Do Academics Still Trust Research? | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of The James G. Martin Center. The author of this post is Grace Hall.

    No matter where one falls politically, one must admit that the pandemic brought to the foreground the importance of scientific research. A new report from The Economist's think-tank spinoff, Economist Impact, attempts to better understand how the pandemic affected this crucial field, with an emphasis on scientists' confidence in currently-emerging findings.

    Confidence in Research: Researchers in the Spotlight explores the attitudes of scientists, researchers, and scholars on "how the pandemic has affected the practice of undertaking and communicating research in the face of increased public scrutiny." Though primarily based on a survey of over 3,000 researchers conducted from December 2021 to August 2022, the report also makes use of a literature review, six roundtable discussions, and qualitative interviews. Its intended purpose is to identify what it describes as "actionable insights and interventions for the research community."

    The report contains a few valuable insights but is laced with woke talking points. For example, the authors are quick to point to alleged funding inequalities and the "widening of pre-existing gaps between researchers in the Global South and Global North," as well as between men and women and early- and mid-career scientists. To be sure, getting funding into the hands of researchers with good ideas is important: If there is any area where meritocracy should win out, it is research. Yet Economist Impact goes beyond merely noting this potential problem and lists it as the survey's first "key finding." The far more pertinent discovery that "public attention ... may be leading researchers to adopt more careful research practices" is comparatively deemphasized.

    Elsewhere, the report is on more solid ground. Economist Impact's survey found that two of the factors most affecting researchers' confidence are whether a particular set of findings has been peer-reviewed and whether a given study is correctly designed. Without these safeguards, poorly designed research can be published despite obvious flaws. In the age of social media, this potential for harm has increased significantly due to the quick dissemination of information that is now possible.

    Another important finding from the report has to do with the lack of communications training for researchers who present directly to the public. By any measure, the pandemic increased the public's attention to researchers, many of whom are now in a position to disseminate their ideas on social media. Here, the report's usefulness is mixed. There is no reason not to "formalise communications training" for Ph.D. students, as Economist Impact recommends. However, it isn't clear how such instruction would have prevented overeager scientists from pontificating on Twitter about mask-mandates, vaccine requirements, and other political questions from the Covid era.

    The four main focuses of the report are addressing misinformation, building public trust, preparing researchers for a public-facing role, and tackling inequality. While these seem, overall, to be positive, a constant need to tackle inequality could easily overtake the more important need for accurate, well-designed scientific research, no matter its source. One wonders, too, if building public trust would be easier if scientists, researchers, scholars, and academics practiced a bit more humility. That advice is largely missing from Economist Impact's report.

    Grace Hall is a communications assistant at the James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal. She works and lives in Georgia.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Legendary director Martin Scorcese met with Pope Francis during a tour of Italy after Cannes and announced he’ll be making a Jesus-focused film.
After a judge ruled Trump liable in the sexual abuse and defamation case brought by E. Jean Carroll, the former President responded by announcing he would pay the $5 million judgment using his collectible NFT trading cards.
A pro-life activist suspects nefarious intentions behind the FBI sending agents to her childhood home last month.
Sam Brinton, the “nonbinary” activist tapped by Joe Biden for a key nuclear role before he was fired for stealing women’s clothes, was arrested again Wednesday night as a “fugitive from justice” for allegedly stealing luggage, The Daily Wire has learned.
N.C. Attorney General Josh Stein opposes a motion to dismiss a lawsuit filed against him. The suit chalenges North Carolina's restrictions on abortion pills.
A local father determined the time had come to sit his young son down and officially have "The Talk"...about the Star Wars sequel trilogy. The man reportedly knew he couldn't avoid it any longer once the boy began to talk about how great The Last Jedi was.
Deutsche Bank agreed to pay $75 million to settle a lawsuit accusing the company of failing to recognize the sex trafficking conducted by Jeffrey Epstein, the deceased pedophile hedge fund manager who was once a client of the firm.
Massive "city" of enormous wind turbines would severely conflict with military training and operations


Actor Kevin Costner hinted at a new Western film on Wednesday as he’s set to exit the hit television series “Yellowstone” later this year.
The Attenborough family reportedly expressed regret for having brought Grandpa to the beach with them for a leisure weekend. The grandkids in particular wished he would just shut up and let them enjoy the beach.
The California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS) recently opposed legislation that would require divestment from fossil fuel companies despite the agency’s support of the environmental, social, and corporate governance movement, also known as ESG.
How Washington, North Carolina neglects African-American, Latino and Poor Communities
Retail giant Target has lost $10 billion in market capitalization in ten days, largely due to the backlash over prominent LGBTQ+ PRIDE displays including transgender-friendly clothing items for children.
and also reject transgender medical procedures for chidlren
The N.C. State Board of Elections is updating voter registration forms to comply with the state Supreme Court's ruling against felon voting.


Back to Top