Appropriating the Atlantic Coast Pipeline | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's note: The author of this post is Joseph Coletti, who is a Senior Fellow for the John Locke Foundation.

    If the governor directs where money goes and for what purpose, is it government spending?

    That is just one of a number of questions that arose after Gov. Roy Cooper announced that Atlantic Coast Pipeline (ACP) and its utility partners had agreed, hours after it received regulatory clearance from the Division of Water Quality, to pay $57.8 million into an escrow fund for three purposes specified by the governor. The governor will choose the third-party institution that will hold the escrow account, and there is no indication the plan anticipates going through the normal appropriation process.

    Gerry Cohen, former special counsel to the General Assembly, compared this arrangement to Golden LEAF, which provides grants to private organizations from the Master Settlement Agreement between tobacco companies and states. The money for Golden LEAF, however, is appropriated each year by the General Assembly, but Gov. Cooper hopes to have these funds held in a private institution outside the state treasury where he would direct its use through executive order.

    Former House Majority Leader Skip Stam considers the payment a fine that should go to public schools according to the state constitution. That may be accurate, even though only a portion of the payment is based on anticipated harms to the environment, with the rest dedicated to economic development and renewable energy projects. Even those funds for the environment are aimed at mitigation and are not considered a penalty. Stam also calls it an "exaction," which is more like an impact fee than a fine for wrongdoing. If it is a fee instead of a fine, then there is no requirement for the money to go to education.

    The agreement also does its best to avoid another section of the N.C. Constitution. Article V, Section 7 states, "No money shall be drawn from the State treasury but in consequence of appropriations made by law," that is, by the General Assembly in the state budget. There is also a statutory requirement specifying that the governor must submit his proposed spending plan or revisions to the existing plan to the General Assembly, not by an executive order.

    Although the agreement declares, "Nothing in this Memorandum shall be construed as affecting the authorities of any party," the money trail specifically avoids the normal appropriations process both in the creation of an escrow account and in directing the money through executive order instead of state budget appropriations.

    Gov. Cooper is no stranger to overstepping his bounds in directing money from legal agreements, as with North Carolina's portion of a 2015 multi-state settlement with Standard and Poor's overinflated mortgage ratings. In that case, as Attorney General, he gave his ideas about how the state should use the $21.5 million payment.

    Perhaps the most direct analogy is Gov. Mike Easley's 2001 attempt, with the General Assembly's blessing, to shore up the General Fund with $225 million intended for the Teachers and State Employees Retirement System despite prohibitions against misappropriating pension funds. The courts eventually agreed with state employees that the move violated both state and federal constitutions and ordered the funds be repaid.

    What gives this agreement between Gov. Cooper and the companies involved in the ACP its particular aroma is its timing. Fridays are widely recognized as the day to dump bad or controversial news, so the Department of Environmental Quality announced approval of the pipeline for water quality regulations. Only later in the day did the Governor's Office make known its agreement with ACP. Did the pipeline companies agree to pay $57.8 million under threat that they would not get regulatory approval without the payment? Was it a more amicable market transaction that left both parties pleased with the outcome? The digital trail of communications will be interesting to see.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Look to Florida for a "Rules Throttle" that's Working John Locke Foundation Guest Editorial, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics MSNBC's Mika Brzezinski Throws Smear Artist Michael Wolff off the Set When He Denies Targeting Nikki Haley


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

California Governor Gavin Newsom accused the CEO of Target of “selling out the LGBTQ+ community” after the retail giant pulled some gay- and trans-themed merchandise from its shelves amid a customer backlash.
The N.C. House of Representatives passed legislation Wednesday that would ban abortion after the first trimester, with some exceptions, and extends the window to 24 weeks for abortion due to “life-limiting” fetal anomalies.
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) called on Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen this week to immediately release all suspicious activity reports related to President Joe Biden’s family after Republicans in the House raised the alarm this week after visiting the Treasury Department over the matter.
Opponents of school choice claim that private schools are unaccountable because they don’t have to satisfy every testing mandate required of traditional public schools, yet private schools are subject to the highest standard of accountability: parents
RINO Texas speaker of the House gets major conservative primary challenger
credit card companies had set up special codes to track gun and ammo sale
threatens cooling system of Europe's largest nuclear power plant
Former Biden Energy Department official Sam Brinton, who identifies as “non-binary,” will be placed in a men’s jail in Maryland before authorities transport him to Virginia over suitcase theft charges.


In what is sure to provide much-needed relief in military spending costs, officials at the Pentagon announced today that, rather than dropping bombs, the United States Air Force will begin dropping morbidly obese airmen on enemy targets.
Congressman Mike Waltz (R-FL) fired back on Tuesday after an MSNBC guest claimed that Florida was “about to be a terrorist state” for black Americans and anyone in the LGBTQ community.
A Christian in the United Kingdom has been banned from teaching after he was accused of “misgendering” a female student who identified as a male.
The N.C. Department of Transportation is urging the state's second-highest court to step into a contract dispute.
House Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer (R-KY) is calling for “extreme measures” to break a stalemate with the FBI over a document believed to contain allegations of a criminal “bribery” scheme involving President Joe Biden.
A Moscow court extended the pre-trial detention of Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich by at least another three months after Russian authorities arrested the American journalist on espionage charges.
The beloved series The Chronicles of Narnia by C.S. Lewis has been treasured for over half a century, but did you know the books are actually allegorical, too? They are!
Former President Donald Trump could face an additional $10 million in damages in a defamation case filed by writer E. Jean Carroll for having “doubled down” on remarks made about her during a town hall event on CNN.
Wind projects off Brunswick County beaches would also interfere with military training and operations, including airspace used daily by the 169th Fighter Wing out of South Carolina


Back to Top