Responsibility for UNC-CH COVID-19 Outbreaks Cannot Be Placed Solely on Students | Beaufort County Now | UNC Chapel Hill recently made the decision to move all undergraduate courses online.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Responsibility for UNC-CH COVID-19 Outbreaks Cannot Be Placed Solely on Students

Publisher's note: The author of this post is Brenee Goforth for the John Locke Foundation.

    UNC Chapel Hill recently made the decision to move all undergraduate courses online. In his recent research brief, JLF's Dominic Coletti writes:

  • When UNC-CH officials decided to continue with the university reopening plan, they (and everybody else) knew that bringing students back on campus without testing would lead to COVID-19 cases and perhaps clusters. The fact is that while some college students (particularly those who are in at-risk groups) are symptomatic carriers of the SARS-CoV-2 virus, the vast majority of college students won't show symptoms. As a result, unless a school tests every single student on campus right before students move in, there's no way to avoid an initial cluster.

    The university leadership quickly blamed the spread of COVID-19 on campus on irresponsible students. Coletti explains:

  • UNC System President Peter Hans (among many others) blames students. "This hard work is being undermined by a very small number of students behaving irresponsibly off campus, which unfairly punishes the vast majority of their classmates who are following the rules," Hans said on August 20.

    But Coletti doesn't buy this argument. He believes this was an oversight of the university. Coletti writes:

  • Instead of evaluating a worst-case or even realistic scenario, they envisioned the most ideal scenario. When that was predictably shattered, it seems the administrators panicked. They didn't wait to see if their contact tracing and containment worked. They didn't think of alternative de-densification measures (e.g., allowing students to break housing contracts penalty-free without mandating all students leave). In-person instruction at UNC-CH might still be possible had UNC-CH's administration taken responsibility and made strides to fix the problems that were apparent. Instead, they shut it all down.

    Read the full research brief HERE. Read Carolina Journal's recent coverage of the story HERE. Watch JLF's experts discuss UNC-CH's and NCSU's transition to online learning HERE.


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

An unfolding case at Smith College shows how the obsession with race can blind administrators to facts and lead them to act in ways that harm innocent people.
James Antle of the Washington Examiner highlights potential political damage linked to Biden administration border policy.
Judicial Watch announced today that it filed a Illinois Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) lawsuit against the city of Evanston, Illinois for records about its controversial, taxpayer-funded “reparations” program
Casey Mulligan explains at National Review Online why some left-wing health care ideas would have serious negative consequences.
Everybody in America has had an opinion about the censorship of Big Tech, crossing all political boundaries.


The Biden administration’s decision to call for a pause to the Johnson & Johnson’s COVID-19 vaccine has caused confidence in the vaccine to plummet, according to a new poll.
State treasurer says charges to state employees health insurance should be transparent.
Former N.C. Governor Pat McCrory threw his hat in the ring on Wednesday to represent North Carolina in the United States Senate.
Fauci tries to shame them. Dr. many marines have died from C-19?
Come with us as we gaze into the Looking Glass for answers that most ignore or simply can't see.


A story that won’t receive as much media attention as one involving a male Republican governor, the female Democratic governor of New Mexico’s 2018 campaign recently reached a settlement with a former male aide who accused her of sexual misconduct.
House Bill 370, No Veteran Left Behind Act, on Tuesday, April 13, cleared the House Homeland Security, Military, and Veterans Affairs Committee.
After President Joe Biden announced his court-packing commission, liberal leaders are filing legislation to pack the Supreme Court with liberal activists in robes.
Today, Governor Roy Cooper announced new appointments and nominations to boards and commissions across North Carolina.
We will offer this allotment of three with more to come; some old, most new, but all quite informative, and, moreover, necessary to understanding that in North Carolina, there is a wiser path to govern ourselves and our People.
Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) said in a press conference Thursday that while she will not rule out adding members to the Supreme Court in the future, she will not bring a proposed bill to expand the Court to the floor for a vote.
Three years after the N.C. electorate decided to add a voter identification requirement to the state constitution, Republican lawmakers are defending voter ID in court.


Back to Top