Appeals Court Rules Trial Judge Cannot Force Bail Payment for Deported Immigrant | Beaufort County Now | A unanimous three-judge N.C. Appeals Court panel has ruled that a trial judge could not order forfeiture of $100,000 bond for an illegal immigrant deported by the federal government.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Appeals Court Rules Trial Judge Cannot Force Bail Payment for Deported Immigrant

Publisher's note: The author of this post is Mitch Kokai for the John Locke Foundation.

    A unanimous three-judge N.C. Appeals Court panel has ruled that a trial judge could not order forfeiture of $100,000 bond for an illegal immigrant deported by the federal government.

    Defendant David Lemus had arranged for the secured bond while jailed on a felony charge in Granville County in 2018. Rather than releasing Lemus after he had the $100,000 secured bond, authorities continued to detain him for the federal government. Immigration authorities took custody of Lemus and deported him to Mexico.

    When Lemus failed to show up for his state court appearance, because he had been deported, the trial court forfeited the bond. The bond company appealed.

    Judge Richard Dietz explained the ruling against the trial judge:

  • [U]nder the plain language of the bail statutes, the trial court cannot enter a bond forfeiture unless, once the defendant has satisfied the conditions placed upon his release and there is no other basis in state law to retain custody of the defendant, the State sets the defendant free. This plain reading of the statute also enables the bond forfeiture laws to serve their intended purpose — to ensure that defendants report to court for their scheduled criminal proceedings.
  • Here, the State knew Lemus would not be at his criminal trial because the State handed him over for deportation. The federal government even offered to coordinate with the State so that Lemus could be returned for trial,but the State declined.
  • Interpreting the bail statutes to permit forfeiture in these circumstances conflicts with those statutes' plain language, does nothing to serve their statutory purpose, and ultimately harms undocumented immigrants and their families — some of the poorest, most vulnerable people in our society — for absolutely no reason.

    Dietz concludes:

  • Lemus satisfied the conditions set by the trial court for his release, but he was not released. Instead, the State continued to detain him, despite the bond he posted, until he could be transferred to the custody of federal immigration authorities for deportation. Because the State never released Lemus, the trial court erred by entering a bond forfeiture and further erred by declining to set that forfeiture aside.

Go Back

HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Deputies should not have to give up their right to due process when they put on a badge
Restricts power of police to seize guns because they "think" the person is a threat
Joe Biden is bankrupting our country with his massive spending
No room for dissenting opinions in the Space Force

HbAD1

If you follow state politics, you have no doubt heard of crossover day on the legislative calendar.
Question the integrity of the 2020 election and Biden competency to be Commander-In-Chief
Judicial Watch announced today that it filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) lawsuit against the Department of Defense seeking records of communications between Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin and other top military officials regarding Fox News and its host Tucker Carlson
She has courage. But politics demands more than that.
Hayden Ludwig writes for the Washington Free Beacon about a foreign source of funding for Democratic electoral shenanigans.
The recent hiring of New York Times columnist Nikole Hannah-Jones as a faculty member in UNC-Chapel Hill’s Hussman School of Journalism raises serious red flags about how the university is being run.
Today, U.S. Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC) spoke on the Senate floor honoring the service and sacrifice of law enforcement officers during National Police Week.
N.C. senators are moving forward an omnibus criminal justice reform bill that would make a wide range of changes to state law in response to recent cases of rioting, violence against first responders, and accusations of police brutality.

HbAD2

Former University of Hawaii quarterback Colt Brennan, has passed away at 37, according to Brennan’s father, Terry.
Bill would eliminate provisions that broadly criminalize rules violations of certain occupational licensing boards
Good move. We should all support this common sense legislation
I wrote this article a while back and recent developments make it very clear that the words in this article are being be borne out.
James Antle of the Washington Examiner highlights Republicans’ contrasting approaches to the 45th president’s legacy.
Governor Roy Cooper has appointed Mark Sternlicht to serve as Superior Court Judge for Judicial District 12 in serving Cumberland County.
Graham Piro of the Washington Free Beacon documents state-level efforts to safeguard religious freedom during a pandemic.

HbAD3

 
Back to Top