree on private property," Wood concluded. "In opting not to take advantage of the authority it had under its tree ordinance, the Town engaged in an exclusively governmental action. We thus hold that the Town is entitled to the defense of governmental immunity."

    Judges Toby Hampson and Jefferson Griffin joined Wood's opinion. Since the ruling was unanimous, the N.C. Supreme Court faces no obligation to take the case if the property owners decide to appeal.
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




Treasurer Folwell Holds Public Forum on Medical Debt De-Weaponization Act Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics U.S. Supreme Court to hear N.C. redistricting dispute on Dec. 7


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Acomplaint filed with the State Board of Elections this week alleges that the Neighbors on Call Political Action Committee is taking in-kind contributions from the state Democratic Party that exceed the limits set by campaign finance laws.
A California district superintendent recently announced that a high school football team was no longer allowed to display the Thin Blue Line at its games, but that didn’t stop Saugus High School players.
More sever penalties for those who profit from drugs are needed
Babylon Bee CEO Seth Dillon revealed that the Christian satire outlet ultimately gained a broader audience by refusing to delete a post that caused the former management of Twitter to shutter its account.
The United States' soccer match against England ended in a tie, handing the U.S. team victory as the country which last beat the other in a war wins the tiebreaker.
The Biden administration is close to granting a license to Chevron to resume pumping oil in Venezuela, following previous reporting that President Joe Biden would ease sanctions on the socialist country to allow the U.S. oil company to continue production.
As inflation comes home to roost for many American families preparing to celebrate Thanksgiving, leadership at one of the largest poultry producers in the nation is denying that households will shift from turkey to other alternatives.
N.C. State Treasurer Dale Folwell discussed issues surrounding several towns in the state Tuesday during his monthly “Ask Me Anything” virtual press conference.

HbAD1

Elon Musk may release information on Twitter’s internal discussions regarding censorship of stories about Hunter Biden’s laptop prior to the 2020 election, the newly-established CEO suggested Wednesday.
A new Civitas Poll of North Carolina parents has new information on their views of teachers and what is happening in the classroom
Disney fired CEO Bob Chapek in a dramatic development Sunday, bringing back its former boss and ending a disastrous tenure that saw the entertainment giant become a value-hemorrhaging caricature of wokeness.
A local retailer is making waves after announcing its most dramatic Black Friday sale ever, in which every item in the store is marked down to whatever the price was before Biden became President.
Readers know that when you watch CBS News, much of what you see is spin, but a report regarding Hunter Biden’s infamous laptop from the legacy media network on Monday really takes the cake.
Famed author Salman Rushdie lost the use of one hand and an eye after an attack in August by a man who stormed the stage and stabbed him in the neck and torso several times — his agent confirmed last week.
Cooper makes state personnel office like Soviet political commissars
On Tuesday, Nov. 1, North Carolina’s Democrat Gov. Roy Cooper held a press conference at the Executive Mansion announcing the creation of a new commission tasked with reforming the University of North Carolina System’s governance.
President Joe Biden (D) responded to questions about his age and fitness for office during an interview that aired Sunday morning by saying that he could “drop dead tomorrow.”

HbAD2

 
Back to Top