Popularizing Science Presents ‘Grave’ Problems | Beaufort County Now | Author Jethro Lieberman explains that the answers to the gravity questions might be too complex for popular understanding, even if experts knew all the details with certainty. | john locke foundation, gravity, popularizing science, scientific concepts, climate science, september 8, 2020

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Popularizing Science Presents ‘Grave’ Problems

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Mitch Kokai.

    What is gravity, and how does it work? Those basic questions form the basis of an article, "The Gravity of the Situation," in the latest issue of The American Scholar (not yet posted online).

    Author Jethro Lieberman explains that the answers to the gravity questions might be too complex for popular understanding, even if experts knew all the details with certainty.

    By the way, they don't. Lieberman quotes science journalist Richard Panek's 2019 assessment of the issue:

  • Nobody knows what gravity is, and almost nobody knows that nobody knows what gravity is except for scientists, and they know that nobody knows what gravity is because they know that they don't know what gravity is.

    Lieberman extends his discussion beyond gravity to incorporate other scientific concepts. While he doesn't address climate science, it's hard not to see parallels between the problems he describes and the damage done by scentific "popularizers" (I'm looking at you, Bill Nye) who preach that global warming alarmism is based on "settled" science.

    The following passage from Lieberman's article ought to serve as a valuable warning for all of us, including those with a better grasp of science than I possess.

  • Duck into any bookstore or search any online bookseller and you'll find an ever-expanding section of popular offerings standing ready to initiate inquisitive readers into the latest scientific mysteries, and all without the need to understand math or have any feeling for experiment. (A growing number of websites offer the same.) It's cheap, It's easy. It's entertaining.
  • It's bogus.
  • ... If you try to keep up with developments, the stories become so well worn that, in succeeding books, you begin to notice subtle difficulties that the authors gloss over. After some time, you might begin to suspect that the accounts they provide are deflections from reality, like starlight around the sun, because the popularizers are loath to admit that a subject that enraptures them has loose ends, vague contours, or gaping holes. These writers' longing to instill in readers their own passion and even reverence for the science often overwhelms their prudence. Instead of giving their readers the whole truth, popularizers take to papering over theoretical weaknesses with jargon, fuzzy talk, or even outright silence.

    And Lieberman doesn't even mention the potential impact of politics or professional peer pressure. Add these factors, and the problems for popular science mount.


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

This man sets and example for us all
Naomi Lim of the Washington Examiner reports on special plans for President-elect Joe Biden’s inauguration next week.
Less than a year after an audit of the N.C. Department of Transportation found massive overspending, a blue-ribbon panel is recommending the department get a 40% budget hike.
Today, America's second Fake Impeachment of Donald J. Trump, just days before he leaves office, may speak more about those Impeaching the President than he who is indicted.
For the last four years, Donald Trump kept back the tide. But now, it’s up to Congress.
In her fine opinion piece for the Martin Center, Megan Zogby bemoans the “Quixotic” requirement that North Carolina college and university students take between two and four courses in a language such as Spanish, French, or German.
Andrew McCarthy of National Review Online admits early in his latest column that he believes President Trump has “committed impeachable conduct.”


With civic and political conflict headlining the news nearly every day, I’ve been searching for a bright spot on which to pin my hopes for reconciliation in this country.
According to Politico, Sunday’s rehearsal for Joe Biden’s inauguration has been postponed due to safety concerns, with the rehearsal now being planned for Monday.
Get a good cup of coffee and decompress with The Wolfman as he gives us his account of what really happened on the ground in DC. This is an exclusive series that will not be found anywhere but BCN.
Rich Lowry of National Review Online documents the social media giant’s influence on American political culture.
Pot calling kettle black: Another example of the hypocrisy of the Left/Democrats


Back to Top