Supreme Court Could Have Final Say on H.R. 1

Latest Polls (view all)

Where do you stand on the Transgender Issue now that the issue has gotten to the overt point of the open celebration of this lifestyle choice, dictated by certain direct and explicit actions.

88.51% I do not approve of behavior that has within its expressed tenants policies that harm children.

10.34% I do support the Trans Community in all its many facets because diversity is at a premium in today's society.

1.15% What is a "Children's Drag Queen Story Hour?"

Click Here to Vote
87 Vote(s)

View all Polls

Supreme Court Could Have Final Say on H.R. 1

Published: Tuesday, June 29th, 2021 @ 2:45 pm
By: John Locke Foundation ( More Entries )

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Mitch Kokai.

If Congress manages to approve the sweeping federal election takeover envisioned in H.R. 1, the U.S. Supreme Court should respond. Nathan Lewin explains why in a Federalist column.

If Congress were to enact such a sweeping law - replacing election laws in all states - it would be doomed by a constitutional principle even the most liberal justices of the Supreme Court have recently endorsed.
Copyright law provides the most recent precedent for invalidating H.R. 1. In 2019, the Supreme Court heard a challenge to a 1990 law eliminating the sovereign-immunity defense states had invoked if they were sued for copyright infringement. A photographer whose videos had been used by North Carolina without his permission sued the state, claiming the 1990 law removed its claim that it could not be held accountable in court for infringement.
A unanimous Supreme Court - including the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg - found the 1990 law unconstitutional because it was too broad. Justice Elena Kagan's opinion in Allen v. Cooper, issued on March 23, 2020, said the law violated the "congruence and proportionality" principle by which the Supreme Court has uniformly measured congressional legislation. The law "swept too far," she said, and its "indiscriminate scope" was "out of proportion" to any problem Congress was seeking to address.
Unlike H.R. 1, the 1990 copyright law was the subject of a congressional report, which the court still found inadequate to sustain the law because it cited "just two examples of patent infringement suits against the States."
"Congruence and proportionality" mean a law cannot be indiscriminately broad unless there is evidence such sweeping coverage is necessary. Congress may not displace a large area of local legislation, but must selectively address specific ills shown through legislative hearings and committee findings.
This "congruence and proportionality" standard was also the basis for a ruling in 2000 upholding state immunity from lawsuits under the Americans with Disabilities Act in Board of Trustees of the University of Alabama v. Garrett.

Go Back

Login to Leave a Comment

User-Fee Principle Should Guide Future N.C. Transportation Choices

John Locke Foundation Guest Editorial, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics

Funnel Cakes for All: ‘Science’ Favors State Fairs

Our Members

ENCN Sign Up

BCN Home

Beaufort Observer

Portfolios

Current Events: A Historical Perspective

Current Weather

Latest Comments

Latest Polls

Featured Entries

Latest Entries

Supreme Court Could Have Final Say on H.R. 1 | Eastern NC Now

Supreme Court Could Have Final Say on H.R. 1

Leave a Guest Comment

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

New poll: 60% of Americans blame the media for assassination attempts on Trump

Key UK local elections today, anti-immigration Reform Party expected to do well

FBI raids office of Democrat VA Senate President Pro Tem in major corruption probe

RNC Statement on Roy Cooper in Greensboro

GOP voters in Indiana oust 7 state senate RINOs and replace with Trunp backed conservatives

Cooper released 3,500 “hardened criminals out of the NC prisons

Alberta independence from Canada petition submitted with almost 2X number needed

Another de-transitioner wins court settlement for trans surgery genital mutilation

Dominican Republic has mass deportation of Haitian migrants, while Obama judges stop it here

Henry Hinton: "NCAE teachers union rally in Raleigh was like a communist / left wing rally".

Democrat federal candidates make threats on President Trump's life, one arrested

new poll: 60% of French people believe native population being replaced by 3rd world migrants

14,000 food stamps ("SNAP") users were driving luxury cars in just ONE STATE,

Hollywood Still Blacklists Conservatives — Now They Don’t Even Hide It

NC federal grand jury indicts Comey on charges he threatened Trump

The Abortion Industry Simply Changed Tactics. Now Congress Must Act.

Trump Admin Shuts Down Sham Charities Caught Bankrolling Hamas

51 Prisoners To Be Freed As Cuba Shows Cracks Under Trump Pressure

‘Andre the Giant’ marker puts smalltown Ellerbe into spotlight

Republicans Petition for New Meetings

What Happens When A Naturalized Citizen Commits Terror In America?

teachers unions push WEF globalist propaganda in schools; NH legislature fights back

US Justice Department to enforce SCOTUS ruling against states with racial gerrymanders

Political Parties? – Why We Have Them and What They Do

No Amnesty, No Surrender: Why The DIGNIDAD Act Must Die

Major Teachers Union Plans Trump Walkout While Their Own Students Can Barely Read

Heroic Students Rally To Stop Gunman Who Carried Out Terror Attack At Old Dominion