Critics of eCourts rollout seek more time for possible class-action suit | Eastern North Carolina Now

Critics of North Carolina's new eCourts digital court records system seek more time to move forward with a class-action suit.

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    Plaintiffs challenging the rollout of North Carolina's eCourts digital court records system are seeking more time for a potential class-action lawsuit. They filed a motion Wednesday in federal court asking for an extension.

    The system operates now in Wake, Johnston, Lee, and Harnett counties. It's scheduled to begin operations in Mecklenburg County next week.

    Two plaintiffs, in Wake and Lee counties, sued their local sheriffs and eCourts vendor Tyler Technologies in May. The sheriffs and the company have filed separate motions to dismiss the suit, titled Chaplin v. Rowe.

    Lawyers for the two plaintiffs are asking for more time to bring additional plaintiffs into the case. Tyler and Lee County Sheriff Brian Estes "do not consent" to the extension. Wake County Sheriff Willie Rowe indicated that a court should set the deadline for class certification.


    Court rules require a motion for class certification within 90 days of the initial complaint. "Plaintiffs concede that they filed their complaint more than 90 days ago. However, ... there is 'good cause' to extend the time to move for class certification, and Plaintiffs' delay is on account of 'excusable neglect,'" according to the latest court filing.

    Failure to meet the deadline "was due to simple inadvertence; there is no bad faith or gamesmanship at hand," plaintiffs' lawyers argued. "Counsel calendared the class certification motion deadline as ninety days from the date of service of the Complaint - which occurred in mid-August - versus ninety days from the date of filing the Complaint. Undersigned counsel acknowledge this misstep."

    "This case is in its infancy, so any class certification motion would be premature," plaintiffs' lawyers wrote. "Defendants' motions to dismiss are still pending. Plaintiffs have conducted no pre-certification discovery. And Plaintiffs will likely need to amend the Complaint to add new plaintiffs and defendants given that the putative class in this matter continues to grow."

    The court document signaled the likelihood of additional plaintiffs. "This case involves civil-rights violations arising from the rollout of the so-called 'eCourts' software in North Carolina - a rollout that is still ongoing," according to the court filing. "The state's largest county, Mecklenburg County, is scheduled to implement the software beginning October 9, 2023."

    "Plaintiffs intend to amend the Complaint to add additional plaintiffs and additional defendants as more counties adopt 'eCourts.' Denial of the instant motion would have no binding effect on these new parties. Nor would it shield the currently-named Defendants from later certification motions. Rather, denial would merely complicate this litigation," the plaintiffs' lawyers argued.

    The current case involves a Wake County plaintiff, Timia Chaplin, who argues that authorities arrested her for a second time in April on charges that already had been dismissed. Chaplin blamed the eCourts system for the mistake. Lee County plaintiff Paulino Castellanos argued that he spent 14 days in a local jail because of the "botched transition" to eCourts software.

    ECourts allows for electronic court filing. It gives the public online access to court files and allows people to pay court fees.


    After Mecklenburg County, additional clusters of counties are slated to move to the new system every 60 to 90 days. All courts are slated to use the new system by 2025.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Golden LEAF announces $5.6 million in funding at October meeting Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, News and Information, Government, The Region, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Young entrepreneurs put their ideas to the test


Latest State and Federal

Biotech entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy told The Daily Wire on Monday that he would “strongly consider” replacing J.D. Vance as U.S. senator from Ohio now that former President Donald Trump has picked Vance to be his running mate for the 2024 election.
For the second year in a row, Raleigh was ranked as the overall best place for veterans to live in the United States, according to a WalletHub report. Charlotte, Durham, Greensboro, and Winston-Salem came in 26th, 35th, 48th, and 51st overall, respectively.
Less than 24 hours after a failed assassination attempt against former President Donald Trump — which left one bystander dead and three others, including Trump, injured — The Atlantic’s David Frum blamed the violence on the former president and his supporters.
The Biden campaign fired back at actor George Clooney on Wednesday after Clooney called for President Joe Biden to drop out of the presidential race, suggesting that the 81-year-old president has better stamina than Clooney.
Ray Epps, the man accused by many of being involved with federal law enforcement during the January 6, 2021, riot at the U.S. Capitol, said over the weekend that Fox News host Tucker Carlson was “obsessed” with him and trying to ruin his life.
The North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services is hosting a virtual meeting on Friday, March 1, 2024, for the Standardized Foster Care Trauma-Informed Assessment Workgroup.


Cotton has been mentioned as a possible running mate for former President Donald Trump.
Former President Donald Trump said during a radio hit on Friday that he would be willing to take a cognitive test alongside President Joe Biden to let voters see the mental state of each presidential candidate.
NBC News’ Chuck Todd said Tuesday that Biden’s declining cognitive health has been an “open secret” for years, revealing that a senior cabinet member from the Biden administration suggested in 2022 that the president cannot run for reelection.
Daily Wire Editor Emeritus Ben Shapiro is testifying to Congress on Wednesday for a House Judiciary Committee hearing on the alleged conspiracy to suppress conservative voices under the guise of “brand safety.”
At least one person was shot and killed during an assassination attempt on former President Donald Trump on Saturday at a political rally in Pennsylvania in which the suspected gunman was also “neutralized,” according to the U.S. Secret Service.


The State Board of Elections will hold a remote meeting at 10:30 a.m. Tuesday, July 16, 2024.


Back to Top