Clinton Judge Sides With Leftist Groups To Stop Asylum Ban for Child Abusers, Drunk Drivers | Beaufort County Now | A consortium of open borders groups sued the administration in early November to ban the rule, claiming among other things, that the government exceeded its authority in its attempts to keep criminals out.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
Press Release:

    The government is exceeding its authority for trying to ban illegal immigrant child abusers, drunk drivers, and a series of other violent criminals from getting asylum in the United States, according to open borders groups challenging a Trump administration rule scheduled to take effect this month. A Clinton-appointed federal judge agrees with the leftist nonprofits and has blocked implementation of the policy issued jointly by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and Department of Justice (DOJ) to ban foreigners with serious criminal histories from being rewarded with asylum and all the taxpayer-funded perks that come with it. This includes disqualifying those convicted of domestic violence, child abuse, assault, battery, identity theft, public benefits fraud, immigrant smuggling and driving under the influence.

    A consortium of open borders groups sued the administration in early November to ban the rule, claiming among other things, that the government exceeded its authority in its attempts to keep criminals out. The lengthy complaint alleges a multitude of problems with the new measure, including of course, that it is racist. "The Rule violates the equal protection component of the Fifth Amendment because it was motivated by discriminatory animus toward certain racial and ethnic groups and people of certain national origins," according to the lawsuit filed in a San Francisco federal court. In a statement announcing the lawsuit, the immigrant rights group heading the legal challenge claims that the U.S. has obligations under international law to make asylum broadly available and to make any exceptions narrow and reserved only for the most serious offenses. "The rules build on the systemic racism of U.S. immigration and asylum policies that have become increasingly harsh and narrow over the past several decades," according to the San Francisco-based nonprofit dedicated to deportation defense. "These laws rely increasingly on fear-mongering and criminalization of immigrants."

    In a document asking the court to deny the ban requested by the open borders coalition the government writes that the DHS and DOJ rule "ensures that asylum is not granted to criminal aliens who endanger our country." The court brief also cites the president's authority to keep criminals out of the U.S. "Awarding the discretionary benefit of asylum to dangerous criminals encourages lawless behavior, subjects the United States to danger, and undermines the asylum system," government attorneys write in the filing. "Despite the Executive Branch's broad authority and sound aims, Plaintiffs — organizations that are not even regulated by the Rule — ask this Court to bar the Rule's application to anyone, so that the Executive Branch could not apply it to child abusers, alien smugglers, wife beaters, stalkers, serial drunk drivers, various fraudsters, or persons who commit gang violence. This Court should deny that extraordinary request." The government court filing also reminds that Congress has empowered the Attorney General and Secretary of Homeland Security to decide who may be admitted to this country as a refugee.

    The federal judge, Susan Illston, who presided over the case disagreed granting the open borders coalition a victory a few days ago. Illston concurs with the leftist nonprofits' claims that the government exceeded its authority and writes in her decision that the rule is "substantively and procedurally defective." Appointed to the federal bench in 1995 by Bill Clinton, the judge also says that the new policy is unnecessary because laws already exist prohibiting asylum for those who have committed certain crimes. "Congress has already written a long list of crimes that render one, if convicted, ineligible for asylum — drug trafficking, sex trafficking, money laundering, counterfeiting, and many more," Judge Illston writes. "The Rule adds new crimes to that list, with the stated goals of promoting the efficiency of asylum proceedings, discouraging lawless behavior, and protecting the community from danger. These goals, of course, are not problematic in and of themselves, and in any event, it is not this Court's role to pass judgment on the wisdom of the policies that executive agencies may craft in the administration of their duties. The problem is that the Rule sweeps too broadly. In doing so, it both contradicts Congress's intent and exceeds the authority Congress gave to the executive agencies."

    One of the groups challenging the policy asserts in a celebratory statement that the defeated regulation is part of the Trump administration's attempt to "dismantle asylum protections as part of its anti-immigrant agenda."
Go Back

HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Concerned Graduates of West Point and the Long Grey Line
Vice President Kamala Harris has suffered a steady exodus out of her office amid reports that she is a bully and runs a dysfunctional operation.
The North Carolina State Health Plan and the National Academy for State Health Policy Find that North Carolina's Seven Largest Hospital Systems Reaped Billions of Dollars in Cash, Investments and Profits After Taking COVID Relief
During day six of the trial of alleged sexual groomer and abuser Ghislaine Maxwell, a woman testified that when she was 17 years old, Maxwell asked her to find other young girls to perform oral sex on late convicted pedophile Jeffrey Epstein.
defeats protege of incumbnet who was backed by teachers union
According to sources, Biden was seen outside a gas station this afternoon yelling at the big price sign to lower its prices.

HbAD1

The Heritage Foundation has filed a lawsuit against President Joe Biden's administration demanding the release of documents related to the investigation of mounted Border Patrol agents.
The trouble is, eventually you run out of other people's money to spend=Margaret Thatcher
conservatives take out one of two RINO congressmen in Mississippi
On June 14, pro-abortion terrorist group “Jane’s Revenge” claimed credit for numerous attacks on pro-life centers around the country, including the June 7 attack on Mountain Area Pregnancy Services (MAPS) in Asheville.
Ruby Rose, who played Kate Kane in the CW’s “Batwoman” TV Show, claimed last week that she left the show in 2020 because of terrible working conditions.
58 percent of postsecondary educational institutions now employ a post-tenure review process. This is up from 46 percent in 2000.
Two former Tesla employees filed suit against the automaker on Sunday for allegedly violating federal law through its decision to lay off much of its staff.

HbAD2

 
Back to Top