State Supreme Court splits along party lines to hear voter ID case in October | Eastern North Carolina Now | The N.C. Supreme Court split along party lines, 4-3, in agreeing to hear a challenge against the state's voter ID law in October.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The N.C. Supreme Court has voted 4-3 to hear oral arguments in October in a lawsuit challenging the state's photo voter identification law. The vote split along party lines, with Democrats supporting the October hearing.

    "In light of the great public interest in the subject matter of this case, the importance of the issues to the constitutional jurisprudence of this State, and the need to reach a final resolution on the merits at the earliest possible opportunity, ... [t]his case shall be scheduled for oral argument as soon as practicable, on a date to be determined during arguments scheduled the week of 3 October 2022, or by special setting no later than 18 October 2022," according to the order signed by Justice Robin Hudson, a Democrat.

    Chief Justice Paul Newby wrote for the three dissenting Republican justices. "Once more, the majority expedites the hearing of a case where no jurisprudential reason supports doing so," Newby wrote. "Given the impending November elections, expedited hearing in October on this voter ID matter will likely cause voter confusion, ... especially when this Court recently entered a decision in another case involving voter ID, N.C. NAACP v. Moore."

    "Additionally, the trial court's permanent injunction in favor of plaintiffs remains intact," Newby added. "Expedited consideration, therefore, will not provide plaintiffs any new relief that they do not already enjoy. Accordingly, nothing suggests that expedited hearing is necessary '[t]o prevent manifest injustice' or to protect 'the public interest.'"

    The state Supreme Court ruled in August that a trial judge should take another look at N.C. NAACP v. Moore, the case challenging the 2018 voter-approved referendum that enshrined voter ID as an amendment to the state constitution. The high court suggested that the trial court could nullify the voter ID amendment and another amendment that lowers the state's income tax cap.

    Friday's order addresses a separate case, Holmes v. Moore. That suit challenges the law state lawmakers adopted to implement the voter ID constitutional requirement.

    With a 2-1 vote, a trial court panel threw out North Carolina's voter ID law in September 2021. Unless that ruling is overturned, North Carolina cannot move forward with a photo ID requirement.

    Voter ID defenders appealed the trial court's ruling to the N.C. Court of Appeals, but ID critics then asked the state Supreme Court to intervene.

    Legislative leaders accused ID opponents of "forum shopping" based on the contrasting partisan compositions of the two appellate courts. Republicans outnumber Democrats, 10-5, on the Appeals Court. Democrats outnumber Republicans, 4-3, on the state Supreme Court. Two Supreme Court seats now held by Democrats are up for grabs in the November election.

    The state's highest court agreed on March 2 to take the voter ID case. The latest order responded to a July 11 request from plaintiffs to expedite the case.
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




Legislative leaders rebut arguments from felon voting advocates Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics GOP lawsuit claims NC Board of Elections ignoring absentee, observer laws


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

"...everything that defines us is now an enemy for those who would like us to no longer have an identity and to simply be perfect consumer slaves."
During a camping retreat this week to recharge for more rioting before, during, and after the midterm elections, a group of progressives sat around a campfire and enjoyed swapping scary stories about climate change.
Mortgage rates are approaching 7% as the housing market continues to experience turmoil.
According to a Reuters report, tweets soliciting child sex abuse material have appeared alongside or on profile pages of at least 30 major advertisers’ Twitter accounts. Some of those companies are now pulling their ad services off the social media platform.
‘Gravest technological threat’ to liberty
A local couple is in shock today after a startling visit from Rightful Georgia Governor® Stacey Abrams. According to sources, the couple was listening to the heartbeat of their child on a sonogram for the very first time when Abrams burst through the wall like the Kool-Aid man
Have you ever seen former New England Patriots star Julian Edelman’s unbelievable catch as part of the team’s 25-point comeback in Super Bowl 51? It undoubtedly took “great skill” and “good luck” — thanks, in large part, to his years of practice and determination.

HbAD1

Earlier this year, I wrote how former congressman and Trump administration chief of staff Mark Meadows may have committed voter registration fraud in North Carolina.
“The Chosen” creator Dallas Jenkins recently spoke to The Daily Wire about the uses of social media and if he thinks Jesus would’ve used it, had it been available in first century Galilee, to spread his message.
Matt Walsh is once again stirring up controversy after he shared pictures of Nazi death camps on his Twitter account with the words "We must never let this kind of evil happen ever again."
More than 2.5 million businesses and homes in Florida were left without power in the aftermath of Hurricane Ian on Thursday morning as utility companies work to repair the state’s electrical grid.
Cheri Beasley’s soft on crime agenda and support for the defund the police movement has not gone unnoticed.
The U.S. Navy recently tested technology and completed training exercises near the portion of the Nord Stream pipeline system that saw damage on Monday.
A recently published years-long investigation by the Dallas Morning News has revealed that many colleges and universities throughout the country used or have been using AI to monitor students’ social media and email accounts.
During a White House press conference focused on clarifying every statement Biden has ever made, Press Secretary Jean-Pierre clarified that the official White House policy was the opposite of whatever President Biden says in interviews.

HbAD2

 
Back to Top