SCOTUS Leak Jeopardizes the Court’s Integrity | Beaufort County Now | Yesterday, Politico published a draft opinion for the U.S. Supreme Court in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, and today the court confirmed that the leaked document is genuine.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Jon Guze.

    Yesterday, Politico published a draft opinion for the U.S. Supreme Court in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, and today the court confirmed that the leaked document is genuine. The issue in Dobbs is the constitutionality of a 2018 Mississippi law banning most abortions after fifteen weeks. The draft opinion, which was written by Justice Alito and circulated to the other members of the court on 2/10/22, upholds the Mississippi law. More importantly, it does so by completely striking down Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey, the cases in which the Supreme Court had previously found a constitutional right to abortion.

    While there have been some unsettling leaks from within the Roberts court in the past, this breach is unprecedented as far as I know, and the legal world is in a state of shock. It is absolutely essential that the members of the court are able to discuss issues among themselves with candor and trust. If they can't do that with confidence, it will severely undermine the administration of justice and the rule of law.

    We don't yet know who leaked the draft, or why, but most commentators seem to think the culprit was probably a left-wing ideologue who hoped to provoke a show of force by the pro-choice coalition and intimidate some of the conservative justices into withdrawing their support for the draft opinion. If that explanation turns out to be correct, it will be yet another instance of something we're seeing far too much of these days: people putting their partisan and ideological commitments above the good of the country and its institutions. If that was indeed the strategy, it has already succeed in part. The Supreme Court is in lockdown and surrounded by angry protestors. If the strategy were to succeed in full-or even if it were merely to appear to succeed-it would further undermine the administration of justice and the rule of law. Using intimidation tactics to compel Supreme Court justices to modify their decisions is the stuff of banana republics.

    Regardless of who leaked the draft and why, it will be hard for the court to recover from this, and it won't recover at all unless Roberts can track down the source of the leak, ensure that everyone involved is severely punished, and take steps to stop the leaks once and for all. And that's assuming the leaker wasn't a justice or a clerk. If the leak occurred because of an ethical lapse by a member of that inner circle, then impeachment would certainly be in order, and God only knows what it will take to restore a semblance of trust and collegiality within the court.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

The N.C. Supreme Court has rejected a lawsuit challenging the Greenville red-light camera law as an unconstitutional local health act.
White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki refused to answer questions on Monday about matters related to President Joe Biden’s son, Hunter Biden, including a newly released book and his foreign investments.
Following the overturning of Roe v. Wade, Democrats nationwide have been accusing the Supreme Court of taking rights from "women." Onlookers have confirmed this to be confusing, as it seems to suggest that Democrats do in fact know what a woman is.
President Joe Biden will sign a “historic” executive order Wednesday ordering the Department of Health and Human Services to expand efforts to increase the ability of Americans (including children) who identify as transgender to obtain sex-change surgeries.
Two new N.C. Supreme Court decisions set a 40-year maximum prison sentence for violent juvenile offenders, regardless of the number or severity of their crimes.
Intentional destruction of the USA
Retired NBA legend Kareem Abdul-Jabbar slammed Los Angeles’ Lakers player LeBron James after James recently gloated over an opposing team by making an “obscene gesture,” saying that the truly greatest players of all time do not need to gloat.


A few days ago, as I was finishing shaving, my wife mentioned that she had an upset stomach. So I handed her 2 Tums and set the bottle down on the vanity counter facing our mirror.
The Federal Reserve announced Wednesday that it would hike interest rates by 0.75% — the boldest action since 1994.
The gun-rights group Grass Roots North Carolina criticizes U.S. Sen. Thom Tillis' "misguided approach" to a possible compromise federal gun bill.
Sen. Chris Murphy (D-CT) claimed on Sunday that Democrats have enough votes to enact a new crackdown on guns before admitting that they, in fact, do not have enough votes because of the filibuster.
According to a recently uncovered ancient diary, Biblical scholars now believe that we may now know the words Moses spoke after leading the Israelites out of Egypt and fleeing Ramses with his army.
'The Department of Justice is going easy on those who use violence in furtherance of favored viewpoints'
A woman who used to live in the same housing complex as the 15-year-old charged with killing four students with a handgun and injuring several others said she called Child Protective Services (CPS) on the family years earlier to warn them about potential neglect.


Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis on Wednesday responded to comments from tech billionaire Elon Musk — who revealed he was leaning toward supporting DeSantis in the 2024 presidential race — by saying he welcomes “support from African-Americans.”
Amid rumors that Pope Francis will soon abdicate the See of Peter, the Sacred College of Cardinals has pledged to choose a woman of color as the next pope.
Next pandemic and current covid shots
More than 900 employees of mortgage company were invited to a Zoom webinar last Wednesday, where CEO Vishal Garg announced they would all be fired effective immediately.
Billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk made it clear on Tuesday that he did not agree with the current administration officials — including President Joe Biden himself — who have claimed that a recession was “not inevitable.”
As ratings continue to fizzle for the January 6th hearings, Democrats are trying a new format to bring the committee's scandalous findings to a wider audience.


Back to Top