Two Settlements Later, Guess Who Is Stuck Paying Nearly All of Coal-Ash Cleanup? | Beaufort County Now | My colleague Don van der Vaart writes today about NC Attorney General Josh Stein’s bizarre settlement announcement this week | john locke foundation, settlements, coal-ash, cleanup, attorney general, josh stein, january 29, 2021

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Two Settlements Later, Guess Who Is Stuck Paying Nearly All of Coal-Ash Cleanup?

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Jon Sanders.

    My colleague Don van der Vaart writes today about NC Attorney General Josh Stein's bizarre settlement announcement this week despite recently declaring a December NC Supreme Court "a major win for electricity consumers on coal ash cleanup costs."

    The article asks many strong questions, so by all means read the whole thing. I'd like to point this portion out, however. It's jarring.

  • Remember when Cooper was attorney general running for governor. He had opposed the Coal Ash Management Act specifically because, in his words, it would "allow the public utility to unfairly charge customers for the cost of these actions." Instead, Cooper urged the legislature explicitly to "prohibit the Commission from authorizing utility rate increases related to these costs."
  • He also said that "in this situation it is better to come down on the side of the consumer."
  • That was before Cooper became governor and two coal ash cleanup settlements ago. Note that the settlement Stein announced doesn't cover the additional cleanup costs associated with a December 2019 settlement signed by Cooper's Department of Environmental Quality under Sec. Michael Regan. That settlement explicitly agreed that an additional $5 billion in cleanup costs should be paid by Duke's customers.
  • So for now, consumers appear to be on the hook for almost 90 percent of the $9 billion cleanup costs.

    What changed between 2014 and now? Why is it no longer better to come down on the side of consumers?


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Public school systems in the Tar Heel State are experiencing the highest declines in student enrollment in decades.
Republican leaders in the N.C. General Assembly say they will consider overriding the governor’s veto of Senate Bill 37, the school reopening bill, as soon as Monday, March 1.
No significant difference in severity of pandemic between states that locked down and those that did not.
A group of Wake County parents has written Gov. Roy Cooper asking him to reopen schools for in-person instruction.


Approximately 18,000 Students to Participate in Career Awareness Programs Across North Carolina
James Antle of the Washington Examiner documents one noticeable impact of Donald Trump’s White House term.
Gov. Roy Cooper has vetoed bipartisan legislation to reopen N.C. public schools statewide.
Tobias Hoonhout writes for National Review Online about the 45th president’s upcoming appearance ot a major conservative event.
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) on Wednesday released its analysis of Johnson & Johnson’s one-shot dose COVID-19 vaccine, supporting its authorization for emergency use.
It's the new command focus from Team Biden
Mental health experts who are also parents with students in Wake County Public Schools are sounding an alarm over a rising mental health crisis due to a lack of full-time classroom instruction.


The General Assembly is again considering a mild expansion of gun rights in this legislative session, a year after Gov. Roy Cooper vetoed a similar Second Amendment bill.
We will offer this allotment of three with more to come; some old, most new, but all quite informative, and, moreover, necessary to understanding that in North Carolina, there is a wiser path to govern ourselves and our People.
Today, Governor Roy Cooper announced two new judicial appointments, one to the North Carolina Superior Court and one to the North Carolina District Court.
Samuel Gregg writes for National Review Online about a philosophical divide that animates the fight over a proposal from U.S. Sen. Mitt Romney.
Today, Governor Roy Cooper vetoed the following bill: Senate Bill 37
Andrew McCarthy of National Review Online dissects misleading statements from the Biden administration’s nominee for U.S. attorney general.
Gov. Roy Cooper has signed into law House Bill 4, extending the delay on payment deadlines for the renewal of certain alcohol permits.


Back to Top