Tariffs: Donald Trump's Sin Taxes | Beaufort County Now | When is it acceptable for a Republican president to openly brag about liking taxes?

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Tariffs: Donald Trump's Sin Taxes

    Publisher's note: The author of this post is Dr. Roy Cordato, who is Senior Economist for the John Locke Foundation.

    Question: When is it acceptable for a Republican president to openly brag about liking taxes?

    Answer: When the taxes are directed toward American consumers and are called tariffs.

    Last week, in a tweet that was blamed for reversing what appeared to be the beginning of a positive trend in the stock market, President Trump bragged, "I am a tariff man." Immediately following the tweet, the market run-up abruptly stalled. The market was being spurred by promises of a 90-day truce in the (anti) trade war that Trump had launched against China. In particular, many hoped that Trump would refrain from pursuing new tariffs aimed at purchases of various Chinese goods. At the same time, it was rumored that China had considered allowing Chinese consumers to purchase cars imported from the U.S. tax-free. Trump's tweet was seen as signaling a halt to all of this.

    In spite of his anti-tax rhetoric, by referring to himself as "a tariff man," Trump conveyed that, when it comes to corporate and income taxes, he has no problem with new taxes. From Trump's perspective, if you are an American consumer or producer who has the audacity to purchase products made abroad, you are fair game. In fact, the increased revenues that are obtained when you insist on making these apparently anti-social choices are something for the president to brag about. As Trump noted in this same tweet, "we are now taking in $billions in tariffs."

    The original intent of Trump's taxes was to reduce the U.S. trade deficit. It is clear that Trump doesn't just (wrongfully) consider trade deficits to be bad for the economy, he equates them with coercive wealth transfers and even theft. Trade deficits, in Trump's eyes, have a moral component. This came through in the same tweet where he declared himself "a tariff man." In this tweet, demonstrating that he has no real understanding of the mutually beneficial nature of trade, he referred to countries that maintain a trade deficit with the U.S. as "coming to raid the great wealth of our nation."

    This perspective shapes his view of U.S. consumers who purchase foreign goods, particularly if they have the option of "buying American." Manufacturers that purchase steel from Canada or consumers who are buying cars or electronics made in Korea or China are essentially aiding and abetting this foreign-led raid on "our" wealth. Is it any wonder, then, that the purchase of foreign-made products might be viewed as an immoral act that harms the U.S. and deserves to be punished? From Trump's perspective, a tariff is, in fact, a sin tax. It is meant to discourage immoral and essentially anti-social behavior by American consumers, in much the same way as alcohol or cigarette taxes purportedly do.

    Of course, it's no secret that a lack of understanding of economics can lead to bad policy. It happens all the time. In this case, Trump's weak understanding of the nature of exchange has led to an equally weak understanding of trade deficits. His wrongheaded views of trade deficits have actually led to him to characterize these deficits in ways similar to justifications for sin taxes, that is, singling out a class of American citizens whose behavior needs to be discouraged.


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Fauci tries to shame them. Dr. Fauci....how many marines have died from C-19?
Come with us as we gaze into the Looking Glass for answers that most ignore or simply can't see.
A story that won’t receive as much media attention as one involving a male Republican governor, the female Democratic governor of New Mexico’s 2018 campaign recently reached a settlement with a former male aide who accused her of sexual misconduct.
House Bill 370, No Veteran Left Behind Act, on Tuesday, April 13, cleared the House Homeland Security, Military, and Veterans Affairs Committee.
After President Joe Biden announced his court-packing commission, liberal leaders are filing legislation to pack the Supreme Court with liberal activists in robes.


Today, Governor Roy Cooper announced new appointments and nominations to boards and commissions across North Carolina.
We will offer this allotment of three with more to come; some old, most new, but all quite informative, and, moreover, necessary to understanding that in North Carolina, there is a wiser path to govern ourselves and our People.
Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) said in a press conference Thursday that while she will not rule out adding members to the Supreme Court in the future, she will not bring a proposed bill to expand the Court to the floor for a vote.
Three years after the N.C. electorate decided to add a voter identification requirement to the state constitution, Republican lawmakers are defending voter ID in court.
Netflix’s documentary Operation Varsity Blues: The College Admissions Scandal tells the story of rich parents bribing their children’s way into their college of choice.
Margot Cleveland of the Federalist highlights an important ruling from the nation’s highest court.


Back to Top