NC State asks federal court to dismiss athletics sex abuse case | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    N.C. State University is asking a federal court to dismiss a lawsuit from an unidentified former student-athlete. The athlete claims he was sexually abused by the school's former sports medicine director during treatment in 2015.

    The student, identified in court papers as John Doe, filed suit earlier this year. He was the second former Wolfpack athlete to bring a legal complaint against Robert Murphy Jr. Former soccer player Benjamin Locke filed the first suit last August.

    Locke had accused Murphy of improperly touching Locke's genitals during 75 to 100 massages between August 2015 and May 2017. The earlier suit also alleged that N.C. State took no action after a coach warned a senior athletics official in February 2016 that Murphy was engaging in conduct consistent with sexually "grooming" student-athletes.

    Doe's suit cited two cases of improper touching. "Doe contends that it was not until September 2022, after a different plaintiff filed a complaint in a different case pending before this Court, that he discovered that NC State's 'actions and inactions' had harmed him," the university's attorneys wrote in a memorandum Friday supporting their motion to dismiss Doe's case.

    "Doe asserts violations of Title IX for deliberate indifference and hostile educational environment against NC State based on alleged misconduct that occurred in 2015," N.C. State's lawyers argued. "Doe has failed to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. Additionally, Doe's claims for conduct that occurred more than seven years ago are untimely under the applicable statute of limitations for Title IX."

    The memorandum references the two allegations of inappropriate contact. "This conduct prompted Doe to 'doubt' whether Murphy's conduct was within the confines of 'professionally acceptable athletic training technique[s] for a licensed athletic trainer,' and, thereafter, Doe refused to 'allow Murphy to treat him when he needed assistance from the Sports Medicine Department trainers.'"

    "The Complaint includes no allegation that Doe reported the alleged inappropriate touching that caused him to refuse to work with Murphy," according to the N.C. State memorandum. "Doe alleges only that, in 2016, the head soccer coach told the Senior Associate Athletic Director that Murphy was 'engaging in what he suspected was sexual grooming of male student-athletes.' Significantly, Doe does not allege that Murphy engaged in any inappropriate conduct directed towards Doe after the report to the Senior Associate Athletic Director in 2016 or even that Doe was still enrolled as a student at NC State at the time of the alleged report."

    Doe read Locke's complaint in September 2022, according to university attorneys. "Doe

    alleges that reading Locke's complaint informed Doe that NC State's 'actions and inactions' had harmed Doe."


    The university could not have addressed misbehavior that Doe never reported, according to the memorandum. "Despite Doe's 'doubts' about Murphy's behavior, Doe does not allege that he ever reported the sexual harassment to anyone at NC State."

    Doe should have brought his complaint within three years of the alleged assault, N.C. State's lawyers argued. That's the applicable statute of limitations.

    The university counters a possible argument about a similar case involving Ohio State University in 2022. "The court allowed 110 plaintiffs' Title IX claims arising out of decades-old misconduct to proceed, noting allegations of a decades-long cover up that included the university's knowledge and concealment of the misconduct, destruction of records, and misleading of students by telling them that no one had previously complained," according to the N.C. State memorandum. "In contrast, Doe does not allege a cover-up of any kind by NC State." The Ohio State plaintiffs "also alleged that they did not know that they had been abused. In contrast, Doe's Complaint includes allegations that he had knowledge that Murphy had behaved inappropriately."

    As the university seeks to have Doe's case dismissed, the Locke case sits before U.S. District Judge Louise Wood Flanagan. Flanagan issued an order in February dismissing Chancellor Randy Woodson, former Athletic Director Debbie Yow, and former Associate Athletic Director Lester Clinkscales from the Locke suit.
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




Carolina Journal by Video CCLII: DeSantis v. Biden, SBI v. Cooper, and Veto Overrides Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Unaffiliated voters defend lawsuit against NC state elections board


HbAD0

Latest State and Federal

The most interesting candidate in the 2024 election has to be Democratic hopeful Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. – if not for his career path and family history, then for his willingness to buck the D.C. establishment narrative and attack The Uniparty.
57% of North Carolinians support legislation to prohibit abortions after the first trimester, with exceptions.
Former President Donald Trump’s social media company is seeking $3.78 billion in damages in a defamation lawsuit against The Washington Post for publishing “an egregious hit piece” earlier this month that accused the company of securities fraud and other wrongdoings.
Special provisions continue to thrive in North Carolina. The last biennium budget was loaded with special projects, and the forthcoming one may be no different.
The University of Minnesota was the subject of a civil rights complaint last week for enacting a research program that offers applicants a $6,000 stipend but is restricted to students of color.
South Carolina Republican Sen. Tim Scott announced his entry into the 2024 presidential election on Monday, smacking President Joe Biden while touting his own up-from-poverty story.

HbAD1

One of the largest public state pension funds in the nation has routinely accepted shareholder resolution advice from a woke proxy advisory firm based in San Francisco
Special counsel John Durham‘s long-awaited report serves as a guide for how Congress can further investigate the Russiagate controversy, according to a top GOP lawmaker.
Sen. Tim Scott (R-SC) slammed ABC’s “The View” during a presidential campaign stop over the weekend in Iowa while announcing that he was going on the show this week.
The NAACP Board of Directors issued a statement on Saturday warning black Americans that the state of Florida was not a safe place for them and included an official “travel advisory” calling the state “openly hostile” – but the board’s chairman, Leon Russell, apparently lives in Florida himself.
Children in grades K-3 in North Carolina have surpassed the rest of the nation when it comes to their early-literacy skills. That’s according to N.C. Superintendent of Public Instruction Catherine Truitt, who shared the news at Tuesday’s Council of State meeting.

HbAD2

Ty Cobb, a former White House lawyer for President Donald Trump, said that he believes that the former president will get convicted in the federal criminal investigation into his handling of classified materials and that he will ultimately go to prison over it.

HbAD3

 
Back to Top