Pondering a Trump Quarantine | Eastern NC Now

Andrew McCarthy of National Review Online responds to President Trump’s suggestion that he might issue a quarantine.

ENCNow
Publisher's note: The author of this post is Mitch Kokai for the John Locke Foundation.

    Andrew McCarthy of National Review Online responds to President Trump's suggestion that he might issue a quarantine.

  • The powers of the federal government in general, and of the president in particular, to quarantine American citizens are not cut-and-dried.
  • The Supreme Court has long recognized that citizens of the United States have a constitutional right to travel from state to state. ...
  • ... This right to interstate travel has three components: (a) the right of a citizen of one state to enter and leave another state, (b) the right to be treated as a welcome visitor while in another state, and (c) the right to resettle in a new state and be treated equally with the citizens thereof.
  • Of course, no right is absolute, even one said to be "virtually unconditional." Congress, not the president, has the power to regulate interstate commerce. A federally imposed regulation on the right to travel between states may be upheld, even if the effect is to abide unequal treatment of citizens, if it is "shown to be necessary to promote a compelling governmental interest." ...
  • ... To summarize, although American citizens have what has been interpreted to be a fundamental right to travel between states, the federal government's very limited power to curb such travel undoubtedly includes authority to prevent the spread of infectious diseases - and COVID-19 certainly qualifies as one. Congress has the power to regulate interstate travel, and it has delegated that power to the executive branch for the purpose of protecting against the spread of infectious diseases.
  • Consequently, the president does have the power to restrict travel between the states of persons reasonably believed to be infected with COVID-19. I would assume that this means the power to prevent people who reside (or who have recently been present) in "hot spot" areas from traveling from those areas to other states.

Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published )
Enter Your Comment ( text only please )




Sheriff’s Promise of Kind, Polite Enforcement Downplays Threat of Government Power John Locke Foundation Guest Editorial, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Feds Think Gun Stores Should Remain Open


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

massive data collection by license plate readers on highways and streets threaten freedom
“I’m from America, 250 years ago we were way bigger than 6/1 dogs, and look at us thriving now.” Justin Gaethje pulls off an all time sports upset.
There are many people who overlook the brilliance of the US Constitution. They argue that it is outdated and unfit to adequately govern such a modern nation as ours in the 21st century.

HbAD1

"I plan to keep his counsel close until our paths cross again," JD Vance said on Thursday.

HbAD2

On Tuesday, Democratic Gov. Josh Stein signed an executive order creating the bipartisan Health Care Affordability Commission that he said will look at ways to make healthcare more affordable for North Carolinians.
"Margo’s Got Money Troubles" explores how financial desperation drives women to OnlyFans. That’s not empowering. It’s exploitative.

HbAD3

 
 
Back to Top