Bill would expand administrative judges’ power to strike down government rules | Beaufort County Now | A new N.C. House bill would expand administrative law judges' ability to kill state government rules.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    North Carolina could see a new tool in the fight against excessive state regulation. A bill filed in the state House offers a new way to strike down bad rules.

    Rep. Sarah Stevens, R-Surry, filed House Bill 991 Wednesday. It would expand an administrative law judge's ability to declare state agency rules void.

    Current state law permits an ALJ to determine that a rule is void "as applied in a particular case." Stevens' proposal would delete the phrase about particular cases. In other words, the judge could determine the rule is void for all cases.

    An administrative judge could make that decision under any one of three sets of circumstances. First, the rule "is not within the statutory authority of the agency." State or federal law has not given the government the power to enact the rule.

    Second, "it is not clear and unambiguous to persons it is intended to direct, guide, or assist." Third, it "is not reasonably necessary to enable the agency to fulfill a duty delegated to it by the General Assembly."

    "This seems eminently reasonable," said Jon Guze, senior fellow in legal studies for the John Locke Foundation. "Administrative rules should be 'within the statutory authority of the agency,' 'clear and unambiguous,' and 'reasonably necessary to enable the agency to fulfill a duty delegated to it by the General Assembly.'"

    "Rules that fail those simple tests violate the state constitution in all kinds of ways, and judges should be able to strike them down," Guze added. "Giving them that power would significantly slow the expansion of the administrative state in North Carolina and promote justice and the rule of law."

    The state's Office of Administrative Hearings operates as "an independent quasi-judicial agency that was established to provide a source of independent administrative law judges to preside in administrative law contested cases," according to the OAH website. "It was created to ensure that the functions of rulemaking, investigation, advocacy, and adjudication are not combined in the administrative process."

    The House has assigned Stevens' bill to a judiciary committee.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

This week, local man Joseph Briones gave a rousing speech to his family about his role as king of his home. During his monologue, Briones cast a compelling vision of male leadership, all from under 25 floral pillows on the couch.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell below 30,000 on Thursday for the first time since January 2021 amid dismal inflation news and an aggressive interest rate hike from the Federal Reserve.
More than a week after authorities apprehended a man near Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s home claiming he wanted to kill the justice, Virginia Republican Governor Glenn Youngkin has introduced a budget amendment that would make it a felony to protest outside of a judge or justice’s home
Chancellor salaries at public universities across the country are far higher than those for other public executives, out of step with faculty compensation, and unrelated to student success and university performance.
Former CNN host Chris Cuomo is reportedly planning on taking on his former network by filing a massive lawsuit to get tens of millions of dollars that he believes is still owed to him on his contract and to “likely” seek damages from his recent firing.
According to inside sources, the Capitol Gift Shop has been inundated with tourists looking for Jan 6 hearing souvenirs leading one irritated employee to tack up a large sign at the entrance to the store reading “NO WE DO NOT SELL BUFFALO HAT SOUVENIRS”.
President Biden mocked Governor Ron DeSantis for targeting Disney over its opposition to the Parental Rights in Education bill on Wednesday.
ERIC was created with money from Soros' Open Society Institute


As many as 10,000 cattle have died amid triple-digit temperatures in Kansas, and more livestock could perish over the next several days, according to reports.
The N.C. Supreme Court has rejected a lawsuit challenging the Greenville red-light camera law as an unconstitutional local health act.
White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki refused to answer questions on Monday about matters related to President Joe Biden’s son, Hunter Biden, including a newly released book and his foreign investments.
Following the overturning of Roe v. Wade, Democrats nationwide have been accusing the Supreme Court of taking rights from "women." Onlookers have confirmed this to be confusing, as it seems to suggest that Democrats do in fact know what a woman is.
President Joe Biden will sign a “historic” executive order Wednesday ordering the Department of Health and Human Services to expand efforts to increase the ability of Americans (including children) who identify as transgender to obtain sex-change surgeries.
Two new N.C. Supreme Court decisions set a 40-year maximum prison sentence for violent juvenile offenders, regardless of the number or severity of their crimes.
Intentional destruction of the USA


Back to Top