N.C. Supreme Court Asked to Decide Whether County or State Controls School Spending Decisions | Eastern North Carolina Now | The N.C. Supreme Court on Monday heard another round of arguments over school funding - this time whether county commissioners or General Assembly lawmakers are responsible for guaranteeing sufficient spending

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's note: The author of this post is Lindsay Marchello, who is an associate editor for the Carolina Journal, John Hood Publisher.

    The N.C. Supreme Court on Monday heard another round of arguments over school funding - this time whether county commissioners or General Assembly lawmakers are responsible for guaranteeing sufficient spending.

    In Silver et al. v. Halifax County Board of Commissioners, students and their families hold the county commissioners responsible for unequal funding among the various school districts in the county. The defendants - the Board of County Commissioners - are pointing the finger at the General Assembly.

    The case originally addressed parents' wishes to force three of Halifax's school districts to merge. Parents said the county was spending too little in two predominantly black school districts when compared with a majority white school district. The case has since morphed into a debate about school funding responsibilities.

    The Court of Appeals heard arguments Sept. 19, 2016. Judges ultimately sided with the Halifax County Board of Commissioners. Judge Donna Stroud wrote the opinion and Judge Lucy Inman concurred. Judge Linda McGee dissented.

    Plaintiffs appealed the decision, taking the case to the highest state court. Attorney Mark Dorosin, representing the plaintiffs, argued that since county commissioners make spending decisions, then they are responsible for any inequities.

    "Counties' funding decisions have failed to ensure the constitutional rights of students and the state has given the counties the power to remedy the harms specifically at issue here," Dorosin argued. "By statute, counties must provide adequate operational funding to school districts. They must provide school facilities, furniture, and equipment. They must provide water, supplies, and sanitation facilities for schools."

    Dorosin argued the state delegated spending responsibility to the Board of County Commissioners, and the board made decisions that underfunded certain Halifax school districts.

    Justice Paul Newby questioned whether an existing statute explains how to settle disputes between school districts and county commissioners over funding. Dorosin said there is, but the process isn't available for students and their families.

    Attorney Garris Neil Yarborough, representing the defendants, argued a remedy already exist for students and their families. The landmark Leandro rulings cemented the state's responsibility to provide a sound, basic education.

    Yarborough said plaintiffs should've sued the state rather than the county commissioners.

    "It is the state of North Carolina that is responsible for this," Yarborough said. "The ultimate responsibility rests with the General Assembly. Leandro clearly says that."

    Newby asked how this case differed from the two Leandro rulings. Dorosin said Leandro dealt with state-allocated funds, while this case focuses on how local governments spend money.

    Dorosin argued this case wasn't an either/or scenario. The state and the county commission can share responsibility over school funding.

    Yarborough argued the Leandro rulings set the precedent that the state has the ultimate responsibility to ensure a sound, basic education. This means state officials are fully responsible for inadequate funding.

    "If the state of North Carolina was doing what it was supposed to do, we wouldn't be here today," Yarborough said.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

will they bring down the Rutte government?
White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki responded to news reports from over the weekend that indicated that China had developed advanced nuclear-capable weapons systems by saying that the Biden administration “welcome[s] stiff competition.”
In an unprecedented move to protect the safety and security of millions of Americans, the FBI has added itself to the FBI watchlist.
state has started work to plug 1,000 foot gap in Yuma sector
On Monday the U.S. Supreme Court certified a June 30 ruling that would allow the Biden Administration to end former President Trump’s “Remain in Mexico” border policy.
Have you heard the latest? Uncle Joe is attempting to appropriate billions of dollars to a program designed to mandate that CRT is taught across the nation in OUR public schools.


Terrorism experts quickly downplayed Democrat President Joe Biden‘s attempts to count the CIA’s killing of Al Qaeda Ayman Al-Zawahiri in Afghanistan as a win for his administration, noting the fact that Al-Zawahiri was in Afghanistan at all means that the terrorist group has returned to the country
On July 8, Judge William Osteen, a federal judge appointed by President George W. Bush, gave all sides in the Bryant v. Woodall case 30 days to return briefs to the court on whether the injunction blocking North Carolina’s 20-week abortion ban should be lifted.
White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki downplayed a video from over the weekend that showed President Joe Biden and first lady Jill Biden violating a mask mandate in Washington, D.C., by saying that everyone has “moments” when they don’t put their masks back on as quickly as they should.
Simply put, the idiocy of Common Core Math is at the core of the Leftist's Orwellian ("1984") disposition to convert our Constitutional Republic into a Marxist Hellhole.
Joe Biden’s approval ratings through the first six quarters of his presidency have fallen to the lowest level of any president on record, according to one top pollster.
Amid mounting accusations of attempting to intimidate former President Trump from running for re-election in 2024, Attorney General Merrick Garland explained today that when the FBI was tipped off about a school board protest at Mar-A-Lago, they mobilized without delay


Republican Georgia Senate candidate Herschel Walker promised Monday to pray for the MSNBC contributor who suggested he was one of the “negroes” who would do what Republicans wanted him to do.


Back to Top